05/20/2019
Fetching from start to finish, this novel by Printz Award winner Rosoff (How I Live Now) introduces the Peacheys, a family in disarray, and McTavish, the clever canine who comes to their rescue. There is “a great deal more squabbling and a great deal more squalor” in the household after Ma Peachey abdicates household responsibilities to immerse herself in yoga. Betty, the youngest and wisest of three siblings, proclaims she is “feeling lost, lonesome, and lacking in love,” and suggests that they adopt a dog. Pa Peachey begrudgingly drives his kids to an animal shelter—“Just to browse”—but relents when Betty and McTavish irrevocably bond. The inclusion of the take-charge dog’s voice augments the narrative’s hilarity (he deems humans “puzzlingly dim”). The fact that responsibility for running the household falls entirely on the mother might feel like a frustrating throwback, but many readers may recognize their own families in the dynamics here. McTavish’s sorting-out of the Peacheys conveniently serves his own interests (he uses clothes strewn on the floor to make his bed cozier and feigns lack of appetite to get the kids to cook healthy meals for all)—while teaching his new family much-needed lessons with droll flair. Ages 7–10. (Apr.)
A perceptive dog rescues a family in crisis with sheer cleverness and humor...Easton's grayscale illustrations in her debut offer a gentle counterpoint, depicting the round-shouldered members of the Peachey family with light skin and straight, dark hair. This book is a good selection for those ready for the next step beyond early readers and will undoubtedly create more children wanting a great dog to join the family.
—Kirkus Reviews
Rosoff plays around with our usual people-centered view of events in this short, amusing book, as it switches back and forth between human and canine perspectives. Twelve distinctive full-page pictures illustrate the story. From the appealing premise to the deftly drawn characters and satisfying conclusion, this early chapter book delivers a very readable story laced with dry humor.
—Booklist
A dog adopted from the local pound sets a family straight in this wryly funny chapter book from acclaimed British author Meg Rosoff. Dog owners know well that dogs are accomplished at getting humans to do their bidding, and Rosoff wrings every last bit of humor from this idea.
—Buffalo News
In Meg Rosoff’s droll morality tale ‘Good Dog, McTavish’, children ages 7-11 will find no ogres to be outwitted, but they will observe in the travails of the Peachey family a great deal of fecklessness and ill humor...Monochrome illustrations by Grace Easton add wry humor to this short, entertaining read.
—The Wall Street Journal
Fetching from start to finish, this novel by Printz Award winner Rosoff (How I Live Now) introduces the Peacheys, a family in disarray, and McTavish, the clever canine who comes to their rescue...McTavish’s sorting-out of the Peacheys conveniently serves his own interests (he uses clothes strewn on the floor to make his bed cozier and feigns lack of appetite to get the kids to cook healthy meals for all)—while teaching his new family much-needed lessons with droll flair.
—Publishers Weekly
Brilliant, wise, witty and loads of fun, "Good Dog, McTavish" is pitch-perfect in every way.
—Reading Eagle (from Kendal Rautzhan's "Books to Borrow")
A humorous tale about how a dog can bring a family together using love and a little common sense.
—School Library Journal
05/01/2019
Gr 2–5—This quirky and humorous early chapter book tells the story of how an adopted mutt, McTavish, sets a dysfunctional family on a path to success after Mom relinquishes her role as the family's sole caretaker. Once Mrs. Peachey decides she's had enough, things fall apart quickly—nobody else cleans, cooks, or keeps the family on schedule. This is a tough subject that could hit close to home for many readers, but the story does not dwell on the melancholy premise of a parent leaving home. Instead, it uses exaggerated caricatures—the know-it-all teen, the bumbling, distant father—and overly formal language to create humor. Betty, the youngest and most sensible member of the family, decides that adopting a dog will help her to feel less "lost, lonesome, and lacking in love." The rest of the Peacheys, including Pa Peachey, tend to do what they are told (no matter who tells them) and adopt McTavish, who soon has the family doing laundry and cooking healthy food once again. Perhaps this solution oversimplifies the novel's main problem—Mom feeling unappreciated—but it makes for a feel-good ending. The book's humor is sarcastic and tongue-in-cheek, and Rosoff shows off her writing chops, but sophisticated vocabulary such as "sociopath," "foray," and "acquisition" might make the story a hard sell for younger, less experienced readers. However, the slimness of the volume and Easton's illustrations, which bring Melissa Sweet's work to mind, may turn away older readers who might better appreciate the prose. Alone on the shelves, this book may struggle to find the right reader, so it is recommended for libraries where early chapter books, such as Kate DiCamillo's "Mercy Watson," circulate well. VERDICT A humorous tale about how a dog can bring a family together using love and a little common sense.—Shannon O'Connor, Unami Middle School, Chalfont, PA
2019-03-03
A perceptive dog rescues a family in crisis with sheer cleverness and humor.
"McTavish's decision to adopt the Peachey family was not the most sensible decision of his life." So begins the adventure of a sandy-colored terrier who arrives unbidden, like Mary Poppins, in this domestic satire. Having "decided to give up being a mother," Ma Peachey is boycotting her household responsibilities, leaving Pa Peachey cranky, Ava (14) gloomy, and Ollie (12) petulant. Only 8-year-old Betty is wise enough to see their dire straits. Who will do the cooking and the cleaning and get everyone to school on time? McTavish sees the youngest one's sensible nature and works with her, without magic or fantasy, to bring the family back from the brink even as Ma Peachey indulges her yoga habit while the household falls to pieces. If the essential ridiculousness can be overlooked, this is a sweetly humorous story about training a family to behave. Readers will enjoy seeing the role reversal of the dog adopting a family, and they might gain some psychological awareness of others. Easton's grayscale illustrations in her debut offer a gentle counterpoint, depicting the round-shouldered members of the Peachey family with light skin and straight, dark hair.
This book is a good selection for those ready for the next step beyond early readers and will undoubtedly create more children wanting a great dog to join the family. (Fantasy. 7-10)
