Dagne Lonegan, aka Dear Philomena, advice columnist hoped that spending a year on the Eastern Shore island of Chincoteague would extinguish any feelings she had left for Jack Andrews, erstwhile lover and long-time jerk. It's just her luck that in her first week on the island she's entangled in a murder. Only she doesn't know it. Unfortunately, the murderer doesn't know she doesn't know. Strange and dangerous things begin happening to her, disrupting her new romance with Aidan Ellis, the handsome manager of the National Wildlife Refuse. As if that weren't enough, Jack arrives to take charge of the murder investigation.
Will Dagne stick with the tall, cool glass of Ranger or risk falling back into the arms of the man who broke her heart?