Robert is a reclusive, millionaire writer. Livy is a talented, compassionate artist. And Jason is a veteran with a complicated past and a grandmother who adores him. While learning about one another's pasts and navigating the future in Cleveland's Little Italy, the trio encounter Native American mysticism, the Cleveland Mafia, and the redemptive power of love. Never as it Seems examines what happens when three very different people learn they have far more in common than they ever could have known.