From the gritty streets of nineteenth century London, the loyal and courageous Dr. Watson offers a tale unearthed after generations of lore: the harrowing story of Sherlock Holmes’s attempt to hunt down Jack the Ripper.
As England’s greatest specialist in criminal detection, Sherlock Holmes is unwavering in his quest to capture the killer responsible for terrifying London’s East End. He hires an “unfortunate” known as Mary Ann Monk, the friend of a fellow streetwalker who was one of the Ripper’s earliest victims; and he relies heavily on the steadfast and devoted Dr. John H. Watson. When Holmes himself is wounded in Whitechapel during an attempt to catch the savage monster, the popular press launches an investigation of its own, questioning the great detective’s role in the very crimes he is so fervently struggling to prevent. Stripped of his credibility, Holmes is left with no choice but to break every rule in the desperate race to find the madman known as “the Knife” before it is too late.
A masterly re-creation of history’s most diabolical villain, Lyndsay Faye’s debut brings unparalleled authenticity to the atmosphere of Whitechapel and London in the fledgling days of tabloid journalism and recalls the ideals evinced by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s most beloved and world-renowned characters. Jack the Ripper’s identity, still hotly debated around the world more than a century after his crimes were committed, remains a mystery ripe for speculation. Dust and Shadow explores the terrifying prospect of tracking a serial killer without the advantage of modern forensics, and the result is a lightning-paced novel brimming with historical detail that will keep you on the edge of your seat.
|Publisher:||Simon & Schuster|
|Product dimensions:||8.40(w) x 5.56(h) x 0.80(d)|
About the Author
Lyndsay Faye is a writer and actress who lives in New York with her husband and cat.
Read an Excerpt
It has been argued by those who have so far flattered my attempts to chronicle the life and career of Mr. Sherlock Holmesas to approach them in a scholarly manner that I have often been remiss in the arena of precise chronology. While nodding to kindly meant excuses made for me in regards to hasty handwriting or careless literary agents, I must begin by confessing that my errors, however egregious, were entirely intentional. Holmes' s insistence, not to mention my own natural discretion, often prevented me from maintaining that exactitude so highly prized in a biographer; I have been forced to change the dates of marginal cases to disguise great ones, alter names and circumstances, all the while diligently preserving the core truth of the events, without which there would have been no object in writing anything at all. In this instance, however, any obfuscation would be absurd, as the facts are known not only to the people of London but to the world. I shall therefore set down the entire truth, as it happened to Holmesand to myself, omitting nothing that pertains to the most harrowing series of crimes my illustrious friend and I were ever called upon to solve.
The year of 1888 had already proven significant for Mr. Sherlock Holmes, for it was in that twelvemonth that he performed valuable services for one of the reigning houses of Europe and continued forestalling the activities of Professor James Moriarty, whose hold over London's underworld grew ever more apparent to my friend. Several highly publicized investigations that year displayed Holmes' s remarkable skills to the public, including the appalling affair of the faulty oil lamp, and the matter of Mrs. Victoria Mendosa's mysteriously vanishing thimble and its consequences. My friend's talents, which had once languished in obscure specialism, in that year flamed into the most gratifying notoriety.
Despite the busyness that accompanied Holmes's ever-increasing reputation for omniscience, we found ourselves at home on that evening in early August, the day after Bank Holiday, Holmesperforming chemical analyses of an American snake venom which had recently proven itself a nearly untraceable poison, and I engaged in a perusal of the day's papers. To my delight, the skies above the buildings burned with that most elusive of all elements, the London sun, and a brisk breeze fluttered about the windows (one of which I'd opened as a safeguard against Holmes' s chemical efforts), when an item in the late edition of the Star caught my eye.
"I cannot begin to understand," I said to no one in particular, "what could drive a murderer to such total desecration of the human body."
Holmes, without looking up from his work, remarked, "An argument could be made that the ultimate desecration of the human body is to end its earthly usefulness, which would imply that all murderers share equally that specific charge."
"This is rather beyond the pale. It states here that some poor woman, as yet unidentified, was found stabbed to death in Whitechapel."
"A deplorable, though hardly baffling occurrence. I imagine that she worked the area for food, drink, and daily shelter. Such pitiable unfortunates are particularly likely to inspire crimes of passion in the men with whom they associate."
"She was stabbed twenty times, Holmes."
"And your unassailable medical assessment is that once would have been enough."
"Well, yes," I faltered. "Apparently the villain continued to slash at her long after she was dead, or so the pattern of blood indicates."
The detective smiled. "You are a gentleman of the most sympathetic character, my dear Watson. While you would possibly for I have seen you do it condone a crime of passion committed in the throes of despair or of vengeance, you can see nothing permissible about such morbid abuse."
"I suppose that expresses it."
"I confess I cannot imagine myself in such a rage as to batter my victim beyond all sense either," he admitted. "Is there anything further?"
"The police know nothing yet."
Holmes sighed and pushed aside his scientific materials. "Would you and I had the power to make all of London safe, my good man, but for the moment, let us leave our musings upon the depths to which our fellow citizens can sink and instead explore whether or not we have time to make a seven-thirty curtain for Brahms's Symphony No. 4 in E Minor at the Royal Albert Hall. My attention was directed to the second-chair cellist by my brother Mycroft, and I should be grateful for your company while I observe the gentleman in his natural habitat."
It took Sherlock Holmesexactly five days to complete the affair of the second cellist, and once concluded, my friend had the thanks of the premier branches of the British government, of which his brother Mycroft was a pivotal member. My own knowledge of Mycroft Holmes' s exalted occupation was at that time a closely kept secret, for he occasionally engaged his brother upon nationally vital inquiries about which neither Sherlock Holmes nor I ought to have had the slightest inkling. I regret to say, however, that when nothing but the most pedestrian of wrongdoing took place in the following weeks, my friend lapsed into that melancholy torpor which made my own life, not to mention that of our landlady, Mrs. Hudson, taxing in the extreme. Holmesever maintained the opinion that we should abandon him entirely when such a fit was upon him, but as a medical man, I dreaded the sight of his tiny, impeccably kept hypodermic syringe and that momentous stop at the chemist's which promised that my friend would commence to ruin himself for a matter of days or weeks if I did not take any steps to circumvent him. In vain I scanned the papers, and in vain I attempted to convince Holmesthat a woman ought not to be stabbed so very many times, Whitechapel or no. At length I found myself longing, fleetingly and against the dictates of my conscience, for the advent of some sensational misfortune.
I rose early that fateful Saturday, the morning of September the first, and as I sat smoking a pipe after breakfast, Holmes strode into the sitting room, fully dressed and in the process of reading the Daily News. The warmth of his pale complexion announced he had been out, and I noted with relief that his keen gaze betrayed no glimmer of the drug I had come to despise. His chiseled brow furrowed in concentration, he laid the open paper on our dining table and within moments had opened seven or eight other editions to which we subscribed, quickly locating the same story in each and then draping the paper over an article of furniture.
"Good morning, Holmes," I remarked, just as our sitting room seemed in danger of disappearing under the crackling storm of newsprint.
"I've been out," he replied.
"Yes," I returned dryly.
"I hope you have already broken your fast this morning, Watson."
"Whatever do you mean?"
"It appears that the defilement of corpses is a growing industry in Whitechapel. They've found another one, my dear fellow. Abdomen apparently slashed after she was murdered."
"What was the cause of death, then?"
"Her neck was nearly severed."
"Good heavens. Where was she found?"
"In Buck's Row, it seems, which arrested my interest immediately. I imagined the other matter a bizarre aberration, but here is another on its heels."
"The first was bad enough."
"That girl's name was Martha Tabram, and the early report had it wrong: she was stabbed a grand total of thirty-nine times," he stated dispassionately. "Yesterday morning's victim, whose name was apparently Mary Ann Nichols, by all accounts was partially eviscerated."
"Dare I hope you shall look into the matter?" I asked.
"It is hardly within my purview to do so when no one has consul "
At that moment, Mrs. Hudson entered and surveyed our newly adorned furnishings with silent cynicism. Our landlady was not in the best of spirits, for Holmes in his devil-may-care humour had used the berry spoon to dissolve chemical elements over his burner, and the disagreement this activity had caused had not yet resolved itself to her satisfaction.
"Gentlemen to see you," she said from the doorway. "Inspector Lestrade and one other. Will you be requiring aught from my cupboards, Mr. Holmes, or have you everything you need?"
"Ha!" Holmes exclaimed. "Lestrade occasionally evinces the most impeccable timing. Indeed no, Mrs. Hudson, I've sufficient cutlery for my purposes. I shall ring if I want anything in the way of a pickle fork. Do show up the inspector, if you will."
With studied dignity, Mrs. Hudson exited. A few moments later Inspector Lestrade and an associate entered the room. Holmesoften had occasion to bemoan the intellect of our hatchet-visaged friend, the lean and dapper little inspector, but Lestrade's diligence commanded our respect even when his utter lack of imagination strained the independent investigator's nerves. On this occasion, Lestrade looked as rumpled and anxious as I had ever seen him. His companion was dressed in dark tweeds, his beard modestly trimmed beneath a more impressive moustache; he had a pale, retiring aspect, and his eyes darted shyly between Holmesand myself.
My friend took them in at a glance. "How are you, Lestrade? We should be delighted to offer you both coffee, or something stronger if required. I am pleased to make your acquaintance, Doctor...?"
"Llewellyn. At your service, sir," our visitor replied with evident disquiet.
"Dr. Llewellyn, I assure you I am at yours. You will excuse my use of your prefix you have recently sustained some slight injury to your right hand, and the way in which the dressing is fastened leads me to believe it was secured entirely by the aid of your own left appendage. And yet, the cloth is not of a variety to be found outside a medical facility. I should be shocked to learn our local surgeons have grown so slovenly as to require a gentleman to secure his own bandages."
"You are correct on all counts, sir how very extraordinary."
Holmes nodded briefly. "This is my friend and colleague Dr. Watson."
"I am glad to meet you. I am glad to meet anyone willing to get to the bottom of this horrid affair."
Holmes waved Lestrade and our nervous new acquaintance to their seats, the backs of the furnishings still entirely wreathed with newsprint. My friend then threw himself into his own armchair.
"You are here about Buck's Row, I imagine," he remarked. "You were knocked up yesterday, Dr. Llewellyn?"
"My surgery is at one fifty-two Whitechapel Road, some few minutes' distance," he acknowledged. "I was summoned at slightly before four yesterday morning. I completed a postmortem examination just now."
"One moment, if you please. Lestrade, while I am delighted to see you, as ever, why in God's name have you waited an entire day to consult me?"
"I've only just been reassigned two hours ago!" Lestrade protested. "Inspector Spratling began it, then Helson. I wasted no time in bringing Dr. Llewellyn round."
"My abject apologies, Inspector." Holmessmiled. "Your haste was not lax; it was unprecedented."
"No more unprecedented than the corpse. If you had seen what I did at the morgue this morning, what Dr. Llewellyn here saw yesterday..." Lestrade shook his head. "Your methods may be unconventional, but we need an end to this case as quick as is possible. There's something about it that's very queer, Mr. Holmes, and correct me if I've the wrong end of the stick, but that's where you tend to come in."
Holmes settled back in his chair, half closing his eyes. "Very well, then. The story, as it happened to you, Dr. Llewellyn."
"Well, Mr. Holmes," Dr. Llewellyn began hesitantly, "as I have said, I hold a medical practice in Whitechapel Road which I obtained after I finished my studies at the University of London. That main thoroughfare is quite respectable, and to a great extent, the same ailments parade across my consulting room from day to day influenza, rheumatism, agues the most peaceful of maladies. However, living in London's East-end as I do, I occasionally find my work to be of a more unsettling nature. A regular patient of mine once burst into my offices with a nasty knife wound, as he'd forgotten himself and wandered into a corner where some roughs thought his pocketbook worth trying for. I suppose that the immediate proximity of the slums would be all too obvious if I ever had cause to treat any of my poorest neighbours, but I fear they haven't the means. In the case of disease, they consult quack street doctors for penny compendia of gin or of laudanum. And in the case of injury, as their wounds were often got through misadventure, many deem it safer to suffer in anonymity than to risk dealing with police.
"That terrible murder in George Yard Buildings three weeks ago left a strong impression on my mind. We all were shocked by the ferocity of it. I cannot convey to you my horror at what I was called upon to witness yesterday."
Holmes held up a cautionary hand. "Please," said he, "everything just as you saw it."
"Buck's Row is one of those sordid pitch-black byways of which Whitechapel boasts so many once the main road is abandoned. The body was situated at the entrance to a stable yard beneath a decrepit gateway. I saw nothing out of the ordinary save the body, but the inspector may have more to say on that subject."
"I wish I did," sighed Lestrade. "As you say, the body was the only thing out of the ordinary, as it were."
"And the body?" prompted Holmes.
"Something over thirty years of age," said Dr. Llewellyn, mopping his brow with a handkerchief. "She had brown hair and was missing several of her front teeth, but that characteristic did not seem to be a recent development. Nearly all of her was still warm, save her extremities. Her throat was savagely slashed two times. She may as well have been decapitated. Apart from her throat, I found her upper body to be completely intact, but the lower she was ripped apart, Mr. Holmes. Her skirts were raised up to reveal the torso, and savage cuts penetrated her lower abdomen, exposing the internal organs."
I regarded the doctor with dismay, but for Holmes, shock remained secondary to professional absorption. "Her chest was unharmed, you say? Surely her garments, at least, were soiled with blood?"
"She was wearing a brown frock, and I assure you it was entirely free of stain."
"If that is the case, she was prostrate before the wound to her neck was administered. Where is she now, Lestrade?"
"At the morgue. Name of Mary Ann 'Polly' Nichols, identified by a friend from Lambeth Workhouse who calls herself Mary Ann Monk. Mark of the workhouse was on the petticoats, which led us to seek identification there. Shabby clothing, black bonnet, and she had on her person a comb, pocket handkerchief, and a piece of mirror. Morethan likely it's all she had to her name."
"What do you imagine the time of death to have been, Dr. Llewellyn?"
"I arrived at three fifty a.m. She could not have been dead more than ten minutes."
"And the gruesome discovery was made by whom?"
"One Charles Cross, a carman on his way to work," said Lestrade as he consulted his notes. "In my opinion, he's merely a passerby. Poor chap was terrified. Constable Neil arrived on the scene shortly after and sent for Dr. Llewellyn here, hoping to save her. It was too late by that time, of course."
We sat silent as the wind picked up. I wondered briefly whether Polly Nichols's family knew of her hideous fate, and then whether she had any family to tell.
"Lestrade," Holmessaid finally, "has the force had any luck in clearing up the murder of Martha Tabram early this month?"
Lestrade shook his head perplexedly. "The inquest has just been reopened. I was not myself working on the case, but we're all of the mind it was a tryst gone terribly wrong. Good Lord, Mr. Holmes, you don't think these events could have been connected in any way?"
"No, certainly not. I've merely the professional certainty that two such outrageous crimes committed ten minutes' walk apart from each other is remarkable enough to note."
Dr. Llewellyn rose and reached for his hat. "I am very sorry I have not more to tell you gentlemen. I'm afraid I must return to my practice, as my patients will be wondering what has become of me."
"Be so good as to leave your card, Dr. Llewellyn," said Holmes, shaking his hand absently.
"Of course. The best of luck to all of you. Do let me know if I can be of any further assistance."
After Dr. Llewellyn's departure, Lestrade turned a grave face to Holmes.
"I don't like your harping on Martha Tabram one bit, Mr. Holmes. Surely the same man couldn't have fallen out with both these women? More likely Polly Nichols was killed by a jealous lover, or a gang, or one of her clients who'd fallen into a drunken rage."
"You are probably right. However, I beg that you will humour me far enough to fill me in on the details of both crimes."
Lestrade shrugged. "If Tabram is of interest to you, of course I've no objection. It shouldn't be difficult for me to gather up the papers. I can have them for you this afternoon."
"I shall cast an eye over the evidence immediately."
"You have full access, Mr. Holmes just mention my name at the morgue or at the crime scene. I shall see you both at the Yard." The inspector nodded and made his way out.
My friend crossed to the mantelpiece, shook a cigar out of an empty bud vase, and commenced smoking with the deepest absorption. "This Tabram murder is a very curious affair," he commented.
"You mean the Nichols murder?"
"I mean precisely what I say."
"You thought little enough of it before, Holmes."
"I expected every morning to read that they'd solved it. Men do not often stab helpless females thirty-nine times and then disappear into the ether. The motive behind such an outrageous act would necessarily be sensational."
"And such women necessarily have a great many associates, most of them untraceable," I pointed out.
"That is obvious," he retorted. "It is also obvious that the district of Whitechapel offers a great many natural advantages to the predator. Once the sun has fallen, you can hardly see your hand before your face, and the slaughterhouses allow blood-spattered men to pass without remark. What is less obvious is whether we have anything to fear from the proximity, in place and in time, of the two deaths."
"It is certainly a distressing coincidence."
Holmes shook his head and reached for his walking stick.
"One viciously maimed corpse is distressing. Two is something else entirely. I fear we have not a moment to lose."
Copyright © 2009 by Lyndsay Faye
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
Lyndsay Faye has accomplished three things with her first novel that many authors do not after many attempts. 1) She has written an excellent book that is truly a page turner. 2) She has combinded fact and fiction so well, that it seems real and 3) She has written a fresh story about Jack The Ripper, that could be real. With so many bad Sherlock Holmes books about, Ms Faye has managed to recreate the style of Doyle, yet pick a subject that Doyle never touched, and at the same time make Holmes appear more human. I hope this is not the last we hear from this author as I feel her next book will be ever better.
In 1888 London is shocked by the brutal murders of two prostitutes in the East End. Inspector Lestrade knows this is no run of the mill killer and he will need help. He asks renowned private sleuth Sherlock Holmes to investigate the homicides. Already fascinated by the accounts Holmes welcomes the case.
As Holmes and his sidekick Dr. Watson investigate, more vicious murders occur by the same killer the media dubs Ripper for his brutality. In an ironic twist one reporter claims Holmes is the Ripper, which is why he insists the famous detective has failed to end the reign of terror.
Holmes fans will welcome Lyndsay Faye to Baker St as her Watson comes across as a winner telling readers the tale of Holmes and Ripper. Fans will enjoy the great detective¿s efforts even as the press badgers him to solve the case; which ironically readers do earlier than the sleuth does. Although Homes and Ripper co-starring has been used before by Carole Nelson Douglas (in her Irene Adler series) and Michael Dibdin in THE LAST SHERLOCK HOLMES STORY, etc. Ms. Faye provides a fresh entry.
New novelist Lyndsay Faye has done what few have managed before. She has resurrected Sherlock Holmes and company. Faye succeeds admirably in creating the ambience of the original novels, and by pitting Holmes against Jack the Ripper, presents him with a challenge worthy of his talents. The world's greatest detective emerges true to form, with arrogance and foibles intact. Dr. Watson, dear as ever, remains at his side, but in this tale, he takes a more active role than was his wont. The usual lovely woman, in this case a fallen but by no means helpless one, assists with some hitherto hidden investigative skills, and may just find a life off Whitechapel's streets. And off course Lestrade and Mycroft have their days under this new sun. Faye has also created a theory about what might have happened to Jack, who in real life seems to just have up and vanished. And Faye's scenario is more than elementary, it's plausible. Dust and Shadow is a genuine page turner, rich in foggy Victorian atmosphere and a delight in which to lose yourself for a few suspense filled hours.
Alright, so that was trite; but this book was really quite fun and suspensful and a very interesting plot. I have often wondered where Sherlock was when "Jack" was around and this is a unique story. I thoroughly enjoyed it.
This is a can't put down book. The best characterazation of Holmes I have read in years. Hopefully Lyndsay Faye (author) has more Sherlock Holmes books in mind.
TITLE: Dust and Shadow AUTHOR: Lyndsay Faye GENRE: Mystery PAGES: 336 Let me be upfront and honest, I am a HUGE Sherlock Holmes fan. My grandfather got me hooked on Holmes and mysteries. One of the things I love about the Sherlock Holmes stories is being transported to a different time, place, and way of thinking. To me that is the magic that makes readers come back again and again. A lot of people have tried to harness that magic. Some great, some not so great, but in the end you can tell it is a pale imitation of Arthur Conan Doyle. They do say that imitation is the greatest form of flattery, these authors really flatter him. Not Lyndsay Faye. Oh no, she went far beyond my expectations. In Dust and Shadow, Lyndsay Faye gives us a tale of Sherlock Holmes taking on Jack the Ripper. Her writing is sharp and on point. Her level of detail is excellent to the point that she took me back to London of 1888. I could taste the air, feel the fog, smell the streets, pubs, and citizens. Most and best of all, she reminded me why I fell in love with Sherlock Holmes. She does her job so well, that I could not tell the difference between Arthur Conan Doyle, and her work. If you a) love and good mystery; b) love Sherlock Holmes; c) love a good Jack the Ripper tale; d) love a story set in Victorian London or e) all of the above, then please do yourself a favoer and go out and get this book. Dust and Shadow: An Account of the Ripper Killings by Dr. John H. Watson is most definitely for you. I give Dust and Shadow 5 out of 5 Bookmarks and my highest recommendation.
First-time author Faye rises to the double challenge of merging a new adventure of the world¿s most beloved fictional detective with the real-life story of the world¿s most famous serial killer. The stage is set when Holmes receives a vaguely threatening letter. Soon after, Watson reads of the first murder/mutilation in the papers. When a second murder is discovered, Inspector Lestrade appears at Holmes¿ Baker Street residence to request his help, and the game is afoot. For the rest of the book, Holmes and Watson play an increasingly dangerous game of cat and mouse with the serial killer of London¿s East End ¿unfortunates.¿ At one point, Holmes and Watson interrupt a murder, and Holmes is gravely injured. In the end, Holmes solves the case, but his brilliant deduction must remain a state secret. The murders stop, but the world will never know who was behind them. Fay does an outstanding job of recreating Conan Doyle¿s voice. A vivid cast of secondary characters, some of whom provide assistance, help flesh out the story. A enjoyable read that will appeal equally to Sherlock Holmes¿ fans, Ripperologists, and general mystery readers.
Reason for Reading: I always enjoy a good book featuring Holmes but this time I must say it was my pet true crime case Jack the Ripper that pulled me towards this book even more.Comments: The plot is what you would expect. The real-life Jack the Ripper case has been put into the the fictional London of Sherlock Holmes and in this world Holmes becomes involved in trying to solve the case. The book itself has been approved by the Holmes estate and is very true to Holmesian Canon, including characters and history from previous stories with footnotes to show from whence the references came. The Jack the Ripper information has also been thoroughly researched but is much more vague and not nearly as in-depth. This is much a story of Holmes, first and foremost before it is a story of Jack the Ripper.I've read all of Doyle's Holmes works, though I must say it was a long time ago, but I still felt the genuine tone of the original books come through in Fayes' writing. While one knows the plot, per say, of the Ripper murders she has added some shady characters and goings on that Sherlock must also unravel along his way to solving the bigger case. Also, while Faye stays true to the main facts of the Ripper case she does deviate away from the facts into fiction to make the story her own (or should I say Holmes' own). Jack the Ripper purist will not find a plausible solution to the case but then they shouldn't be expecting one with a fictional detective on the case.An enjoyable book but one I must say that never really grabbed me tightly. It was a pleasant read that didn't ever get me excited as to whodunit. Holmes and Watson were portrayed well, and fans will be sure to be pleased, but I just didn't connect with any of the other characters nor did the plot ever get me turning pages faster than normal. Overall, a pleasant, enjoyable mystery but nothing extraordinary.
A very good Sherlock Holmes pastiche. It is hard for any writer of Sherlock Holmes stories to ignore the Jack the Ripper killings just like it would have been impossible for Holmes to have avoided investigating the crimes. The trick for the writer is to have Holmes come up with a creditable solution to a case that was publically unsolved and Lyndsay Faye (in her first novel) does a nice job. The investigation is exciting, the solution is satisfying, there is a lot of good period detail and the characters are well presented. Even Inspector Lestrade comes off well.
Lyndsay Faye has done something that most authers can't accomplish: understanding and presenting a wonderful Sherlock Holms Book. Not only did she accomplish this with flying colors but she touched upon another subject that's not easy to get right: the Jack the Ripper murders. She obviouosly did her homework because this book is awesome.
I picked up Dust and Shadow because I was in a mystery phase. I had just read Shutter Island and The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo-both excellent-and I was on a streak. I went to the mystery section of Barnes and Noble, and Dust and Shadow was featured. It looked interesting-Sherlock Holmes and Jack the Ripper in one book. Robert Downey Jr. had nothing on this book¿that was until about page fifty.Initially, the language took me in. Listening to Holmes speak, make crazy observations, and irritate Scotland Yard was great, but then I got bored. The case with Jack the Ripper continued, and nothing seemed to develop. You learn, eventually, how Holmes made his discoveries, but even then it is anticlimactic. Holmes is involved in a violent attack-from Jack the Ripper himself-but it happens out of range and we don¿t see any of it. We miss all the action. We only get to see/hear one man talk and explain what happened and how we missed it.Last week, I was wondering what a good mystery had in it. I had started Dust and Shadow, and at the time I couldn¿t think of an answer. Well, now I have one. A good mystery is one that keeps you guessing but that also allows you to guess. Dust and Shadow didn¿t let me guess. Holmes told his guesses. Holmes gets involved, and we wait for him to come back to the flat. I was bored because I wasn¿t allowed to do anything.Dust and Shadow was Lyndsay Faye¿s first novel, and it was an ambitious one to take one. You have to admire the courage it takes to put two of our most famous icons together in one adventure. I just wish I had been allowed to go along too.
A smashingly good read!
This book kept my interest from beginning to end. The story was exciting and her style mirrored A.C.D. beautifully . I would recommend this book highly
The story moves well, it's woven in the true spirit of Conan Doyle and Sherlock Holmes. I thoroughly enjoyed this read.
I've been a fan of Sherlock Holmes since I was a child, and this book was a great way to get more. Faye does a great job with the tone of the book, and even offers a plausible ending to one of the greatest enduring murder mysteries. Her Watson was so spot on I almost forgot I was reading a pastiche sometimes. It is both a well written and well researched mystery to keep you turning the pages, and a love letter of sorts to literature's greatest partnership. Can't wait to read her other books.
If you're looking for a spellbinding retelling of the Jack the Ripper Case, don't bother with this book, it is a rambling, slow moving, wordy waste of time. "The Yard" exceeds this book by more than mile (pun intended), and the YA novel "The Name of the Star" is a 5-star rendition of this story.
I really enjoyed this book. Lyndsay Faye has captured the voice of Sherlock Holmes, Dr. Watson, and the grittiness of London in 1888. She obviously did her homework regarding the events surrounding the Jack the Ripper murders, and proposed a plausible and realistic theory. The story moved extremely well, and kept me interested all the way through until the last page. I look forward to reading "The Gods of Gotham".