Keith Ansell-Pearson, Journal of Nietzsche Studies
"Dirk R. Johnson Nietzsche's Anti-Darwinism not only argues for the validity of its main thesis, but also presents a valuable overview and critique of the historiography surrounding its subject matter. It will most likely become an important text to contend with, for or against, in future scholarship ... a welcome addition to the scholarship surrounding one of the most penetrating critiques of science to emerge from the nineteenth century."
Benjamin Mitchell, Isis
"... the book contains acute and careful readings of a number of Nietzsche's texts, especially the Genealogy, and displays an impressive command of the Nietzsche-Darwin scholarship. It is geared toward those interested in Nietzsche studies, nineteenth century philosophy of biology in general, and the Nietzsche-Darwin connection in particular."
David Storey, Environmental Philosophy
"Johnson presents readers with a tightly argued case regarding "the pre-eminence of Darwin for the development and articulation of Nietzsche's philosophy" ..."
Matthew Day, The Quarterly Review of Biology
"In this readable account, Dirk R. Johnson, associate professor of modern languages at Hampden-Sydney College, disputes a long tradition in which scholars deemed Friedrich Nietzsche's ideas compatible with Darwinism."
Christopher Cumo, Canadian Journal of History
"... well-written ... it is a major study and stands out for its methodological juxtaposition of both American and continental scholarship on Nietzsche ... needs to be read by everybody interested in both Darwin and Nietzsche, but also and perhaps especially by those who would like to see a closer engagement between the various global paradigms of Nietzsche research."
Christian Benne, Orbis Litterarum
"... a significant contribution to the understanding of the role of Darwinism in Nietzsche's thought and future work in this area will have to engage with it."
Ruth Burch, The European Legacy