No Closure: Catholic Practice and Boston's Parish Shutdowns

No Closure: Catholic Practice and Boston's Parish Shutdowns

by John C. Seitz


View All Available Formats & Editions
Members save with free shipping everyday! 
See details


In 2004 the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Boston announced plans to close or merge more than eighty parish churches. Scores of Catholics—28,000, by the archdiocese’s count—would be asked to leave their parishes. The closures came just two years after the first major revelations of clergy sexual abuse and its cover up. Wounds from this profound betrayal of trust had not healed.

In the months that followed, distraught parishioners occupied several churches in opposition to the closure decrees. Why did these accidental activists resist the parish closures, and what do their actions and reactions tell us about modern American Catholicism? Drawing on extensive fieldwork and with careful attention to Boston’s Catholic history, Seitz tells the stories of resisting Catholics in their own words, and illuminates how they were drawn to reconsider the past and its meanings. We hear them reflect on their parishes and the sacred objects and memories they hold, on the way their personal histories connect with the history of their neighborhood churches, and on the structures of authority in Catholicism.

Resisters describe how they took their parishes and religious lives into their own hands, and how they struggled with everyday theological questions of respect and memory; with relationships among religion, community, place, and comfort; and with the meaning of the local church. No Closure is a story of local drama and pathos, but also a path of inquiry into broader questions of tradition and change as they shape Catholics’ ability to make sense of their lives in a secular world.

Product Details

ISBN-13: 9780674053021
Publisher: Harvard
Publication date: 06/14/2011
Pages: 322
Product dimensions: 6.20(w) x 9.40(h) x 1.10(d)

About the Author

John C. Seitz is Assistant Professor of Theology and Associate Director for Lincoln Center of the Francis and Ann Curran Center for American Catholic Studies at Fordham University.

Table of Contents

Introduction: Closings 1

1 The Pasts Living in People 40

2 Divergent Histories: Change and the Making of Resistors, 1950-2004 81

3 "What do we have?" Locales and Objects in the Hands of the People of God 131

4 "This is unrest territory": Orthodoxy and Opposition in Resistors' Practice of the Parish 174

5 Openings 213

Epilogue 234

Notes 251

Acknowledgments 305

Index 309

What People are Saying About This

Amy Koehlinger

A compelling ethnography. Seitz is present, but never overwhelms the voices and perspectives of the Catholics at the center of the story. A fine history of Boston's parishes and neighborhoods and a nuanced portrait of the complex legacy of the Second Vatican Council in modern Catholic life.
Amy Koehlinger, Florida State University

Customer Reviews