The Exile: An Outlander Graphic Novel

The Exile: An Outlander Graphic Novel

by Diana Gabaldon, Hoang Nguyen
3.0 195

NOOK Book(eBook)

View All Available Formats & Editions
Available on Compatible NOOK Devices and the free NOOK Apps.
Want a NOOK ? Explore Now

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

See All Customer Reviews

Exile 3 out of 5 based on 0 ratings. 195 reviews.
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Waiting for The Exile was long and not worth the time to read, the paper used for printing, or the cost of the book. I have read all of the Outlander books and found this book shameful to the great characters of Jamie and Claire, and their legacy. Jamie and Claire have been downsized to nothing more than simpletons and reduced to a bad comic strip and nothing more. The inconsistencies in Hoang Nguyen illustrations are constant throughout the book; starting with Jamie looking like a person in the beginning and in the end looking like Speed Racer; and, that includes Claire. Ms. Gabaldon tries to write away the changes of these characters with a laugh in her text in the back of the book does not help matters; including downplaying the size of Claire's breasts. This does not change the simple fact that as an illustrator continuity is essential in making your characters believable. Going from the front to the back of the book, my questions during reading and looking at the illustrations were "who is that now?" This book was very disappointing and somewhere along the way Ms. Gabaldon you should have taken back control of your characters and found a better illustrator that would have stayed true to your written words. Personally, I would like a refund!
Marion_Klarke More than 1 year ago
Tries to cram too much into the graphic format, wildly inconsistent pictures of Jamie, Claire, and others. Puzzling new subplot introduced. All in all -- hard as it is to wait, this book doesn't add enough to the Outlander series to justify the cost. And the book's later images of Jamie are just awful -- he looks like Dudley Dooright with red hair. Ick. And -- I note in passing that the highest-rated positive review was posted more than a month before the release date. Suggest you read the reviews of Gabaldon fans who actually read the book before deciding to buy it. Marion K.
kerrysbabydoll More than 1 year ago
Having read the Outlander Series and loved every book, I wasn't sure what to expect with a graphic novel. In my opinion, it in NO way complimented the series. It was cheesie and immature. A huge disappointment. I'll continue to wait for the next book.
Headingley_Girl More than 1 year ago
I am enthralled with the Outlander series, and was intrigued to see the graphic know, compare it with how I envisioned what the characters and settings would be like...taking a chance at wrecking my ideal vision. For the most part, the settings, colors, textures are wonderful, however, I am disappointed with specific details such as the character's faces. Of course Jamie and Claire had to be beautiful, outwardly as well as inwardly, and we see this in many scenes. However, often times their facial features are drawn so differently from one scene to the next, it makes it hard to recognize them as the same character. As an example, the shape and distinctive qualities of their nose, and other facial characteristics may be drawn so differently from one scene to the next, one has to refer to their clothing to make certain they are the same person because they are so unrecognizable. Another example is that Jamie's size and stature is essentially equal, and in some cases smaller than the other men. His height and stature is one of his most distinguishing characteristics after all. Thank goodness he is depicted wearing a green tartan most of the time, otherwise it is often difficult to pick him out of the crowd. Anyway, I am not done the book yet, just received it (Sept.22/10), and may have more input after finishing it. My comments may seem a bit shallow to some, but I am an adult reading (viewing) what is essentially a comic book after all...cheers!
donkeycong More than 1 year ago
Diana Gabaldon is my favorite author. I have "devoured" all of her books... except this "Graphic Novel". I thought the Illustrations were poor... and the "comic book" writing style (for me) was beyond awful. Diana, if you read (or get feed-back) regarding reviews.... Please (I beg you) to ignore everything else and get your next novel finished. I have re-read all your novels "twice"... and I am salivating for your next book. Originally, I thought you were just being kind to a "relative" by letting them illustrate "The Exile" (using a pen name)... because the graphic novel art is simply awful and the "comic book" style writing is a bore. After you finish writing the next and ALL "Outlander" books,.... I would love to see a Novel, (not a Graphic Novel), written by YOU, regarding Jamie's perspective... true to the original "Outlander" book. or books. But, for now.... Please, please, please,.... finish writing the next book in the Outlander series.
Lynnibob More than 1 year ago
I read all 6 Outlander books, in a row, since I was introduced to them last summer. I loved the time, the characters, the romance and adventure. This book was not marketed for what it is: A comic book of Outlander. It lacks depth. It lacks any sort of original storyline. If you haven't already read Outlander you would be somewhat lost. If you have, then there is no point. The art was even hard to follow. The characters all looked alike. The only way I could identify them was the color of their tartan. Sorry Ms. Gabaldon, a more original storyline or at very least, a more realistic summary of the book (This is Cliffs Notes for people who can't read 800 pages) would have stopped me from spending my money.
loriabby More than 1 year ago
I'm very disappointed in the book. They should not have changed the storyline. It was like reading a Japanese comic book very disappointing I have read the first five books 5 times. Her last two books were not as good as the first five. I have given the book's as gifts to many people I do not recommend buying the book. She needs to get back to the basic story. The story that everyone fell in love with .
Darcys_mom More than 1 year ago
I have been a fan of DG since Outlander first came out but I must say I really wish she had passed on this project. I understand that she made her start doing comic books for Disney but this book seems like a big insult to the whole Jamie and Claire series. I have to agree with some other reviewers that if someone who has not read the other novels reads this book they probably would be completely confused about what is going on. And while reading the book I couldn't help feeling that if I read "Jesus H. Roosevelt..." one more time I would scream. Claire did not say it that often in the other books, so why have her saying it on every other page in this one? The illustrations are very good however they do not depict most of the characters the way I invisioned them. Especially Jamie and Claire. The drawings make them look more like teenagers than 20-somethings. And what is with Claire's ever-growing boobs? In one picture they look semi-normal, then in the next picture it looks like they are going to explode at any momemt. I do understand the concept of a "graphic novel" but I just don't think this story is a good choice for that format. Maybe if this had been published first and then the novels, it might have made more sense. I also did not understand where the Kenneth character came from. Why introduce someone who wasn't in the original books? Just doesn't make any sense. I will keep the book as part of my library but doubt very much that I would ever read it again. Unlike the other books, which I've read probably at least 8 or 9 times each.
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
I am an avid reader and a Gabaldon fan. I read all her books and I recognize that not all of her novels deserve a five star rating not even a four such in the case of her first book in the Lord John series. But there is something about her writing that is pivotal: Character development. In Outlander, Gabaldon spends pages painting the physical features, attributes, and personality traits that make her characters unique and unforgettable. When in a graphic novel, it's obvious we will not find her beautiful narrative, because, it's a blend of graphics and words. But I never expected to find a story so uninteresting, filled with a new convoluted plot, as the new time traveler, which lead to nowhere other than to a dead end. The main characters, Jaime and Claire, sound dumb, very far away from the witty, sharp, and educated loving individuals we came to know through her seven novels. The artwork looks promising until we hit page four. Slowly, the defined features of the characters begin to fade into pudgy, goofy looking, comic strip drawings. All the men look the same and the women seem to suffer from an overdose of hormones, especially Claire, that make their breast look like the centerfold picture of a Playboy magazine. All in all, I don't recommend this graphic novel since it is a far cry from Gabaldon's excellent abilities as a writer and does an utter disservice to the beautiful Outlander series.
Forensixchick More than 1 year ago
If you are unfamiliar with graphic novels, this book is probably not for you. I happen to be a fan of the Outlander series as well as many graphic novels and I really liked this work. No, the characters do not look the same as I envisioned but that is to be expected since my mental version of Jamie and Claire probably isn't the same as the authors anyway. I think that the art work was very well done and I really like the small section at the end of the book that explained why certain things were drawn the way they were. A good companion book to help pass the time before the next installment in the series is out.
TK87 More than 1 year ago
This was a total disappointment.
Gertt More than 1 year ago
After reading the reviews on this site, I think people need to remember that not only is The Exile a graphic novel, it is not a new story, but the retelling of a story we all know and love. The Outlander novels are among the best books I've read. Ms. Gabaldon not only creates many amazing characters that you know, love, hate and suffer with, but she is able to transport you to their time and place. Whether it's 1749, 1776 or 1960, Fraser's Ridge in NC, Wilmington or Philadelphia, Paris or Edinburgh, in prison, on the sea, or in the hills of Scotland and Lollybrook, you feel as if you are there and experiencing the adventure. Don't compare the outstanding Outlander series to the graphic novel, enjoy them each for what they are.
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Sell-out. I love the Diana Gabaldon Outlander series. Every book is an enjoyment. This was an attempt to use Diana Gabaldon's fame to make money on a comic book that could not have stood on its own with original characters. Shame on you Diana and Random House Publishing Group. I would recommend this book(?) to readers who like comic books and bright and shiny things.
cloggiedownunder More than 1 year ago
The Exile is a graphic novel in the popular Outlander series by American author, Diana Gabaldon. The text is by Gabaldon; the artwork by Vietnam-born Hoang Nguyen. Gabaldon states that it covers approximately the first third of the first book, Outlander, but in reality, it covers the first two thirds. The story is mostly told from the perspective of Jamie’s godfather, Murtagh Fitzgibbons Fraser, and begins where he meets Jamie returning from France. While the novel contains some new information, as well as some overlap with the novella, Virgins, much of what it tells is already known to the Outlander reader, although perhaps with some slight variations. The characters are given speech bubbles and thought bubbles, which does put a new slant on some of the characters’ motives, and there is a new character, Kenneth, another visitor from the future. Gabaldon has herself illustrated comics earlier in her life, so perhaps this is the impetus for this form of novel. Hoang’s artwork is detailed and colourful, but the Highland men are difficult to tell apart, except for Jamie with his red hair, and Colum Mackenzie with his (over)exaggerated lack of height. Claire is given a set of pneumatic breasts that seem to expand with the story, and Jamie’s injury cannot seem to make up its mind whether it resides in the left or right shoulder. The book is a quick read, especially for those familiar with the story, the presentation is on beautiful paper, and devoted fans of both graphic novels and Outlander may want to lay out between $20 and $30 for this quality hardback; those less fervent are advised to borrow it from the library. 3.5 stars
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
I really enjoyed reading the Outlander story from a different perspective and learning a little more about the story. I gave it four stars only because I thought it would be hard to follow if you are not familiar with the original story. Overall I loved the story and the graphics.
CelticWolf270911 More than 1 year ago
I don't agree that this work is disappointing. Gabaldon took Outlander to another level. True, we're all dying to see the next Jaime and Claire installment, but there's nothing wrong with revisiting the beginning of such a wonderful story and putting a new perspective on it. I would highly recommend ALL Outlander fans to give this another look and another try. Let it help you remember what was so wonderful about the first book in the first place. It's done that for me and I love it just as it is. Wouldn't change a thing. Keep them coming, Diana. This book is fun and a very welcome appetizer while we wait for the next meaty book to get finished. This book WILL get a place of honor beside all of my other hard Gabaldon hardbacks. Great job and PLEASE keep them coming.
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
After just reading the reviews and watching the series which i love the books and series the readers have convinced me i would be wasting my time and money since Diana writing and how she describes the characters were not in this or should I call it a comic book which I have no interest in reading!
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
I enjoyed seeing "the rest of the story" in the Outlander world. Murtagh was super cool, protective, abiding, and strong. The extra character Kenneth was puzzling. The story itself was told with a strangely immature vibe. Immature, considering the subject matter, and the sex scenes contained therein. Maybe it's written to a focus group of teenagers? The art was lovely, but not consistent. At times, I had to read the dialogue to figure out who the characters were. The faces were very similar, and the kilts looked a lot alike as well. Often, I needed to flip back a page or two to remind myself what each person was wearing, before continuing the story. Since I've already read all 8 of the Outlander novels, the story was familiar, with some interesting side views. But, if I had never read the original story before, I think this novel would be difficult to understand. With all of that said, I'm still glad I bought the Nook book, in order to fill in the gaps of my Diana Gabaldon collection.
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Let me read the book
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
I thought that it would be a novel telling Jaime's side. Instead I spent $12.99 on a comic book. I did not care for the illustration,in itself. It just was not what I expected. I want to read a novel a long one at that. Zero stars
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago