They call her the porcelain princess...
With her fragile beauty and regal bearing, the Duchess of Warneham knows how to keep her admirers at a distance. Twice wed and twice widowed, Antonia has vowed never again to marry; never again to surrender her freedom. But when her husband's death is deemed suspicious, and his long-lost heir returns to seize control of the dukedom, she finds that fate has placed her future in yet another man's hands but not just any man.
They call him a cold-hearted bastard...
Deep in London's docklands, Gareth Lloyd runs Neville Shipping with an iron fist. Unrecognizable as the starving orphan who was abandoned by his family and sent an ocean away from home, Gareth has put his troubled past behind him. That is, until the Duke of Warneham is murdered, and Gareth turns out to be the dynasty's last living heir. Wrenched from his solitude, Gareth neither wants nor needs the honors and obligations of nobility especially the Duke's all-too-tempting widow.... Or does he?
About the Author
During her frequent travels through England, Liz Carlyle always packs her pearls, her dancing slippers, and her whalebone corset, confident in the belief that eventually she will receive an invitation to a ball or a rout. Alas, none has been forthcoming. While waiting, however, she has managed to learn where all the damp, dark alleys and low public houses can be found. Liz hopes she has brought just a little of the nineteenth century alive for the reader in her popular novels, which include the trilogy of One Little Sin, Two Little Lies, and Three Little Secrets, as well as The Devil You Know, A Deal With the Devil, and The Devil to Pay. Please visit her at LizCarlyle.com, especially if you're giving a ball.
Read an Excerpt
Never Deceive a Duke
By Liz Carlyle
All right reserved.
The sun beamed down, warming the fragrant grass of Finsbury Circus. Gabriel played with his wooden animals, queuing them up across his blanket. Papa bent down, his thin, brown hand plucking one from the queue. "Gabe, what is this one called?"
Gabriel moved his tiger into the empty space. "Frederick," he said simply.
His father laughed. "No, what kind of animal is it?"
Gabriel though it a silly question. "Frederick is an elephant. You sent him to me from India."
"Yes, that's right," said Papa.
His mother laughed lightly. "Gabriel had memorized the entire animal kingdom, I think, by the time he was three, Charles. I rather doubt there is much you can teach him now."
With a sigh, Papa leaned back on the bench. "I have missed so much, Ruth," he said, taking her hand in his. "Too much -- and I am to miss a great deal more, I fear."
Mamma's face fell. "Oh, Charles, I did not mean -- " Abruptly, she drew a handkerchief from her pocket and delicately coughed into it. "Oh! I beg your pardon. I sound frightful, do I not?"
Papa frowned. "You must see to that cough as soon as I am gone, my love," he chided. "Gabriel, can you help Mamma to remember? She is to see Dr. Cohen tomorrow -- and not a moment later."
"Yes, sir." Gabriel plucked one of the monkeys from his queue and handed it to his father.
Papa balanced the monkey in hispalm. "This is for me?"
"It's Henry," said Gabriel. "He will go back to India with you. For company."
Papa tucked the monkey into his regimental jacket, then ruffled Gabriel's hair. "Thank you, Gabe," he said. "I shall miss you terribly. Are you all right here, you and Mamma, with Zayde and Bubbe?"
Gabriel nodded. His mother set her hand on Papa's knee. "It is better we continue on this way, Charles, until things settle down for us," she said softly. "Truly, it is. Do you mind terribly?"
Papa laid his hand over hers. "The only thing I would mind, my love, would be your unhappiness."
The offices of Neville Shipping along Wapping Wall were a beehive of activity, with clerks rushing up and down the stairs carrying last-minute contracts, bills of lading, insurance policies, and the occasional cup of tea. London's muggy August heat did little to calm the fervor, though every window had been thrown open to the morning breeze, which was just strong enough to carry in the stench of the Thames, and very little else.
Standing over her desk, Miss Xanthia Neville scarcely noticed the smell of putrid mud and fermenting sewage. Nor did she hear the rattle of the cooperage's carts, or the lightermen bellowing at one another along the water below. After less than a year in Wapping, she was inured to it all. But this blasted accounting -- ah, that was another matter! Exasperated, Miss Neville threw down her pencil, and raked the hair back off her face.
"Gareth?" She glanced up at a passing clerk. "Siddons, where is Gareth Lloyd? I need him at once."
Siddons nodded sharply and dashed back down the stairs. In seconds, Gareth appeared, his broad shoulders filling the doorway to the cavernous office which they shared. For a moment, he let his eyes roam her face.
"Haste makes waste, old girl," he said laconically, setting one shoulder to the door frame. "Can you not get those numbers to add up?"
"I haven't even got that far," she admitted. "I cannot find Eastley's voyage reconciliation sheets to carry over the amounts."
Slowly, he crossed the room to her desk and slid the reconciliation report from beneath the accounting papers. Xanthia's shoulders fell and her eyes rolled heavenward.
Gareth studied her quietly for a moment. "Nervous?" he finally asked. "It is understandable, Zee. By this time tomorrow, you will be a married woman."
Xanthia closed her eyes and set a protective hand over her belly; a telling, intimately feminine gesture. "I'm scared to death," she admitted. "Not of marriage -- I want that. I want Stefan desperately. It's...it's just the ceremony. The people. His brother knows everyone. And he has invited all of them. Yet I dare not put it off..."
Gareth braced a hand on the back of her chair. He did not touch her. He would never touch her again; he had sworn it -- and this time, he meant it. "You had to know, Zee, that it would come to this," he said quietly. "And this is not the worst of it. When you are Lady Nash and people discover that you have the audacity to actually work for a living, they will say -- "
"I do not work for a living!" she interjected. "I own a shipping company -- or rather, you and my family own it. All of us. Together. I just help...oversee it."
"That's an awfully thin hair to split, my dear," he said. "But I wish you success in attempting it."
She looked up at him then, her face crumpling a little. "Oh, Gareth," she said quietly. "Tell me it will be all right."
She spoke not of the marriage, he knew, but of the business, which was almost like a child to her. Indeed, it was far more important to her than he had ever been. "It will be all right, Zee," he promised. "You are not leaving on your wedding trip for another week or so. We will get all this caught up. We will hire someone if need be. I will be here every day until you come home."
She smiled faintly. "Thank you," she answered. "Oh, Gareth. Thank you. We shan't be gone long, I promise."
Then he broke his pledge not to touch her and slid one finger beneath her chin. "Please don't worry, Zee," he murmured. "Swear to me you won't. Think of the new and happy life which awaits you."
For an instant, her face brightened in a way which was attributable to only one man. "You will be there tomorrow morning, will you not?" she asked almost breathlessly. "At the church?"
He cut his gaze away. "I do not know."
"Gareth." Her voice was suddenly raw. "I need you to be there. You are my...my best friend. Please?"
But Gareth did not get the chance to answer. A faint knock sounded. Gareth turned to see an elderly, silver-haired man standing in the doorway, and their chief accounting clerk, Mr. Bakely, hovering in the shadows behind, looking gravely ill at ease.
"May we help you?" Xanthia's voice was a little impatient. It was Bakely's job to keep visitors in the counting house below, not in the management offices above.
The man stepped fully inside, allowing the sunlight to fall across his simple but well-cut suit. He wore a pair of gold spectacles and carried a burnished leather satchel. A banker from the City, Gareth guessed -- or worse, a solicitor. Whatever he was, he did not look as if he brought glad tidings.
"Miss Neville, is it?" said the man, bowing stiffly. "I am Howard Cavendish of Wilton, Cavendish and Smith in Gracechurch Street. I am looking for one of your employees. A Mr. Gareth Lloyd."
Inexplicably, the tension in the room leapt. Gareth stepped forward. "I'm Lloyd," he answered. "But you'll have to take up your legal business with our solicitors in -- "
The man lifted a staying hand. "I fear my errand is of a more personal nature," he said. "I urgently require a moment of your time."
"Mr. Lloyd is not an employee, sir, he is an owner." Xanthia's voice was haughty as she swished from behind her desk. "One generally makes an appointment in order to see him."
Surprise sketched across the solicitor's face but was quickly hidden. "Yes, I see. My apologies. Mr. Lloyd?"
Resigned to what seemed inevitable, Gareth returned to his glossy mahogany desk and motioned for the solicitor to take the leather chair opposite. The man made him deeply uneasy, and Gareth was inexplicably glad that Xanthia had just spent a small fortune refurbishing their once-shabby office, which now looked as elegant as any solicitor's might.
Mr. Cavendish flicked an uncertain gaze at Xanthia.
"It's quite all right," said Gareth. "Miss Neville and I have no secrets."
The man's dark brows flew up. "Indeed?" he murmured, snapping his leather case open. "I trust you are quite sure of that."
"Dear me!" said Xanthia sotto voce. "This sounds exciting." Curiosity etched on her face, she took the armchair to the left of Gareth's desk.
The solicitor was withdrawing a sheaf of papers from the satchel. "I must say, Mr. Lloyd, that you have proven an admirable quarry."
"I was unaware of being hunted."
"So I gather." The man's lips had an unpleasant curl, as if he found his duty distasteful. "My firm has been searching for you for some months now."
Despite his cool tone, Gareth's unease deepened. He cut a glance at Xanthia, suddenly certain he should have sent her away. Sharply, he cleared his throat. "Precisely where were you looking, Mr. Cavendish?" he asked. "Neville Shipping was headquartered in the West Indies until a few months past."
"Yes, yes, I managed to discover that," Cavendish said impatiently. "Though it took me long enough. There are not many people left in London who remember you, Mr. Lloyd. But I finally managed to locate an elderly woman in Houndsditch -- a local goldsmith's widow -- and she remembered your grandmother."
"Houndsditch?" said Xanthia incredulously. "What has this to do with you, Gareth?"
"My grandmother lived the last months of her life there," he murmured. "She had many friends, but I imagine most of them are dead now."
"Quite so." Mr. Cavendish was sorting through his papers. "The only one left was senile. She told us you had written your grandmother once -- from Bermuda, she claimed. And when that turned up nothing, she decided it was the Bahamas. Alas, no. So she decided to try another letter of the alphabet, and sent us haring off to Jamaica."
"It was Barbados," murmured Gareth.
Cavendish smiled faintly. "Yes, my clerk has practically managed to see the world whilst attempting to find you," he said. "And it has cost rather a fortune, I fear."
"How regrettable for you," said Gareth.
"Oh, I am not paying for it," said the solicitor. "You are."
"I beg your pardon?"
"Or rather, your estate is," the solicitor corrected. "I work for you."
Gareth laughed. "I'm afraid there must be some mistake."
But the solicitor had apparently found the paper he wanted, and he slid it across the desk. "Your cousin the Duke of Warneham is dead," he said flatly. "Poisoned, some say -- but dead nonetheless, most conveniently for you, Mr. Lloyd."
Xanthia was gaping at the solicitor. "The Duke of who? -- "
"Warneham," repeated the solicitor. "That is the coroner's report. Death by misadventure was the verdict, though scarcely anyone will believe it. And this is the research from the College of Arms designating you as the heir to the dukedom."
"The...what?" Gareth felt numb. Sick. There must be some mistake.
Xanthia leaned toward him. "Gareth -- ?"
But Cavendish was still speaking. "I also have several items which urgently require your signature," he continued. "Things are in rather a mess, as you might imagine. The Duke died in October of last year, and the rumors surrounding his death have only grown more speculative."
"I am sorry," said Xanthia, sharply this time. "What duke? Gareth, what is he talking about?"
Gareth pushed the papers away as if they had burst into flame. "I don't know." He felt suddenly unsteady. Angry. He had not thought of Warneham in a dozen years -- at least he had tried not to do so. And now, his death caused Gareth not the pleasure and satisfaction which he had long expected but instead just a strange, unpleasant numbness. Warneham poisoned? And now he was to inherit the dukedom? No. It was impossible.
"I think you had best be on your way, sir," he said to Cavendish. "There has been some mistake. This is a busy counting house. We have real work here to do."
The solicitor's head jerked up from his papers. "I beg your pardon," he said. "You were born Gabriel Gareth Lloyd Ventnor, were you not? Son of Major Charles Ventnor, who died in Portugal?"
"I have never denied who my father was," said Gareth. "He was a hero, and I was proud to be his son. But the rest of the Ventnor family can burn in hell so far as I am concerned."
Mr. Cavendish glowered over his gold eyeglasses. "That is the very point, Mr. Lloyd," he said impatiently. "There really is no Ventnor family. You are it. You are the eighth Duke of Warneham. Now if you would kindly turn your attention to these documents -- "
"No," Gareth firmly interjected. He glanced at Xanthia, whose eyes were wide as saucers. "No, I want nothing to do with that bastard. Nothing. Good God, how can such a thing have happened?"
"I think you know how it happened, Mr. Lloyd," said Cavendish sharply. "But we must put the past behind us, and move on, mustn't we? And by the way, the law does not permit you to refuse the dukedom. It is done. Now you may attend to your estate and your duties, or you may let it all go to rack and ruin if that is your wi -- "
"But Warneham lived a long and vigorous life," Gareth interjected, jerking to his feet. "Surely...surely there were other children, for God's sake?"
Mr. Cavendish shook his head. "No, Your Grace," he said solemnly. "Fate was not kind to the late duke."
Gareth well knew what the unkindness of fate was like -- and he had Warneham to thank for it. Was it possible the son of a bitch had got what he deserved? Gareth began to pace the floor, one hand set at the back of his neck. "Good God, this cannot be happening," he muttered. "We were barely related -- third cousins at best. Surely the law cannot permit such a thing?"
"The two of you were both great-great-grandsons of the third Duke of Warneham, who fell heroically in battle fighting for William of Orange," said the solicitor. "The third duke had twin sons -- posthumous sons -- born but minutes apart. Warneham is dead, his son Cyril predeceased him, and you are the only living blood heir of the second-born twin. Ergo, the College of Arms has determined that -- "
"I don't give two shites what the College of Arms determines," said Gareth. "I want -- "
"Gareth, your language!" Xanthia gently chided. "Now do sit down and explain all this to me. Is your last name really Ventnor? Did someone really murder your uncle?"
Just then, another dark-haired gentleman came breezing into the room, this one dressed with an almost dandyish elegance. He carried something enormous and shiny before him. "Good morning, my dears!" he sang.
His patience already tried, Gareth wheeled around. "What the devil's good about it?"
Xanthia ignored him. "Heavens, Mr. Kemble," she said, rising. "What have you there?"
"Another of his overpriced trifles, no doubt." Gareth loomed over him.
Mr. Kemble drew the object protectively away. "It's a Tang Dynasty amphora," he snipped. "Don't touch it, you philistine!"
"What is it for?" Xanthia looked disoriented.
"It is the accent piece for the marble window pedestal." Mr. Kemble waltzed across the room and delicately positioned it. "There! Perfect. I now pronounce you Fully Decorated." He spun around. "Now, pardon my intrusion. Where were we? Mr. Lloyd has offed his uncle, has he? I am not surprised."
"I misspoke," said Xanthia. "It was a cousin, perhaps?" Swiftly, she introduced Kemble to the solicitor.
"And I haven't 'offed' anyone," snapped Gareth.
"Actually, we looked into that," said the solicitor dryly. "Mr. Lloyd has the perfect alibi. He was in the middle of the Atlantic Ocean at the time."
Xanthia seemed oblivious to the sarcasm. "And the most shocking thing, Mr. Kemble!" She laid a hand on his coat sleeve. "Gareth is going to be a duke!"
"Oh, good God, Zee!" Gareth felt his blood begin to boil. "Just hush, please."
"I am perfectly serious," she said, still addressing Kemble. "Gareth has a secret duke in his family."
"Yes, well, don't we all." Mr. Kemble smiled tightly. "Which one is yours?"
"Warnley," said Xanthia swiftly.
"Warneham," corrected the solicitor.
"Neither of them," said Gareth grimly. "Cavendish here is going to have to shake this family tree until another monkey falls out."
Mr. Kemble lifted his hands. "Well, I cannot help you with this one, old fellow," he said to Gareth. "C'est la vie, non? Now, my dears, I really must run. I wouldn't have barged in at all -- but the mention of a murder was too delicious to ignore. I'll get the gory bits later."
"Thank you again for the lovely decorating, Mr. Kemble," said Xanthia.
The dapper gentleman paused to snatch Xanthia's hand, and bowed over it. "I shall wait to kiss this until tomorrow on the portico of St. George's, my dear," he said, "when I may properly call you the Marchioness of Nash."
At that, the solicitor seemed to sit a little straighter in his chair. "I beg your pardon," he said as Mr. Kemble vanished. "Do I gather that congratulations are in order?"
Xanthia blushed. "I am to be married in the morning."
Just then, another shadow appeared at the door. Gareth looked up in frustration. "I do beg your pardon, sir," said Mr. Bakely. "We've just had a rider up from Woolwich. The Margaret Jane has been spotted coming up the Blackwall Reach."
Xanthia pressed her hand to her chest. "Oh, thank God!"
"About bloody time," said Gareth, shoving back his chair with a sharp scrape.
"Do you wish her to put into the West India Docks, sir?" Bakely pressed. "Or shall she come upriver?"
"She's to put in," said Gareth urgently. "And send round for my gig. You and I will go down and see how bad things are."
Xanthia, too, had risen. "I apologize, Mr. Cavendish," she said. "As intriguing as your story is -- and I confess, I am indeed agog -- we must see to the Margaret Jane at once. She's been three months at port in Bridgetown, and lost a third of her crew to typhus. We are gravely concerned, as I am sure you can understand?"
"You are not going down there, Zee." Gareth's voice was stern. He was already drawing on his driving coat, oblivious to anything but the duty before him.
Xanthia's hand returned instinctively to her belly. "No, I suppose I oughtn't." She smiled at Mr. Cavendish, and with grave reluctance, he, too, rose.
"But what am I to do with the ducal papers?" he asked.
Intent on collecting his things, Gareth said nothing.
"Just leave them on Mr. Lloyd's desk," Xanthia suggested. "I am sure he will review them later."
Mr. Cavendish looked irritated. "But we have a number of pressing issues," he protested. "His Grace's attention is direly needed."
Xanthia smiled gently. "Do not despair, sir," she murmured. "Gareth will do his duty. He always has. And I have every confidence he shall handle whatever problems you set before him with his usual cool competence."
The solicitor paid her scant heed. "Sir," he said to the back of Gareth's head, "this really cannot be put off."
Gareth snatched a ledger from the bookshelf. "I'll be back in an hour or two," he said to Xanthia. "I shall give Captain Barrett your regards."
"Wait, Your Grace!" said the solicitor a little plaintively now. "You are expected at Selsdon Court immediately. Really, sir! The duchess awaits."
"The duchess?" said Xanthia.
Cavendish ignored her. "Everything has been left hanging, sir," the solicitor insisted. "It really cannot wait any longer."
"It will bloody well have to," said Gareth, without looking at them. "Indeed, it can hang 'til Kingdom Come, so far as I care."
"Really, sir! This is unconscionable!"
"Blood does not make a man, Cavendish," Gareth snapped. "Indeed, it is more often his undoing." He thundered down the stairs behind Bakely without another word.
Xanthia ushered the solicitor to the door. He looked down at her, his brows drawn sharply together. "I really cannot comprehend this," he murmured. "He is the duke. Surely he realizes his good fortune? He is now a peer of the realm -- one of England's wealthiest, in fact."
"Gareth possesses a self-confidence which can sometimes seem abrasive, Mr. Cavendish," she answered. "He is a self-made man -- and yet money means very little to him."
Both concepts were clearly beyond Cavendish's grasp. After a few more murmured platitudes, Xanthia at last got the solicitor out the door. At the top of the steps, however, a question struck her. "Mr. Cavendish," she said, "might I ask, who is believed to have wished the duke dead? Are there...suspects? Any hope of an arrest?"
The solicitor shook his head. "As with most powerful men, the Duke had enemies," he admitted. "As to suspects, the rumormongers have regrettably targeted his widow."
Xanthia felt her eyes widen. "Good Lord! Poor woman -- if, indeed, she is innocent?"
"I believe that she is," said the solicitor. "And the coroner believed it. Moreover, the duchess is from a powerful family. No one dares accuse her too loudly -- not without evidence."
"Still, in English society, the mere whisper of scandal..." Xanthia felt suddenly chilled, and shook her head. "The duchess must be ruined."
"Very near it, I daresay," said Cavendish sadly.
The solicitor went down the steps, his fine leather satchel in hand, looking a good deal wearier than he had upon his arrival. Xanthia's head seemed to be spinning. Quietly, she closed the office door and set her forehead to the cool, well-polished wood.
What on earth had just happened? What had Gareth Lloyd been hiding all these years? Something a little more serious than a miserable childhood, apparently. But Gareth a duke?
Then she jerked her head up. Her brother Kieran might know the truth. Abruptly, she crossed the room, rang the bell, and began to haphazardly stuff the contents of her desktop into her bulging leather satchel.
"Send for my carriage," she said to the young clerk who cracked open the door. "I am going to take luncheon with Lord Rothewell."
Copyright 2007 by Susan Woodhouse
Excerpted from Never Deceive a Duke by Liz Carlyle Copyright © 2007 by Liz Carlyle. Excerpted by permission.
All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher.
Excerpts are provided by Dial-A-Book Inc. solely for the personal use of visitors to this web site.
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
Never Deceive a Duke Liz Carlyle Pocket, Aug 2007, $7.50 ISBN 9781416527152 With the Napoleonic Wars part of the history books, shipping has returned somewhat to normal. Thus part owner of Neville Shipping, Gareth Lloyd, is doing quite well. However, he soon learns he has inherited the ducal estate that has driven him to succeed in obtaining wealth. Gareth deems it acrimoniously ironic that he is now the Duke of Warneham as the previous recipient of the title, his grandfather, exiled Gareth when he was the child Gabriel to a harsh life. He considers ignoring the title, but reluctantly visits his new country estate, Selsdon Court. There he meets his predecessor¿s young widow, Antonia, who some suspect poisoned her elderly husband. They are attracted to one another, but both suffer from demons and besides neither trust the other as he considers whether she is a black widow and she wonders why his family disowned him. Meanwhile she still grieves the death of her daughter while he faces the same anti-Jewish bias that sent him away as a child. --- The second ¿Never¿ a fabulous late regency romance that stars two likable individuals who hide their soft interior with an acerbic armor as both learned early in life to trust no one although Xanthia and Kieran (see NEVER LIE TO A LADY) has pierced Gareth¿s shield as they treat him like an adored brother. The story line is fast-paced with the changing relationship between Antonia and Gabriel, as only she calls him, being the prime plot supported by an investigation into the death of the previous duke and enhanced by the religious prejudice suffered by Jews. Liz Carlyle provides a fresh historical that showcases why she is consistently one of the sub-genre¿s best. --- Harriet Klausner
Couldn't put it down! Wonderful love story, as usual.
If anything, Liz Carlyle can certainly write. Even when the story she tells isn¿t quite as well put together, her prose sweeps you up and places you right in the minds of her characters. Never Deceive a Duke picks up right after Never Lie to a Lady, after Gareth Lloyd¿s unrequited love, Xanthia Neville, heroine of NLL, has been married off to Lord Nash. Gareth isn¿t too pleased, and things just keep getting worse when he finds out he¿s inherited a dukedom upon the death of his cousin. There¿s bad blood between Gareth and the former duke, which comprises a twisted family history of murder(s), anti-Semitism, betrayal, and abuse. Gareth has tried to put all that behind him, embracing his life as a shipping magnate and unofficially adopted brother to Xanthia and her brother ¿ they¿re all three of them joint owners of Neville Shipping. Gareth¿s tortured past comes rushing painfully back to him once he¿s forced to very reluctantly join the unwelcoming aristocracy and assume responsibility for his estate. This includes meeting and deciding what to do about the dowager duchess, the former duke¿s widow, Antonia. She happens to have a whole boatload of baggage of her own, which makes them quite a depressed/depressing pair. Never Deceive a Duke is a pretty good read. Its pacing falters at times, but not too badly. There¿s a murder mystery, which develops into several murder mysteries, actually, and this aspect of the plot seemed well constructed. Though things did a little complicated near the end, when it seemed like everyone and their mother had been murdered at some point. The ubiquitous George Kemble makes an appearance here. He¿s called in to do all the dirty work and get to the bottom of the former duke¿s death. There have been nasty rumors that Antonia did him in for her own gain, and Gareth, having instantly taken a shine to her, wants her name cleared. I love George Kemble. He¿s hilarious, but still chillingly dangerous, and steals the show every time. As for the romance, it was unbalanced at best. Gareth I really liked. He¿s a very tortured guy. The flashbacks prefacing each chapter provide powerful, moving vignettes of his childhood, the difficulties of being raised between two worlds, neither fully Jewish, nor accepted into the English aristocracy. I¿ve never come across a Jewish hero before, and I think that through the flashbacks this aspect of his character was well drawn. He¿s a unique character. The extent and depth of his pain, what he¿s suffered, isn¿t readily apparent. The way in which his character is thus layered and gradually explored was skillfully handled, and my favorite part of the book. Gareth quietly suffers throughout, never wallowing in self pity. He¿s a very strong, very appealing hero. Antonia, while equally tortured, is more pathetic than noble in her suffering. She¿s basically a depressed, shattered, shadow of her former self, having undergone a nervous breakdown and been committed to an insane asylum. This was before her marriage to the former duke, which took place barely a year after her first husband¿s death, which had precipitated her mental collapse. She¿s also exiled from society because of all the nasty murder rumors. I thought it was really interesting to have a heroine purported to be mad, after coming across so many supposedly mad heroes. Maybe madness is sexier in men or something¿ who knows. Either way, Antonia fits into the woman in white role perfectly ¿ fragile, not quite all there, sad, weak, and broken. Unfortunately, the romance suffers for her overriding weakness, because Gareth has to take care of her the whole time, despite her protestations that she¿s getting stronger and starting to know her own mind. Their conversations sound like therapy sessions as Gareth dispenses pearls of wisdom and tries to piece Antonia back together. (I have to mention, even though it¿s nitpicking, that their conversations bugged the hell out of me though because Gare
Unfortunately, I didn't enjoy this book as much as everyone else did. This was my first from Carlyle, and I don't think I care for this author's style very much. She writes like a modern American writing a Regency novel, e.g. the hero Gareth keeps reiterating over and over the value of working and that life is meaningless without work, etc. This just would not have been present in England at that time. Likewise the heroine's many reflections on the situation of her fellow women, even as she explains to her servant that "she must behave appropriately" in a very June Cleaver fashion. These moments kept jarring me from the storytelling, and the duchess came off as nothing more than an archetype, shallowly developed. We know she's resistant to her lot in life because this is conveyed not-so-subtly when she keeps becoming flustered and "flushing" or otherwise lapsing in the ladylike composure that is so obviously important to her. Needless to say, this cannot power a character through three or four hundred pages. We need a little more, a heartbeat perhaps, and I got the impression her flustered routine continued a long while. As anothe reviewer wrote, she's just needy (that's the entirety of her character). I liked Gareth, but he's misplaced here for the reasons I mentioned before. I also thought if the author took the time to establish in flashbacks that Gareth comes from a partly Jewish heritage and that his childhood suffered because of it that the flashbacks should have been connected to the present at one point, perhaps mentioning his difficulties in the present, or else they seem somewhat aimless. It would have been more useful for the flashbacks to center around his ship experiences in that case, which seem to have affected him strongly (and to tell from his repeated mentions of it, continue to affect him). The dialogue and some of the secondary characters felt as if the writer had done her research watching Disney's adaptation of the times. I can suspend disbelief, and I can read less faithful reimaginings of the period. I don't mind-- but it's a little difficult when a novel takes itself so seriously while an anachronism entirely powers a character's motivations. It's a little hard to ignore. Most likely, I wouldn't have caught onto this if the romance were less limp (or just the heroine), if there were heat, tension, whatever you call it. Gareth was too strong to credibly fall for this kind of heroine. But there you have it. Sorry, folks, I know a lot of people read her.((Note: If you'd like to read an author who's done her research and, whether from exposure or from education and an open mind, can write British and French characters believably without them becoming caricatures, I recommend Joanne Bourne's The Spymaster's Lady. I'm reading it now and I love it.))
Good story, good twists, too much sex.
Graphic child sexual abuse
This was a really good read. I highly recommend it.
This story was full of romance, life long pain getting resolved ( childhood sexual abuse, rejection, loosing family, being Jewish in England but never fully belonging anywhere....) as well as a multiple deaths hanging overhead! Wow and a feel good love story budding! Gareth/Gabriel got his story told - a book worth reading! Looking forward to the next one in this series.
It's definitely well written book . Other reviews already provided many details of the story line . Numbers of serious problems have been not just mentioned but got developed . Regarding "too much sex" , if I may I would like to give it my own understanding of its meaning in this romance . The first time it was not like something between the Duke and Duchess , but like the salvation of two lonely souls in extremely difficult situation . Both main characters are such complicated that love and marriage are far away from their plans . But first bite of the apple was done , and memory of it and curiosity would bring them together soon . They tried to convince themselves that it's for body pleasure only . In reality they discover each other during intimate scenes . And then comes love that makes them stronger and whole . So, don't worry about sex . You would not be drown in it . There so much more in this book, including mystery . I feel confident about recommend this book . I 'm going to read Gabriel 's friends ' stories now . G.K.