Like songwriter team-oriented compilations that Ace has produced for
Doc Pomus-
Mort Shuman and
Jerry Leiber-
Mike Stoller, this anthology of 26 tracks penned by Gerry Goffin and Carole King mixes a few famous hits with a bunch of items that are much more off the beaten path. It's a mixed, if overall worthwhile, blessing. For it's not the place to start if you want the best and most famous work in the Goffin-King catalog, missing the biggest covers of their compositions by
the Shirelles,
Little Eva,
Bobby Vee,
Herman's Hermits,
Manfred Mann,
the Chiffons,
the Everly Brothers, and others. On the other hand, for those who already have those hits several times over in their collections, it's a good place to pick up '60s recordings of many of their lesser-known songs, with a few smashes (particularly
Aretha Franklin's "(You Make Me Feel Like) A Natural Woman" and
the Animals' "Don't Bring Me Down") sprinkled in. The downside is that most of the songs, with some exceptions like the aforementioned pair, simply aren't as good or memorable as Goffin-King's most famous classics. But there are some very good tunes here, including a few that were small hits, like
Tony Orlando's "Halfway to Paradise,"
Betty Everett's rousing soul-popper "I Can't Hear You," and
the Tokens' "He's in Town" (which
the Rockin' Berries made a much bigger hit in Britain). Also of note are oddities like
the Crickets' "Don't Ever Change," a hit only in the U.K. (where
the Beatles covered it in 1963 on the BBC), Bobby Vee's rare "The Idol" (a theme song for a 1962 TV documentary), and
Dusty Springfield's version of "Wasn't Born to Follow" (a song much more renowned as done by
the Byrds).
Skeeter Davis' wonderful "Let Me Get Close to You"
sounds like it should have been a big hit, but to be honest, most of the relatively unfamiliar tracks here simply aren't in the same league, though many have excellent period '60s pop
ock production. That's even the case when stars like
the Drifters, the Chiffons,
Lenny Welch,
Bobby Rydell, the Righteous Brothers, and the Everly Brothers take a crack at something, though
Jackie DeShannon's girl group-flavored "Heaven Is Being with You" and
P.J. Proby's Righteous Brothers-like "I Can't Make It Alone" are well worth hearing. Still, the CD's a smartly chosen sampling of material for those who want to hear more Goffin-King compositions than what's most commonly available, with excellent liner notes covering both the composers' early careers and these specific recordings.
