- (Argument With David Rawlings Concerning Morrissey)
- To Be Young (Is to Be Sad, Is to Be High)
- My Winding Wheel
- Oh My Sweet Carolina
- Bartering Lines
- Call Me on Your Way Back Home
- Damn, Sam (I Love a Woman That Rains)
- Come Pick Me Up
- To Be the One
- Why Do They Leave?
- Shakedown on 9th Street
- Don't Ask for the Water
- In My Time of Need
- Sweet Lil Gal (23rd/1st)
While Whiskeytown's third album languishes in record-company limbo, the band's frontman and songwriter, Ryan Adams, has some other stories to tell. Adams lost a lover while he was living in New York City, and he confronts his loneliness and frustration on Heartbreaker. Avoiding the raucous side of Whiskeytown in favor of a more introspective approach, Adams has assembled a stripped-down combo featuring Gillian Welch and David Rawlings for a cycle of intimate, primarily acoustic ballads. The songs carry an aura of being alone in a hotel room far from home, late at night, and knowing that the one you want to call doesn't want to hear from you. The female harmonies -- most of them by Welch but with cameos from Emmylou Harris (who works her usual magic on the homesick meditation "Oh My Sweet Carolina"), Kim Richey, and Allison Pierce -- amplify the album's yearning, heartbroken vibe. It's not all sad banjos and acoustic guitars, though: Adams and friends let loose convincingly on "To Be Young (is to be sad, is to be high)," which recalls Bob Dylan and The Band's most rollicking moments, and the rockabilly murder ballad "Shakedown on 9th Street." Sly Dylan allusions abound, most directly in the cadence of "Damn, Sam (I love a woman that rains)," but that's just Adams playing with history. He also tweaks his roots on "Don't Ask for the Water," which crosses William Bell's "You Don't Miss Your Water (Until Your Well Runs Dry)" with Howlin' Wolf's "I Asked for Water (She Gave Me Gasoline)," and ebbs and flows achingly between hopeless attraction and vindictive repulsion. More than just an indie stopgap between his band's higher-profile releases, Heartbreaker is a lonely, low-key gem.
Performance CreditsRyan Adams Primary Artist,Acoustic Guitar,Banjo,Harmonica,Piano,Electric Guitar,Vocals
Emmylou Harris Vocals
Ethan Johns Bass,Drums,Glockenspiel,Hammond Organ,Vibes,chamberlain,Musician
Kim Richey Vocals
Gillian Welch Acoustic Guitar,Banjo,Electric Bass,Bass Guitar,Vocals,Voices
David Rawlings Acoustic Guitar,Banjo,Electric Guitar,Tambourine,Vocals
Allison Pierce Vocals
Pat Sansone Organ,Piano,Background Vocals,chamberlain
Allison Pearce Vocals
Technical CreditsEthan Johns Producer,Engineer
Vanessa Alston Composer
Tony Monaco Graphic Design
Ethan Jones Audio Production
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
I was given Ryan Adams ''Gold'' album by a friend and found it a refreshing change to what was being played on the radio. While at the record store I came across heartbreaker and decided to buy it. It has since become a staple in my CD collection I can not say enough about it. If ''come pick me up'' does not hit a chord with you, I will never understand why.
Ryan's heart is broken, thus the title Heartbreaker. Many of the songs deal with his heart break--the lyrics and vocal delivery are so emotionial, you almost feel like your eavesdropping. Amy, My Winding Wheel, To Be the One, Call Me On Your Way Back Home, Don't Ask For The Water will just about rip your heart out! There's a few Alt-country gems including Oh, My Sweet Carolina, Bartering Lines, and In My Time of Need that aren't quite as sad, but still lyrically pack an emotional punch. And there's a pair of kicking rockers To Be Young is To Be Sad, and Shakedown on 9th Street. The production is sparse, and sometimes you can barely hear is voice, and sometimes the harmonica is so loud it startles you. I think they were going for a live sound (this was recorded in 14 days for a small independant label) and perhaps didn't have the inclination to change a thing. One more thing: Come Pick Me Up really sums up the plight of a young man who just can't stay away from the wrong woman. It is a funny and sad song at the same time, because you just KNOW he's going to hook up with the wrong gal again!
I first heard this CD in a local record shop and was blown away. As soon as I heard Come Pick Me Up I was hooked. I've been waiting for years for someone to put this much thought and emotion into an album and it appears Adams has finnaly done it.