By Cook or by Crook (Five-Ingredient Mystery Series #1)

By Cook or by Crook (Five-Ingredient Mystery Series #1)

by Maya Corrigan

Paperback(Mass Market Paperback)

View All Available Formats & Editions
Use Standard Shipping. For guaranteed delivery by December 24, use Express or Expedited Shipping.

Product Details

ISBN-13: 9781617731389
Publisher: Kensington
Publication date: 11/04/2014
Series: Five-Ingredient Mystery Series , #1
Pages: 320
Sales rank: 238,509
Product dimensions: 4.10(w) x 6.70(h) x 0.90(d)
Age Range: 18 Years

About the Author

Maya Corrigan lives near Washington, D.C., within easy driving distance of Maryland's Eastern Shore, the setting for this series. She has taught courses in writing, detective fiction, and American literature at Georgetown University and NOVA community college. A winner of the Daphne du Maurier Award for Excellence in Mystery and Suspense, she has published essays on drama and short stories under her full name of Mary Ann Corrigan. Visit her at

Read an Excerpt

By Cook or By Crook

By Maya Corrigan


Copyright © 2014 Mary Ann Corrigan
All rights reserved.
ISBN: 978-1-61773-139-6


Val Deniston waved good night to her last customers, relieved that they'd ignored the elephant in the Cool Down Café. No one had rehashed Monique's rant about her husband's affair with Nadia. Maybe they'd tired of the topic after three days or avoided it with Nadia around. Though thankful that Monique hadn't shown up tonight, Val worried that her cousin had spent the evening alone, plotting how to get back at Nadia.

Exercise music from the workout room drifted into the athletic club café and set a quick pace for Val's cleanup. She poured a pot of coffee down the drain, taking a last whiff of the aroma that masked the scent of sweat. Not many takers for coffee tonight. After two hours on the tennis courts, the crowd had thirsted for juice and smoothies, not lattes.

The music cut off, and a gruff voice came through the speakers. "The Bayport Racket and Fitness Club will close at nine-thirty. Please finish your workout promptly."

As Val wiped down the eating bar, the exercise junkies who'd stayed until closing time on a Sunday night filed past the café toward the exit. A petite woman in a white tennis dress bucked the flow and rushed back into the club. Nadia Westrin carried an athletic bag large enough for three rackets, a change of clothes, and a Thanksgiving turkey.

"Thank goodness you're still here, Val." Nadia dropped her sports bag near the eating bar. Under the hanging lights, her frosted brown hair with gray roots resembled a desert camouflage helmet. "My car won't start. Can you give me a lift home?"

Val hesitated. Since the night of her accident this past winter, she'd allowed no one to ride with her after dark. Time to get over that. The country road from the club to town posed no driving hazards. Though Val didn't want to do any favors for her cousin's enemy, refusing to give Nadia a ride smacked of schoolyard tit-for-tat. "Of course. Give me a minute to finish here."

"I'm glad you agreed to play in our mixed doubles group and open the café for us." Nadia watched Val stack biscotti studded with pistachios and currants in a glass jar. "The last café manager sold everything in cellophane like a vending machine. Your fresh food is way better."

"Thanks." Val waited for the dig that would surely follow the compliment.

"Isn't the café a comedown for you, though? After doing publicity for New York chefs?"

Val clenched her teeth. Over the last few months, she'd adjusted to living in a Chesapeake Bay town, but reminders of her shattered career still rankled. "I publicized other people's cookbooks for ten years. Now I have a job that lets me try out recipes for my own book." Recipes the average person could make in less time than it took to watch a TV cooking show.

"When the tennis teams finish the season in July, we always throw a big catered party." Nadia leaned toward Val like a conspirator. "I can talk the club manager into letting you cater. It's four weeks away, but I'll need menu options and prices pretty soon."

Val perked up as if a shot of espresso had hit her veins. One catering gig could lead to another and plump up her résumé. "I'd love to do it. When do you want to talk about it?"

"Stop by my house Tuesday morning before you open the café. I get up early. Let's make it seven o'clock."

The day after tomorrow. Not much time to work on the menus. "Okay, and thanks for the chance to cater the party."

"We always funnel business to each other here at the club. I hope that when your grandfather's ready to sell his house, you'll reciprocate and give me the listing."

Ah. The sales commission on Granddad's huge house would dwarf whatever Val earned from catering the club party. Nadia's idea of a fair trade—her lentils for your caviar.

Fifteen minutes later, Val steered her Saturn off a narrow tree-canopied road and onto Nadia's street at the outskirts of town. "Let me know when we get to your house. I'm not sure I'll recognize it in the dark."

"I appreciate the ride. I'm glad your cousin hasn't turned you against me."

Val felt her blood pressure rise. "Don't start knocking Monique. I won't—"

A black-clad figure darted into the car's headlights.

Val swerved. She slammed on the brakes and clutched the wheel in a death grip. A memory flared of an icy highway, the car skidding and hurtling toward leafless trees.

The tires grabbed the road, and she snapped back from the past. Breath whooshed from her lungs, a mix of relief and frustration. No crash this time, no blood spattered on her. But the elusive memory of the accident last winter had vanished, leaving behind a single frame when she needed the whole reel.

Nadia smacked the dashboard. "What an idiot. Who jogs at night dressed in black? If you'd hit the guy, it wouldn't have been your fault."

No fault didn't mean no guilt. Val started the stalled car. "How far to your house?"

"Just past the bend."

Val took the curve slowly, still shaky from her near miss. Pinpoints of light came from houses set back from the road. An eerie glow flickered through the bushes. Flames? "It looks like someone built a campfire up ahead."

Nadia peered through the windshield and squawked, "That's my place."

Val stopped across the street from Nadia's driveway. They both dashed from the car toward the fire.

The flames came from a makeshift torch, a wad of white fabric tied to a wood shaft like a giant onion on a two-foot skewer. The odor of charcoal lighter fluid hung in the still air. Val circled the torch planted in a bed of river rock near the driveway. No trees or shrubs nearby. It would take a gale force wind off the Chesapeake to spread the fire. Tonight, though, a shroud of humid air hung over Maryland's Eastern Shore. This fire would die in place.

The light from it tinged Nadia's ashen complexion orange and emphasized the frown lines in her forehead. "Who put that here? What is that thing anyway? Why—?" Her voice broke on a helium high note.

The outer layers of cloth disintegrated and the inner ones sprouted holes. The shape under the cloth became visible—oval and flat like the head of a tennis racket.

Val gasped. "A wood racket?" She'd occasionally seen one of those at a garage sale, but never on a tennis court or on fire.

Muffled pops came from the head of the torch, strings snapping from the heat.

The burning racket would make an awesome kickoff for a surprise party. Too bad no one was jumping out of the bushes, singing "Happy Birthday."

Nadia thrust her shoulders back, her posture ramrod. "Your cousin did this. She's harassed me for the last three days."

Val's jaw clenched. A few seconds ago, she'd felt her first ever twinges of sympathy for Nadia. Not anymore. "You have no way to know if Monique—"

"She turned everyone against me. Blew off a team match. Now look what she's done."

Val waved away the torch smoke and the accusation. "Let's put the fire out. Where's your hose?"

Nadia flicked her wrist toward her white Cape Cod. "Hanging near the back porch."

Val turned on her key ring flashlight, headed toward the clapboard house, and unwound the hose.

She tugged it toward the fire. "Good thing you hitched a ride with me and not Althea." The flaming racket would remind the tennis team's only black player of Klan cross-burnings.

Nadia put her palms together. "Amen to that."

A car door slammed and someone bounded up the driveway. Luke Forsa entered the circle of light made by the fire. "Hey, Nadia, what's with the torch? You having a luau?" Her silence must have told him his joke had fallen flat. "I was driving by and saw the fire. You need any help dousing it?"

"Val's got the hose. We can handle it."

Luke sidled up to Val. "Whaddya know? Meeting an old flame over a fire."

Val nearly dropped the hose, surprised that he remembered those kisses and fumbles after nearly two decades. Back then, his success at poker and hooking up had earned him the name Lucky Luke. Now the dashing rebel of her teen fantasies manned the grill at his mom's diner.

Luke's gaze lingered on Val's thighs, where her tennis shorts ended. The guy still hoped to get lucky. She looked down. Did torchlit legs, like candlelit faces, have a romantic glow? Not that she could see. Val gave one last tug to the hose, aimed the nozzle at the torch, and squeezed the handle. Luke jumped back from the water ricocheting off the rocks. So much for old flames.

She soaked the racket thoroughly and turned the flashlight on the charred frame. Bits of singed cloth clung to it.

"Racket flambé. Yum." Luke stepped toward Nadia. "You should have given your racket a decent burial instead of cremating it."

"It's not mine." Nadia glared at him. "How old do you think I am? Wood rackets were passé long before I took up tennis."

Luke pulled the charred racket out of the ground. Either it had cooled down, or he had asbestos hands. The racket's handle, bare of grip tape, was whittled to a point. "Lot of work, turning this into a stake and getting it to burn."

"Right on schedule too. I always play mixed doubles on Sunday and hang around the club until closing time." Nadia waggled her index finger at Val. "That jogger I took for a man could have been a tall woman. She wore a hoodie so I wouldn't recognize her."

The flashlight wavered in Val's hand. Monique, the tall woman Nadia meant, could have waited near Nadia's house for an approaching car, set the fire, and fled in a face-hiding hoodie. But so could anyone who'd played tennis tonight, or even one of Nadia's neighbors.

Val didn't want Luke, or anybody else, to hear wild charges against her cousin. "Would you get Nadia's sports bag from my car? It's parked across the street."

"You bet." He jogged down the driveway.

"Are you going to report this to police?" Val held her breath, waiting for Nadia's answer.

"I don't need the police to tell me who did this."

Val exhaled. Nadia could make accusations, but no one would believe them without evidence to back them up.

The bushes on the far side of Nadia's driveway rustled. A sixtyish woman in a black caftan emerged from them.

Tall and erect, she held a portable lantern in her upraised hand. "I saw a fire from our window. Is everything okay?" Nadia's neighbor, Irene Pritchard, made an imposing figure.

Nadia looked tiny next to her. "Everything's fine now. The fire's out."

Val stepped back from the lantern's beam. She felt uncomfortable around Irene, her former rival for the café manager job.

Irene lowered her lantern toward the charred racket. "What on earth? That's a nasty thing."

Luke joined them, gave Nadia her sports bag, and pointed to the racket on the ground. "You want me to junk that?"

Nadia picked it up. "I'll take care of it. Y'all keep a lid on this, okay?"

She held the racket away from her tennis whites and marched toward the house with Irene lighting the way. Dramatic exit. A crescendo from the cicadas in the trees sounded like applause.

Val aimed the blue beam of her LED flashlight at the driveway.

Luke fell into step beside her, gravel crunching under his feet. "You're still in Bayport, huh? I heard you came here just to coax your grandpa to sell his house."

"That's what Mom wanted." But not Granddad. Easier for Val to side with him while living in his house than with her mother a thousand miles away in Florida. "The house needs work before it goes on the market. I don't have the time to spend on it, now that I'm running the café at the club."

"And competing against my diner." He nudged her with his elbow.

"No competition. You have a different clientele."

"I'll say. My customers would never burn sports equipment. What do you make of that flaming racket?"

"An ugly practical joke?" Or an act of revenge.

Val swiped at a mosquito whining near her ear as Luke aimed his remote at a black BMW. Fancy car. He must have made money before moving back home to rescue his mom's diner, a doomed business if Val ever saw one. But what small business in a small town wasn't doomed? Granddad had kissed good-bye to his fish market and his video store.

"Drop by the diner sometime with your grandpa. He used to eat with us everyday, him and his buddies, sometimes all three meals."

Three meals of cholesterol, salt, and empty calories, the diner's staples. At least Val could check off one item on her mother's agenda: a healthier diet for Granddad.

Back in her car, she grabbed her cell phone, punched the first three digits of Monique's number, and stopped. What would she say if her cousin admitted burning the racket? What would she say if Nadia asked whether Monique had done it? If Val didn't know the answer, she wouldn't have to lie or betray her cousin. The best strategy for flaming rackets: don't ask so you can't tell.

She clicked the phone off and drove home—or what passed for home temporarily—a gabled and turreted Victorian that looked like an eyesore by day and a haunted house by night. Her grandfather's big Buick sat as usual on the street. He'd hit the mailbox backing out of the driveway so often that he happily ceded the driveway to Val's much-used Saturn.

She let herself into the house by the side door sandwiched between the dining room and the sitting room. She found her grandfather ensconced in a recliner by the sitting room window. A scene from Hitchcock's Vertigo, one of his favorites, played on the flat-screen TV near the tiled fireplace. The ear hooks of his bifocals nestled in tufts of white curls that fringed his balding head.

He pressed the pause button on his remote. "Humidity must be bad. Your hair's wilder than usual."

She ran her fingers through the unruly, cinnamon-colored locks she inherited from him. Eventually her curls would turn ivory like his. She pointed to a plate with telltale crumbs on the end table. "I see my apple crisp was a hit."

"A base hit, not a home run. Your grandmother always topped it with whipped cream."

Val glanced at the mahogany table in the dining room where Grandma had served so many family meals. Cream, butter, and red meat, Grandma's favorite foods, had nudged her toward a heart attack six years ago. Val knew enough not to say that to her grandfather. He'd reply that at least Grandma had enjoyed life, and Val couldn't argue with that.

She sank onto the oatmeal tweed sofa near his chair. Its cushions enveloped her like a hug from a long-lost and slightly seedy friend. "An amazing thing happened tonight on my way home." Even more amazing than a burning racket.

Granddad wiped the lenses of his glasses on the hem of his polo shirt. "I'm glad someone had an exciting evening."

Whenever he channeled Eeyore, she pretended not to hear. "I had to stop short to avoid a jogger. Hitting the brakes hard brought back a memory. I did the same thing that night in January. Maybe the rest will come back too."

"Dwelling on the past won't change it." Granddad gestured toward the agitated Jimmy Stewart on the TV screen. "There's a man destroyed by his memories."

Val picked at loose threads on the sofa arm. "I just want to know what happened. I need the truth."

"You store a lot in your noggin. Recipe ingredients, movie plots, bits of trivia. They pop out when you need them. That night you had a concussion. It's not your fault you can't remember."

"I know." But the accident might have been her fault. With no memory of what led to it, Val didn't know if her anger had turned destructive. Could she have crashed the car deliberately, as the man riding with her claimed? That night had tested her character. After five months she still didn't know if she'd passed or failed.

"Take my advice, Val, and let it go." Granddad squeezed her hand. "How was your game tonight? Did they pair you with a geezer again?"

The change of subject brought Val out of her funk. "This time I had a younger partner, in his thirties. He works in D.C. and is looking for a weekend place. Gunnar Swensen."


"Possibly, but mixed with Latin blood. Thick dark hair, bluish eyes." Plus rugged features and a crooked nose. But a megawatt smile transformed his face from almost a train wreck to almost attractive. "He's pretty buff for someone who works in an office. His tennis isn't bad, and he wants to play me in singles."

Granddad's eyebrows rose, furry white squiggles in his forehead. "Gonna whup him?"

"Gonna try. Tennis gives a short player like me a fighting chance against a taller, stronger one. That's why I like it."

"Losing to a small woman—that'll test his mettle." Granddad laughed.

"Tony couldn't handle it." Her ex-fiancé used to sulk whenever he lost to her.


Excerpted from By Cook or By Crook by Maya Corrigan. Copyright © 2014 Mary Ann Corrigan. Excerpted by permission of KENSINGTON PUBLISHING CORP..
All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher.
Excerpts are provided by Dial-A-Book Inc. solely for the personal use of visitors to this web site.

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

See All Customer Reviews

By Cook or by Crook 3.9 out of 5 based on 0 ratings. 9 reviews.
pandabear3 More than 1 year ago
Very enjoyable book. I liked everything about it - the characters, the romance, the setting and the mystery. Can't wait for the next one.
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Interesting start to new series.
Dollycas More than 1 year ago
Dollycas’s Thoughts The number 5 is the key here. 5 ingredient recipes 5 suspects 5 key clues Maya Corrigan is off to an excellent start with this mystery! Val Deniston is a great character with a tragic past. She is trying to get on with her life but is haunted with nightmares of the night when a car accident changed her life. She thought coming to Bayport would make things easier but a recent murder that has her best friend pegged at the prime suspect has her remembering that fateful night again and again as she tries to find the real killer. I love the relationship Val has with her grandfather. She thinks he needs her there to take care of him and he does to a certain point but that man has more going on than she gives him credit for. He even turns the table on her and it was so much fun to read. Brought back a few memories of my own grandfather. The other characters were great too. I think everyone in town has a secret and Val considered them all suspects at one time or another, even the one whose kisses gave her that warm and tingly feeling. The reason for this is a masterfully plotted mystery. There were several red herrings in this mystery’s recipe and they all needed to be sifted through to find the real killer and I figured it out just as Val did. Isn’t that what we readers want? The author has served up a wonderful story with more than mystery to solve, a pinch of romance and a morsel of humor. It also contains a huge “hang on to your seat” moment that had my heart pumping. I am truly excited for the next book in this series. I think the author has just given a tidbit of what she can dish up. “What are the chances of another murder in a peaceful small town?” We shall have to wait and see…
lauralovesreviewingLT More than 1 year ago
Maya mixed up a fun new cozy mystery. With tennis, vying for manager of the Cool Down Cafe, and trying to sell real estate, there are some pretty serious competitions going on in this book. That’s what makes this such a fun mystery. When one of the woman from the local tennis club is found murdered, there’s also an unsolved hit-and -run, and some arson going on and it may all tie together, or not. I bet Val didn’t expect to be helping the police with a murder when she left New York City behind to move in with her grumpy grandfather in the small town of Bayport in Chesapeake Bay. Managing the cafe and playing on the local tennis team, Val quickly gets to know a lot of the people in this small town. And like most small towns, it’s hard to keep a secret and the gossip is rampant. Val is drawn into the murder investigation when she discovers the body of a fellow tennis player. And the number one suspect is her cousin. Not wanting to believe her capable of murder, Val starts her own investigation, but being a stickler, she doesn’t scratch her cousin off the list of suspects. And that list is long. As Val’s suspect list shrinks, the danger escalates. She’s being stalked and someone ran her off the road. She’s getting close, but to which case. The hit-and-run, the arson, the murder, or all three? The author had me going in circles trying to figure out who the killer was. It wasn’t obvious. There were lots of false trails. And I didn’t have a clue until about two thirds of the way through the book. There was still a ways to go so I knew things could change and have me suspecting someone else, so I paid close attention, sniffing for clues. This cozy mystery had a lot to offer. Several mysteries, lots of colorful characters, danger, and romance. Val and Gunnar are flirting with a burgeoning romance. This wasn’t the main focus in the mystery, just a dollop of whipped cream to add zest, and it’s early in the romance stage. Val has her own personal mystery to solve too. Her memory of the car crash that ended her budding career in New York is still not clear. Did she cause the crash or was it an accident? Lots of questions and the author gave me the answers bit by bit. There was no rush to wrap this up, and the ending left me happy and eager for more.
KristinSchadler More than 1 year ago
It took me longer to read this story as there seemed to be a lot of side stories that I had to keep straight. That being said, I really enjoyed the book.
Carstairs38 More than 1 year ago
Five Things You Need to Know About the First Five Ingredients Mystery I was quite intrigued by the idea behind the Five Ingredients Mysteries. Each book will have five suspects and five clues that helped the main character solve the case. I had to see how that would work out in a novel, so I picked up By Cook or by Crook, the first in the series. And here is what I thought of the book in five points for you. 1 – Story Teaser: Val Deniston has fled NYC and moved to the town of Bayport, Maryland, on the Chesapeake. She’s living with her grandfather and running the café at the local athletic club where she also plays tennis. There’s she’s met Nadia, a realtor and fellow tennis player, who wants to help Val getting a catering gig in exchange for sending realty referrals to Nadia. But when Val arrives for the meeting, she finds Nadia dead – stabbed by a wooden tennis racket that’s been whittled down to a stake. The police are focusing on Val’s cousin, so Val dives in to find the killer. Can she do it? 2 – Plot: I must admit that I was a bit worried that having five clues and five suspects might make for a repetitive story as Val would spend the book rehashing things to fill pages. That wasn’t the case at all. Instead, this was a fast paced story that moved from suspect to suspect and clue to clue, constantly keeping me guessing what was really happening. The way things came together at the end was brilliant; the clues were all there, but they weren’t easy to figure out. The climax was wonderful and tied everything up well. 3 – Characters: Unfortunately, the characters took me a bit to warm up to. The book is narrated third person from Val’s limited point of view, and for some reason, that kept me a bit out of the story. As I kept reading, I did feel I got to know the characters and warm up to them. It also didn’t help that we got some back story dump in the first couple of chapters. Again, the more I read, the more I grew to like the characters, and I am looking forward to getting to know them better in future books. 4 – Recipes Of course, being a culinary cozy, there have to be recipes. We get 8 of them, for such various things as crab cakes, potatoes, apple crisp to name a few. And - you guessed it - all of them have only five ingredients. Well, one of two of them cheat with a couple of options spices, but we won’t mention that. They do sound delicious and super easy, which is nice. 5 – The 5 Gimmick As I hinted at before, I didn’t find the gimmick of five suspects and five clues to be an issue at all. Despite being a numbers guy (I’m an accountant in my day job), I wouldn’t have known if the characters had discussed it in these terms a few times. It’s fun, but it never gets in the way of telling a compelling mystery. So, as you can see, there are lots of reasons to read By Cook or by Crook. The mystery is strong and the characters grow on you. I hope this series goes for 5 times 5 books.
SewWrite More than 1 year ago
This book is a great start to a new mystery series. Val Deniston has moved from the hustle and bustle of New York City and the car accident that ruined her career to what she expected to be a quieter life in the small tourist town of Bayport. Unfortunately one of the women on her tennis team is murdered and Val’s cousin Monique looks like the prime suspect. Val can’t let Monique be arrested for a crime she is sure Monique didn’t commit. I loved the depth of the characters, especially Val’s Gradfather. All of the people that inhabit this book have multiple layers and it was a great time meeting them all and watching them change and evolve as the book page flew past much too quickly.
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
I got as far as page 49 before I had to stop. This book is terrible. The dialogue is awkward and simplistic. The characters are flat and unappealing. I figured out who the murderer was as soon as the main character discovered the body. I skimmed the last chapter just to see if I had correctly identified the killer. I had. I'd also correctly guessed cliched details about some of the characters as well as some poorly done red herrings. Don't waste your time and money on this lousy cozy.