After attending TC and Eve's (Everything But a Christmas Eve) wedding, Nana Vancy and her cohorts, Isabel and Annabelle, are looking for two more unsuspecting victims—er friends—to play matchmaker for. It just so happens Isabel's nephew, Henry Hanson, is visiting Erie with his daughter. Her single nephew.
Heather Rayson runs a community-based daycare center at the local retirement center that Isabel and Annabelle now live in. Heather's unsure what to make of Nana Vancy when Annabelle and Isabel bring her around, but she soon decides that the three older ladies are up to something. It takes a little longer for her to realize that what they're up to is trying to fix her up with Professor Henry Hanson. Heather's not against the idea of dating, and she certainly loves the professor's daughter, Lissa...but whenever she and the professor are in the same room sparks fly as they spar.
But perhaps there's a chance that the sparks aren't really two people who can't get along, but rather are the sparks of two people that could learn to get along very well indeed with a little nudge from their three matchmaking cupids!