The Last Days of the Romanovs: Tragedy at Ekaterinburg

The Last Days of the Romanovs: Tragedy at Ekaterinburg

by Helen Rappaport

Paperback(First Edition)

$16.40 $17.99 Save 9% Current price is $16.4, Original price is $17.99. You Save 9%.
View All Available Formats & Editions
Choose Expedited Shipping at checkout for guaranteed delivery by Thursday, July 18

Overview

From the New York Times bestselling author of The Romanov Sisters and Caught in the Revolution, The Last Days of the Romanovs is Helen Rappaport's riveting, moment-by-moment account of the last fourteen days of the Russian Imperial family.

“The brutal 1918 massacre of the Romanov family may be familiar, but in Russian scholar Rappaport's hands, the tale becomes as shocking and immediate as a thriller. . . . A gripping read.” —People magazine

This is the story of the murders that ended three hundred years of Romanov rule and set their stamp on an era of state-orchestrated terror and brutal repression. Counting down to the last, tense hours of the Imperial family's lives, Rappaport strips away the over-romanticized versions of previous accounts. The story focuses on the family inside the Ipatiev House, capturing the oppressive atmosphere and the dynamics of a group—the Romanovs, their servants, and guards—thrown together by extraordinary events.

Marshaling overlooked evidence from key witnesses such as the British consul to Ekaterinburg, Sir Thomas Preston, American and British travelers in Siberia, and the now-forgotten American journalist Herman Bernstein, Helen Rappaport gives a brilliant account of the political forces swirling through the remote Urals town. She conveys the tension of the watching world: the Kaiser of Germany and George V, King of England—both, like Alexandra, grandchildren of Queen Victoria—their nations locked in combat as the First World War drew to its bitter end. And she draws on recent releases from the Russian archives to challenge the view that the deaths were a unilateral act by a maverick group of the Ekaterinburg Bolsheviks, identifying a chain of command that stretches directly, she believes, to Moscow—and to Lenin himself.

Telling the story in a compellingly new and dramatic way, The Last Days of the Romanovs brings those final tragic days vividly alive against the backdrop of Russia in turmoil, on the brink of a devastating civil war.

Product Details

ISBN-13: 9780312603472
Publisher: St. Martin''s Publishing Group
Publication date: 01/19/2010
Edition description: First Edition
Pages: 288
Sales rank: 107,579
Product dimensions: 6.00(w) x 9.10(h) x 0.80(d)

About the Author

Helen Rappaport studied Russian at Leeds University and is a specialist in Russian and nineteenth-century women's history. Her previous book No Place for Ladies: The Untold Story of Women in the Crimean War (Aurum Press) was published to acclaim in the UK in 2007. She lives in Oxford.

Read an Excerpt

The Last Days of the Romanovs

Tragedy at Eckaterinburg


By Helen Rappaport

St. Martin's Press

Copyright © 2008 Helen Rappaport
All rights reserved.
ISBN: 978-1-4299-9128-5



CHAPTER 1

Behind the Palisade

30 APRIL–3 JULY 1918


It took five days of bone-rattling travel by tarantass – a crude springless carriage – for the Romanovs to get from Tobolsk to Tyumen. During the journey, Alexandra and Maria huddled together and shivered as they were jolted across rivers and through spring floods and quagmires of mud. Drained and exhausted, Alexandra had been glad of the company of Maria, who had volunteered to come with them as a comfort to her. Nicholas, in contrast, seemed cheerful, glad to be on the move and out in the fresh frosty air.

Faced with the choice of accompanying her husband to Moscow, as she thought, and defending his position, or staying behind to nurse the sick Alexey in Tobolsk, Alexandra had agonised over her decision, torn between the overwhelming emotional pull of her son and her ingrained fears for Nicholas. Eventually she resolved that her first duty was to the Tsar, if only for her malleable husband's own protection.

At Tyumen the royal party transferred to the heavily guarded first-class carriage of Special Train No. 8 VA, commandeered by Vasily Yakovlev. En route Yakovlev continued to give the official line that Nicholas was being sent back to the capital to be put on trial. Privately, the Tsar and the Tsaritsa were convinced that fate would intervene and that this would be but the first stage in the Imperial Family's safe passage out of Russia. After a series of delays, the train arrived at Omsk, the junction of two major lines on the Trans-Siberian Railway, and the couple were suddenly gripped by alarm. Where would they be taken next? Eastwards across Siberia to Vladivostok and out of Russia via Japan? Or west towards Moscow and a public trial? Nothing was said as the train idled for hours in a siding at Lyubinskaya while Yakovlev parlayed over the telegraph with Moscow. Finally a change of plan was agreed. The train moved off, back in the direction of Tyumen. The Tsar and Tsaritsa were to be escorted not to Moscow after all, but to Ekaterinburg, where the Ural Regional Soviet would take custody of them.

At 8.40 a.m. on Tuesday 30 April, the train pulled into the city with its blinds drawn. As it did, Nicholas and Alexandra's anxiety levels rocketed. For here, at last, they encountered the full, ugly force of Russia in revolution. As the Tsaritsa later recalled in her diary, the day might have been 'gloriously warm and sunny', but the welcoming committee had been decidedly frosty. Rumours of the imminent arrival of the hated Tsar and Tsaritsa had spread like wildfire and an angry mob had gathered at the main railway station demanding that they be paraded before them. Fearful of a lynching, the Urals military commissar, Filipp Goloshchekin, who had been waiting to receive the Romanovs, decided to send the train on to the city's freight station No. 2 at Shartash, on the eastern outskirts. The Romanovs' first sight of Ekaterinburg was, after several hours kept sitting in the train, a goods siding at four in the afternoon. Waiting for them on the platform was a group of stony-faced Bolsheviks – Aleksandr Beloborodov, chair of the Ural Regional Soviet, Boris Didkovsky, his deputy, and Sergey Chutskaev, a member of the Ekaterinburg Soviet and the local secret police, the Cheka.

The Tsar and his family were now received into the hands of the Ural Regional Soviet for 'detention under surveillance', along with Dr Evgeny Botkin, their maid Anna Demidova, the valet Terenty Chemodurov and footman Ivan Sednev. With a bureaucratic flourish, Beloborodov signed the official receipt for them, like so much baggage. Aleksandr Avdeev, who with Yakovlev had accompanied the Tsar and Tsaritsa from Tobolsk, was appointed commandant of the Romanovs' new place of confinement. Later that hot summer afternoon the party made the short journey to Voznesensky Prospekt along eerily deserted streets, in closed motor cars, escorted by a truck bristling with armed soldiers. As their car pulled into the courtyard of the Ipatiev House, the former Tsar and his wife looked their last on Russia and the outside world. It was Passion Week and the bells – the beautiful bells that had so beguiled Anton Chekhov – were ringing out across the city. But they could not drown out the sound of the heavy wooden courtyard gates as they slammed shut behind them.

The Tsar and Tsaritsa moved to enter the Ipatiev House, to be greeted at the entrance by Goloshchekin, who had gone on ahead to meet them and now turned to his former monarch and declared: 'Citizen Nicholas Romanov, you may enter.' Impervious to insult, reconciled to his fate, Nicholas did not react, but the slight cut the Tsaritsa to the quick. Though Alexandra would continue, stubbornly, to take exception to Bolshevik disrespect, from now on there would be no more acknowledgement of Romanov status and titles, which, even in Tobolsk, had still been part of the daily protocol observed by staff and guards alike. The former Tsar of Russia was now an ordinary Soviet citizen like any other, with his own ration card. While he may have looked on their life at Tobolsk as a kind of house arrest, here Nicholas finally found himself in prison, within that vast annexe of the Russian empire that was itself a prison: Siberia.

Via emphatic instructions sent from Moscow by Yakov Sverdlov to the Ural Regional Soviet, it was the clear intention of the Kremlin leadership that the family should now be confined 'in the strictest way'. Seething with class hatred and desire for revenge on 'Nicholas the Bloody', the Ekaterinburg Bolsheviks delighted in withdrawing comforts previously accorded the Imperial Family. If the relative idyll in Tobolsk had prevented them taking their fate seriously, then now, surely, their presence in Ekaterinburg was for Nicholas and Alexandra a stark awakening. On her arrival it prompted the Tsaritsa to inscribe the date and a reverse swastika on the bedroom wall, a last faint gesture that this ancient symbol of faith, love and hope might eventually bring release.

Together with Maria, the Tsar and Tsaritsa spent their first three weeks at the Ipatiev House cooped up together in a single bedroom with only the use of the bathroom and sitting room, where Dr Botkin and the servants Chemodurov and Sednev slept; Anna Demidova occupied a small room in the back. The electricity supply was sporadic, but when she could, Alexandra wrote endless letters to the children in Tobolsk, as Nicholas read aloud from the Gospels. Despite the glorious sunshine, heavy snowfalls had continued well into May and emotional comforts were few until, at 11 a.m. on the unseasonably cold and snowy morning of the 23rd, the remaining four children arrived from the city station. But the 27-strong Tobolsk entourage who had travelled with them were informed that they could go no further. The Ekaterinburg Soviet had no wish to burden itself with the additional expense of their maintenance. They were left sitting on the train at Ekaterinburg station, to be later dispersed, a few to freedom but most to prison (where the Tsar's loyal aide Prince Dolkorukov had already been taken on arrival in April). Only three more servants, the cook Ivan Kharitonov, the kitchen boy Leonid Sednev (the nephew of Ivan Sednev) and the manservant Alexey Trupp, were allowed to follow the Imperial Family into the Ipatiev House, bringing with them Alexey's beloved pet spaniel, Joy, and Tatiana's two dogs, Jimmy and Ortipo.

The arrival of Alexey, Olga, Tatiana and Anastasia from Tobolsk, of which the Tsar and Tsaritsa were forewarned only a few hours before their arrival, greatly lifted the family's flagging spirits. There was no doubt, Nicholas noted in his diary, that the four children had all suffered personally and spiritually when left in Tobolsk on their own. But theclosely interdependent family unit was once more reunited and what greater joy could there be than for it to be during Passion Week – the most sacred festival in the Orthodox calendar. That evening they gathered together in front of their treasured icons and said fervent prayers of thanks. But Alexandra had already noted with alarm that her son was worryingly frail and wasted, having lost 14 pounds since his latest attack of haemophilia. That same first evening, all it took was one small slip and twist of the knee getting into bed and Alexey spent the whole of the night in unremitting pain. The Tsaritsa lay nearby, sleepless and watchful, listening to the boy's moans, as she had done for so many long nights now over the last 13 years.

But at least the family had each other again – and God. Their only line of resistance to the new and far more draconian regime imposed on them was to turn in on themselves and draw on their intense religious faith. It would sustain them through the days to come as they entered into a new, strange state of suspended animation. Existing but not living; locked in the deadening familiarity of a narrow, tedious daily ritual which day by day led them ever closer to – what? Release? Escape? Rescue? Whatever their ultimate fate might be, of one thing this strangely insular family were certain. God would take a hand in their fate.

And he was doing so already in that of several of their Romanov relatives now, unbeknown to the Imperial Family, being held in the city. The Tsaritsa's sister Grand Duchess Elizabeth (known as Ella), Grand Duke Sergey, the Tsar's cousin, and Princes Ioann Konstantinovich, Konstantin Konstantinovich and Igor Konstantinovich (three Romanov brothers descended from Konstantin, the second son of Nicholas I), together with Prince Vladimir Pavlovich Paley, had all been brought to Ekaterinburg in May and shut up in the Atamanov lodging house. But at least they had been allowed out to celebrate midnight mass in the cathedral at Easter, a privilege denied the Imperial Family. Here they had stood holding lighted candles of red wax, praying that the transcendent beauty of the Easter liturgy would bring hope and release. Prince Paley, himself a soulful and talented poet, wrote home to his mother of his anguish for his Romanov cousins. He had ventured up to the Ipatiev House in hopes of catching a glimpse of the Imperial Family, but the palisade was too high and the windows at that time were covered with newspaper. Meek, calm, submissive to his fate, he confided to officer's wife Madame Semchevsky his personal anguish for 'our poor Russia'. The country had, for him, become like some once majestic and powerful ship, now being engulfed by the waves and vanishing into the darkness. The great pools of Prince Paley's melancholy eyes spoke volumes for his sense of loss, remembered Semchevskaya, reflected in the lines of a poem he read that evening: 'Our near and dear ones are so terrifyingly far away; our enemies so terrifyingly near ...' – sentiments no doubt shared by his Romanov relatives a few streets away.


As a place of confinement, the Ipatiev House at No. 49 Voznesensky Prospekt was adequate, if cramped. It had been the original intention of the Ural Regional Soviet to incarcerate Nicholas in the city's prison, but security problems had prevented it. A suitable private house had been opted for instead, the Ipatiev House finally being chosen in preference to the residence of local doctor Kensorin Arkhipov because it was closer to the Cheka headquarters. Though boasting 21 rooms, it was small by the standards of the more spacious and airy Governor's House in Tobolsk. But situated as it was at the top of one of the few gentle hills leading out of Ekaterinburg, it had a fine view of the lake, public gardens and city below, through which the River Iset wound its course. Built between 1875 and 1879 by a mining engineer, Andrey Redikortsev, its present owner, Nikolay Ipatiev, had acquired the house in around 1908 for 6,000 roubles. Boasting as it did a private bathroom and flush toilet, it was considered one of the most modern residences in the city. Ipatiev was a well-respected citizen and intellectual, a member of the Ekaterinburg Duma who had been involved in the construction of the Perm–Kungur–Ekaterinburg section of the Trans-Siberian Railway and who ran his railway engineering business from the house's basement rooms. He had been out of Ekaterinburg taking a rest cure for his weak heart, and friends from Petrograd had been staying in the house, when order no. 2778 had arrived from the Ekaterinburg Soviet on 27 April, giving 48 hours' notice to quit. Ipatiev had hurried back to rescue some personal belongings but largely left the house intact with all its comfortable furnishings, down to the stuffed bear on the upstairs landing.

The house appeared rather low and unimposing from the outside, because it was built into the side of the hill, so that the lower semi-basement was only visible at its full height from the side, along Voznesensky Lane. But it was attractive and reassuringly Russian in style rather than classically elegant. It was built on the site of an old wooden church, pulled down in the eighteenth century when the grand new Voznesensky Cathedral had been built across the road.

Constructed of brick and stone and faced with white stucco, it had carved decorations on the doors and window frames and under the eaves and faced a dusty, unpaved street shaded by linden trees. Opposite was Voznesensky Square with its baroque cathedral and the grandly classical Rastorguev-Kharitonov mansion, but beyond, the poorer log and frame houses of ordinary working-class Ekaterinburgers were a stark reminder of the contrast between wealth and poverty still to be seen all over the city. Near the front door stood a small shrine dedicated to St Nicholas, built where the altar of the old wooden church had been located, but the family could not see this poignant and ironic reminder of the Tsar's patron saint because a palisade blocked it from view.

Having failed to keep the family's presence in the city a secret (it had been announced in the daily Ural'skiy Rabochiy on 9 May), the Romanovs' Bolshevik captors had initiated a deliberate policy of isolation and desensitisation from the very beginning. Before the Tsar's arrival the house had been descended on by a gang of 100 workmen who hastily surrounded it with a high palisade of sawn timber and telegraph poles standing a few feet from the front of the house. Originally about 12 feet, the palisade was heightened at the end of May, but worse was to come. On 5 June a second, higher palisade was thrown up in an even larger sweep, enclosing the entire house from the courtyard at the northern end, right across and down into Voznesensky Lane. The front entrance to the house was now dominated by Guard Post No. 1, the first of 10 placed in and around the building, and the exterior of this fortress was patrolled twice hourly – day and night – by a constantly changing roster of guards. All 10 guard posts had connecting bells to both Commandant Avdeev's room and the guardhouse across the street.

With the palisade only 14 feet from their windows, Alexandra's 'lovely world' was now finally shut off from the family. Despite the approach of summer, every window had been sealed tight, and on 15 May the world outside was whitewashed from view when an old man came and painted the windows over, thus ensuring no one could see in or out. Nicholas wrote that it felt 'as if there is a fog outside'. No matter how bright the day, there was a perpetual gloom indoors. As the temperature rose and the rooms became increasingly stuffy, the Tsar made repeated requests to Avdeev for the windows to be reopened. The Bolsheviks were reluctant to accede: the Romanovs already had access to the fortochka, a small winter ventilator in the upper section of a window looking on to Voznesensky Prospekt. Repeatedly, early in the morning, the sentries outside had noticed the head of one or other of the daughters peeking out. Warnings were ignored, and finally one morning a sentry had fired when Anastasia's head had appeared, the bullet striking the upper sill and ricocheting into the plaster on the bedroom wall.


(Continues...)

Excerpted from The Last Days of the Romanovs by Helen Rappaport. Copyright © 2008 Helen Rappaport. Excerpted by permission of St. Martin's Press.
All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher.
Excerpts are provided by Dial-A-Book Inc. solely for the personal use of visitors to this web site.

Table of Contents

Acknowledgements ix

List of Illustrations xiii

Introduction: The Red Urals 1

1 Behind the Palisade 2

2 'The Dark Gentleman' 28

3 The Man with a Cigarette 44

4 The Woman in a Wheelchair 58

5 Girls in White Dresses 73

6 The Boy in the Sailor Suit 86

7 The Good Doctor 98

8 'Our Poor Russia' 106

9 'Everything Is the Same' 118

10 'What Is To Be Done with Nicholas?' 128

11 'Absolutely No News from Outside' 144

12 'Something Has Happened to Them in There' 159

13 'Ordinary People Like Us' 170

14 The House of Special Purpose 175

15 'The Will of the Revolution' 184

16 'The World Will Never Know What We Did to Them' 203

Epilogue: The Scent of Lilies 208

Note on Sources 224

Bibliography 228

Index 243

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

See All Customer Reviews

Last Days of the Romanovs 4.3 out of 5 based on 0 ratings. 61 reviews.
Caseylondon More than 1 year ago
A romance, a family saga, a murder mystery, and a political thriller - all of these descriptions aptly fit the story of the last Russian Tsar Nicolas Romanov and his family. Many novelists and historians have written about the family, the individual members, the time period, and even the tragic love story between Nicholas and Alexandra. Like many historical tales, the lives and deaths of the Romanovs are shrouded in myth, mystery and legend. Helen Rappaport's book tells the story of Russia's royal family at Ipatiev House in July 1918 the last residence they occupied & where they spent their final hours. It is different in tone from other books because of the specifics it addresses. Sheltered and protected all of their lives, removed from the everyday hardships of ordinary Russians the family is caught in a frightening situation without the normal trappings of their wealth and privilege. Taken from their palatial homes & with hopes of being exiled the family instead are captives in five gloomy rooms. Alexy, the heir to the throne has a fatal, painful disease & his four sisters are spending their teen years (or early 20's) not in happy youthful exuberance but in fear & with no chance to explore relationships with the opposite sex (one exception is noted). Born a royal, the Tsarina is ill, (perhaps a bit of a hypochondriac) devastated, difficult and unprepared for the events. The Tsar, always a simple and kind man who prefers exercise to affairs of state is beginning to realize that his family will not be rescued. Eyewitness accounts & a new look at the hierarchy for implementing the death penalty for the Tsar & for the entire family is exposed by Rappaport. She delineates why the family was included in the death sentence. Anyone who has read or seen anything about the Romanov family knows that the basement killings in July 1918 were brutal, but nothing compares to the vivid writing in this book. Nothing. But, as horrible as the deaths may have been, it is the daily life of the Romanov's during their time in Ekaterinburg that brings heartbreak to the reader. All the windows in their rooms were sealed so there was no light from windows - nor any chance of a cool breeze. Royal dignity was displayed when even small joys were taken such as the Tsar's daily newspaper. Rappaport's book does an excellent job of tracing the culpability of their deaths something that has long been in question. The research efforts that went into writing this book are very apparent. The way the research is used,however, is where the author distinguishes herself as a writer. Rappaport's story of the Romanovs last days is told as a as a reporter but with an historian's eye and heart. Facts are meshed with personalities to provide a full complement of the actual events at Ekaterinburg. This story has been told before in bits & pieces but never the ending and never so fully and perhaps never so well.
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
My only disappointment is that the illustrations are not included!!!!!!!!
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
I found this book informative and full of historical details, but dry and slow reading. It is not light reading, but is good for the history buff who is interested in the subject.
Jeremy_McNeese More than 1 year ago
Although there have been many books on the topic of the last Tsar of Russia, very few have come close to depicting the details that Helen Rappaport does in her book, The Last Days of the Romanovs: Tragedy at Ekaterinburg. Within the pages of her page-turning she recounts what the life of the deposed ruler was like under house arrest. However it is Rappaport's thesis that once the deposed ruler and his family were sent to the Ekaterinburg, their fate had been sealed into destiny. In the first chapter of her book, Rappaport recounts from the perspective of the Alexandra Romanov, what it meant to be moving into Asia-simply that they would never return back to the European Russia that they had known so well. This meant that they were terminally exiled. Rappaport makes this clear with her statement on page 2 in reference to the giant obelisk monument that is situated outside the city of Ekaterinburg: "Many would kiss the obelisk in a final farewell; others scratched their names on the plasterwork. Most would never pass this way again." Rappaport makes it clear that the former Tsar and his wife knew that their future did not await them in European Russia, and "they would never pass that way again." The Style of this book is written in a form of prose similar to the novel. Each chapter heading relates to a picture, a snapshot rather, to paint a more vivid picture of what the chapter was about. Each of the snapshots that are mentioned in the chapter headings are conveniently placed within the book. It is very easy to become enthralled in this book, as each page makes the last days of the Romanovs more relative to the audience. Although it is her intent to focus the majority of her attention on the last fourteen days that the Romanov family lived, Rappaport spends a great deal of time in the first chapter covering the events leading up to their deposition and transfer by rail to Ekaterinburg. This aids Rappaport's ability to convey the story to a much larger audience than just the educated elite. Rappaport backs up her argument in many different modes. It is apparent that she is knowledgeable of Russian History, as well as the city of Ekaterinburg, Russia. Through pictures, facts, and personal research within the city of Ekaterinburg, Rappaport makes it clear to her audience that she is very well informed. Her point of view is something that is unheard of in regards to the depiction of the death of the last Tsar; It is apparent that Rappaport is a monarchist and in favor of the Tsarist rule. In Ekaterinburg today, as the city, since the fall of Communism, has been dedicated to the Romanov family. This is a huge change in directions from where it was when the Romanov family was killed. Therefore, it may be a clear fact that the contemporary culture of Ekaterinburg has influenced Rappaport's interpretation of the historical events that occurred there. Within the pages of this page turner Rappaport shares with her readers the vivid and broken lives of the former Tsar and his family. She carries this through to their deaths on the morning of Thursday, 18 July 1918. I highly recommend this book to anyone who is remotely interested in the history of the 20th century. Rappaport's recounting is very much a part of what has gone into making the last century what it became.
denise brunson More than 1 year ago
Informative. Details all the players. Makes the Imperial Family real people rather than an idealized monarchy. Only disappointment is the illustrations/pictures did nit download with the book.
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
I have read a great deal of information on the Romanov Family, and I found this book to be filled with information that I had not heard before. I enjoyed the easy way that the informaion was presented. It is a must read for any Russian History Enthusiast.
Dinaki More than 1 year ago
I enjoyed reading this book. I learned a lot with this book, Miss Helen Rappaport used some easy English words that made reading not difficult and revealing to us, what the Romanovs family had to endure.
Doc79 More than 1 year ago
This book is one of the best Romanov's book I have read. The details are amazing. If you want to kinda know what happened their last days...read this book..Make sure you have a strong stomach when you get to the end:)
peaches65 More than 1 year ago
tragic throughout. one can't believe how easily it was to literally wipe out a dynasty that is over 300 years in such short order. one question constantly rise its head: "were there no one give a thought of the importance of the moment?" i wanted to say badly, "shame on the bolsheviks!!" i guess we can say that to so many so call revolutionaried, i.e. mao's cultural revolution brings to mind. at the end of the book, i can't help but to feel certain sadness not just on the lack of preparation to end a dynasty but the bumbling idiots that were the participants. it is too bad that history has let them "off" so easily. good read.
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Obviously Helen Rapport is passionate about the subject and did an incredible amount of research. She did a thorough job of explaining the situation in Russia in 1918, what led up it and what happened afterward. The Romanov family was brought to life and the reader got to know them as people not just names in a history book. Not really suited to the role of Tsar, Nicholas just wanted to lead a quiet life with his family. Alexandra was a domineering woman plagued by ill health. The children? They were just that, children. Their only crime was being born as Romanovs. Their lives were cut short before they really started. The chapter that dealt with the family's murder was very hard to read. The assassins subjected the family to so much pain and horror. The family pets were even killed - except for Alexey's beloved spaniel who gratefully was able to live out his live in England. The good, the bad and the ugly - I loved this book and would recommend it highly.
knightlight777 on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
Excellent book, much like the page turning pot boiler but it was real.
Schmerguls on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
I have for many years had an inordinate interest in the events surrounding July 17, 1918. On May 7, 2004, I read the fictional The Kitchen Boy, and while it was good reading I thought it would have been better if it had been wholly true. This book is purportedly wholly true and it makes for a compelling read. It has a good bibliography, but deliberately has no footnotes. The author does not even indicate things about which there is dispute so there is no way to check as to what she relates. Outside of this glaring defect the book is a good one. The site where the Czar and his family were murdered now has on it a cathedral!
irsslex on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
This is a fascinating account, told in meticulous detail, about what exactly the title of the book is: the last days of the Romanovs. It was obviously well researched, but frankly what struck me most was the vicious and cruel way that the Romanovs were ultimately disposed of. It's as if they were, to the Communists, evil incarnate, not to be accorded any humanity whatsoever.
ddelmoni on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
Helen Rappaport does an excellent job with the very last days of the Romanov family. I'd recommend this book to anyone familiar with the story and era. However, for those not familiar with the story and this era in history, I would strongly suggest they read Massie's Nicholas and Alexander first then Rappaport's The Last Days of the Romanovs for a truly complete overview of early 20th century Europe and Russia as well as the political and social circumstances that led to the Romanovs days in Ekaterinburg.
Kegsoccer on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
I freely admit to not knowing all that much about the Romanovs or their time in history. Though I must mention that my favorite Disney movie growing up was "Anastasia." I loved the idea that the girl had somehow survived the massacre.This book is an eye opening look at what really happened, and not only that, what lead up to the deaths of the Romanovs. While at times, some of the information got a bit much to handle, for the most part it was very informative. I would eagerly recommend it to those who want to learn about the Romanovs.
annesion on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
Advanced Readers CopyThis book was amazing. I have read several books on the fate of the Imperial Family, and as other reviewers have mentioned was not at first sure if yet another biographical account of the final days of the family was needed. I was proven wrong.I found Rappaport to be an excellent historian. Her use of primary sources and other previously published works melded into an easy to read and informative history of the final days of the family at Ekaterinburg. The book was divided into chapters each ostensibly designed to reflect one of the last fourteen days of life for the family, and to define the family as individuals peculiar to their place and time. The sections of the book dealing with the actual murders and the aftermath of the disposal of the bodies are described in vivid detail. These portions are extremely graphic, and are among the first that I have read that made me actually feel the real presence of reader within the context of the non-fiction narrative, much as a reader of fiction might feel. This book made me feel, and that to me is a significant achievement for words on a page.Rappaport also did a favor to those who had some knowledge of the Imperial Family prior to the reading of this volume. While spending some time describing and talking about the the vast machinations of the extended Royal Family and Imperial network as a whole, she limited these entries to only what was needed for logical flow of the narrative. The book does an excellent job of humanizing the Imperial Family. We learn the hopelessness of the eldest daughter Olga, the resigned faded specter of the Empress Alexandra, and the acquiescence and acceptance of his fate by the Czar himself.Overall this book far exceeded my expectations.
kentlibrarysuffield on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
This didn't seem to add any new information to the body of study on the Romanov assassinations. Regardless, even though the outcome is obvious it was still thoroughly researched and made for compelling reading.
caseylondon on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
A romance, a family saga, a murder mystery, and a political thriller - all of these descriptions aptly fit the story of the last Russian Tsar Nicolas Romanov and his family. Many novelists and historians have written about the family, the individual members, the time period, and even the tragic love story between Nicholas and Alexandra. Like many historical tales, the lives and deaths of the Romanovs are shrouded in myth, mystery and legend.Helen Rappaport¿s new book Last Days of the Romanovs: Tragedy at Ekaterinburg tells the story of Russia¿s royal family at Ipatiev House in July 1918 - the last residence they occupied and where they spent their final hours. It is different not only in tone from other books, but also in the specifics it addresses. She takes great effort to individualize the family members and to remind us that while royal they were people with hopes, fears and dreams. Sheltered and protected all of their lives, removed from the everyday world and hardships of ordinary Russians the family is caught in a frightening situation without the normal trappings of their wealth and privilege. While ruling Russia the Romanov¿s preferred to live simply but by virtue of their rank were entitled to opulent surroundings of their own choosing. When held by the Bolsheviks the family had no choice in their lodgings nor did they have access to their prized personal belongings or usual complement of staff. Taken from their palatial home and with hopes of being exiled the family instead are captives in five gloomy rooms. Alexy, the heir to the throne has a fatal, painful disease and his four sisters are spending their teen years not in happy youthful exuberance but in fear and with no chance to explore relationships with the opposite sex (one exception is noted in this book). Born a royal, the Tsarina is ill and perhaps a bit of a hypochondriac she is completely devastated, fearful and unprepared by the turn of events. The Tsar, always a simple and kind man who prefers exercise to affairs of state is beginning to realize that his family will not be rescued. Eyewitness accounts and a new look at the hierarchy for implementing the death penalty for the Tsar and also for the entire family is exposed by Rappaport. She also delineates why the family was included in the death sentence. Anyone who has read or seen anything about the Romanov family knows that the basement killings in July 1918 were brutal, but nothing compares to the vivid writing in this book. Nothing. But, as horrible as the deaths may have been, it is the daily life of the Romanov¿s during their time in Ekaterinburg that brings heartbreak to the reader. All the windows in their rooms were sealed so there was no light from windows ¿ nor any chance of a cool breeze. Royal dignity was displayed when even small joys were taken such as the Tsar¿s daily newspaper.Nicholas believed he was chosen by God to rule Russia. His flaw is perhaps thinking he knew what his people wanted and needed when in reality he did not nor could he understand the suffering in his country. The deaths of the Romanov family are a Russian tragedy as well. A tragedy, however, that now seems to have closure with the identification of the remains of the bodies. Rappaport¿s book does an excellent job of tracing the culpability of their deaths something that has long been in question. The research efforts that went into writing this book are very apparent. The way the research is used, however, is where the author distinguishes herself as a writer. Rappaport tells the story of the Romanovs last days as a reporter but with an historian¿s eye and heart. Facts are meshed with personalities to provide a full complement of the actual events at Ekaterinburg. This story has been told before in bits and pieces but never the ending and never so fully and perhaps never so well.
Cascadian on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
This book is a fascinating combination of true-crime reporting and historical biography, made possible by some pretty impressive research work. For obvious reasons, the Soviet state did its best to hide the truth about what really happened to the imperial family, where, and when. They did so not only by destroying the evidence, but by actively promoting disinformation, false or mistaken "eyewitnesses," and even taking advantage of the claims of "Anna Anderson," all of which still bedevil attempts to get to the bottom of these events.Much of the virtue of this book is described in the Note on Sources at the end, where Helen Rappaport describes her use of Soviet and Russian sources, many of which have not only never been available in the West, but in fact have seldom attracted notice beyond Ekaterinburg/Sverdlovsk. Although I admit to not being up to speed on all the literature on this topic, it's hard to believe there could be as complete or as thorough an investigation of the murder of the Romanovs, making use of these resources, available in English. That makes this essential reading for anyone with an interest in the Russian dynasty, in the red revolution, or in the dynamics of early Soviet government.Though the Romanov family's final days, and ultimate slaughter, are of course the focus of this book, the book also contains well-done biographical portraits of the Tsar, Tsaritsa, the four grand duchesses, and the Tsarevich Alexey that remind us the family's destruction was not only a political act but a crime against individuals (the family plus their retainers, eleven souls in total). That all makes for a book that is notable, not only for its research, but also for its storytelling. I definitely recommend it.
IncaPK More than 1 year ago
I cannot add much to the extensive reviews already written below. I do recommend the book. Though the first 90 pages of the book can seem repetitive and could have been edited, the rest of the book provides, for me anyway, fresh new details of their final weeks in Ekaterinberg. The author keeps a fast pace and builds the suspense of the chaotic preparations by the local Bolsheviks. She also highlights the tantalizing possibility that the advancing counterrevolutionary Czech army came close to rescuing the family. Her account of the actual, tragic execution is the most detailed that I have read.
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Helen Rappaport makes history's figures come alive. Get to know this tragic family in an intimate portrait. A loving but flawed family in a turbulent time.
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
At first was hard to understand but pushed through and eventually started to understand :) what a wonderful book
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Great read!
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Fast moving book. It was a great history lesson while giving us a chance to know each member of the family.
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Excellent book- very well written and engaging.