A cruel prank leads to devastating consequences that leaves her feeling partly to blame. The question "What if?" haunts her waking hours and creates taunting nightmares. Guilt is a heavy burden, and even Maddie's faith is slipping as she faces the biggest test of her life. Her friends don't understand and just want her to snap out of it. She's always been their rock, the sensible one. Events lead her down a dark path until one event in the high school cafeteria forces her to choose. Sit back and watch or stand up and do something. Her decision and more importantly the outcome impacts all of the students at Victory High.