×
Uh-oh, it looks like your Internet Explorer is out of date.
For a better shopping experience, please upgrade now.

A Broken Dream: Rule of Law, Human Rights and Democracy
664
by Justice Surendra Kumar SinhaJustice Surendra Kumar Sinha
22.5
In Stock
Overview
Judiciary is an essential and integral part of a state, and its independence is a prerequisite of a liberal democratic state. Bangladesh, which emerged through a war of independence against the Pakistani in 1971, included democracy as one of the state principles in its constitution in 1972, and the constitution ensured the separation of judiciary from executive, and independence of the judiciary. I had the opportunity and honor to observe this transformation and the hindrances as a participant of the Bangladeshi judiciary since 1974 -- rising from a practitioner at a lower court in the north-eastern district of Sylhet to the highest judicial position of the country, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court. But, in 2017, after delivering a historic verdict in favor of the independence of judiciary, I was forced to resign and exiled by the current government.
The series of unfortunate and unprecedented events, which led to the tension between the executive and judiciary and subsequent improper action against me, began on September 17, 2014 when the Bangladesh Parliament amended the constitution to provide power of impeaching judges to the members of the parliament. The 16th Amendment of the Constitution deleted the provision of removing Judges from office through a highly powerful committee of peers called the Supreme Judicial Council (SJC). The SJC, as stipulated in the constitution, also allowed the accused to have self-defense. Most importantly, the process was meant to protect the judiciary from being subjected to political vagaries and serving political leaders than the citizens. On May 5, 2016, a special High Court bench declared the amendment illegal and unconstitutional. Soon after the verdict, the MPs blasted judges for nullifying their legislation and began displaying sheer disrespect to the judiciary. However, the state party opted for an appeal which was heard by a seven-member full appellate bench. It was incumbent on me to head the Bench. On July 3, 2017, the bench unanimously rejected the appeal upholding the High Court verdict. The complete text of the unanimous verdict, including the observations, were made public on August 1, 2018. Following the appellate decision, on September 13 the parliament passed a resolution calling for legal steps to nullify the Supreme Court verdict. Prime Minister and other members of her party and ministers blasted me for going against the parliament. Cabinet members including the Law Minister began smearing me alleging misconduct and corruption. While I remained confined at my official residence and lawyers and judges were prevented to visit me, media were told that I am unwell and have sought medical leave. Various ministers said I will go abroad on medical leave. On October 14, 2017, as I had to leave the country, I tried to clear the air in a public statement that I am neither unwell nor am I leaving the country for good. I was hoping that my physical absence combined with Court's regular vacation will allow the situation to calm down and good sense will prevail; that the government will understand that the essence of the Verdict - upholding the independence of judiciary - is beneficial to the nation and the state. Finally, in the face of intimidation and threats to my family and friends by the country's military intelligence agency called the Directorate General of the Defense Forces Intelligence (DGDFI), I submitted resignation from abroad.
This book comprises an introduction, highlighting my judicial life, experiences, challenges before the judiciary in Bangladesh, its struggle for independence, sanctity of the legal profession, erosion of values in judicial services, political interference and the state of nascent democracy.
The series of unfortunate and unprecedented events, which led to the tension between the executive and judiciary and subsequent improper action against me, began on September 17, 2014 when the Bangladesh Parliament amended the constitution to provide power of impeaching judges to the members of the parliament. The 16th Amendment of the Constitution deleted the provision of removing Judges from office through a highly powerful committee of peers called the Supreme Judicial Council (SJC). The SJC, as stipulated in the constitution, also allowed the accused to have self-defense. Most importantly, the process was meant to protect the judiciary from being subjected to political vagaries and serving political leaders than the citizens. On May 5, 2016, a special High Court bench declared the amendment illegal and unconstitutional. Soon after the verdict, the MPs blasted judges for nullifying their legislation and began displaying sheer disrespect to the judiciary. However, the state party opted for an appeal which was heard by a seven-member full appellate bench. It was incumbent on me to head the Bench. On July 3, 2017, the bench unanimously rejected the appeal upholding the High Court verdict. The complete text of the unanimous verdict, including the observations, were made public on August 1, 2018. Following the appellate decision, on September 13 the parliament passed a resolution calling for legal steps to nullify the Supreme Court verdict. Prime Minister and other members of her party and ministers blasted me for going against the parliament. Cabinet members including the Law Minister began smearing me alleging misconduct and corruption. While I remained confined at my official residence and lawyers and judges were prevented to visit me, media were told that I am unwell and have sought medical leave. Various ministers said I will go abroad on medical leave. On October 14, 2017, as I had to leave the country, I tried to clear the air in a public statement that I am neither unwell nor am I leaving the country for good. I was hoping that my physical absence combined with Court's regular vacation will allow the situation to calm down and good sense will prevail; that the government will understand that the essence of the Verdict - upholding the independence of judiciary - is beneficial to the nation and the state. Finally, in the face of intimidation and threats to my family and friends by the country's military intelligence agency called the Directorate General of the Defense Forces Intelligence (DGDFI), I submitted resignation from abroad.
This book comprises an introduction, highlighting my judicial life, experiences, challenges before the judiciary in Bangladesh, its struggle for independence, sanctity of the legal profession, erosion of values in judicial services, political interference and the state of nascent democracy.
Product Details
ISBN-13: | 9781727420937 |
---|---|
Publisher: | CreateSpace Publishing |
Publication date: | 09/26/2018 |
Pages: | 664 |
Product dimensions: | 6.00(w) x 9.00(h) x 1.33(d) |
Customer Reviews
Related Searches
Explore More Items
The Kingdom of Belgium is a parliamentary democracy with a limited constitutional monarchy. The country ...
The Kingdom of Belgium is a parliamentary democracy with a limited constitutional monarchy. The country
is a federal state with several levels of government: national; regional (Flanders, Wallonia, and Brussels); language community (Flemish, French, and German); provincial; and local. The ...
Emma Blair only fifteen and life was not treating her kindlyHer life fell to pieces ...
Emma Blair only fifteen and life was not treating her kindlyHer life fell to pieces
around her when her father died. Emma finding it hard to adjust to her mothers new lifestyle. She had to get away. A move interstate ...
This book is genuinely written for grasping the fundamental concept of chemistry. It is aimed ...
This book is genuinely written for grasping the fundamental concept of chemistry. It is aimed
to the secondary level students. It can serve as a reference for a particular topic. It is also useful for various competitions. This book deals ...
World War 2. Germany. Berlin. 1939. The war has begun in Germany, and Jewish civilians ...
World War 2. Germany. Berlin. 1939. The war has begun in Germany, and Jewish civilians
are massacred in the blood soaked streets of Berlin in large numbers by 'Einsatzgruppen', the Nazi killing squads, who stop at nothing to destroy their ...
government led by President Jose Mario Vaz and Prime Minister Baciro Dja of the African ...
government led by President Jose Mario Vaz and Prime Minister Baciro Dja of the African
Party for the Independence of Guinea and Cabo Verde (PAIGC). Vaz took office in 2014 after an election judged to be free and fair by ...
This document was developed by a Special Technical Committee of practitioners, technical experts and others ...
This document was developed by a Special Technical Committee of practitioners, technical experts and others
with experience in standards development and conformity assessment. Committee members, their organizations and their professional affiliations are listed in Table 1 and Table 2.
The most significant human rights abuses during the year were torture and abuse by security ...
The most significant human rights abuses during the year were torture and abuse by security
forces, harsh prison and detention center conditions, and limitations on freedom of movement for Palestinian and Syrian refugees.
This book is dedicated to the U.S. citizens who are aware and concerned about the ...
This book is dedicated to the U.S. citizens who are aware and concerned about the
many illegal, immoral and counterproductive acts of our government, which have caused our decline into less Peace, Liberty, Prosperity, and Justice in the USA. We ...