The Primal Teen: What the New Discoveries about the Teenage Brain Tell Us about Our Kids
The Primal Teen: What the New Discoveries about the Teenage Brain Tell Us about Our Kids

The Primal Teen: What the New Discoveries about the Teenage Brain Tell Us about Our Kids

by Barbara Strauch

Hardcover(Library Binding)

1 New & Used Starting at $3.35


A groundbreaking look at the teenage brain for anyone who has puzzled over the mysterious and often infuriating behavior of a teenager.
While many members of the scientific community have long held that the growing pains of adolescence are primarily psychological, Barbara Strauch highlights the physical nature of the transformation, offering parents and educators a new perspective on erratic teenage behavior. Using plain language, Strauch draws upon the latest scientific discoveries to make the case that the changes the brain goes through during adolescence are as dramatic and crucial as those that take place in the first two years of life, and that teenagers are not entirely responsible for their sullen, rebellious, and moody ways. Featuring interviews with scientists, teenagers, parents, and teachers, The Primal Teen explores common challenges–why teens go from articulate and mature one day to morose and unreachable the next, why they engage in risky behavior–and offers practical strategies to help manage these formative and often difficult years.

Product Details

ISBN-13: 9781439559215
Publisher: Baker & Taylor, CATS
Publication date: 10/08/2008
Pages: 242
Product dimensions: 4.75(w) x 8.25(h) x 0.75(d)

About the Author

Barbara Strauch, was a reporter and newspaper editor who directed health and science coverage for The New York Times for a decade. Prior to joining The New York Times, she had covered science and medical issues in Boston and Houston and directed Pulitzer Prize-winning news at Newsday. She was also the author of two books about the brain.
Barbara Strauch died in 2015 at the age of 63.

Read an Excerpt

Chapter 1

Crazy by Design

The New Science of the Teenage Brain

Teen. Brain. Brain. Teen. The words, I concede, go more tongue in cheek than hand in hand. Utter them out loud--mention even that you're writing a book on the teenage brain--and the jokes come popping out, like pimples before a prom.

"What? They have one?"

"Short book."

Steve, the father of two teenage boys, shook his head and wished me luck. As far as he could tell, the teenage brains he knew had recently and inexplicably gone berserk.

"I don't get it," he said. "All of a sudden strange things are happening with the kids we know. These are good kids, bright kids, but the other day one stole some calculators from the high school and sold them, another can't finish any homework. Getting my own kids out the door in the morning now is this monumental thing. What's going on?"

Denise, a writer and the mother of two lovely teenage boys, was ferocious.

"Teenage brain? I'll tell you teenage brain," she told me one morning. "You know my thirteen-year-old? Well, he went to the school dance, and the rule is you have to stay inside and you can't leave. But he and his friends decided they were imprisoned, and so they went outside and ran in a big circle around the gym. Who knows what they were thinking, but the principal found out and called my husband at home. The next day, we talked and talked; we told him he had to apologize, that he had inconvenienced everyone. But he just couldn't get it; he couldn't get outside himself to understand things from someone else's point of view."

And what was next from this thirteen-year-old, a straight-A kid who never caused a speck of trouble before and who, as his mother says, "used to be so meticulous and quiet and sweet?"

One evening, Denise came home from work and found three letters waiting for her: One said her son had, as expected, been put on the honor roll, the second said he'd made all-county orchestra, and the third said he was being suspended from school after being caught hanging around downtown when he was supposed to be in history class.

"You look at them and sometimes they're so articulate and they seem so grown up and you think they have all the pieces, but sometimes they just don't," said Denise. "I have to say that I believed, smugly, that only irresponsible, self-absorbed jerks had children who got into trouble. But something always happens. It's annoying; it's scary; it can make you crazy."

As the mother of two teenage girls, I don't quibble with this. Annoying stuff happens, scary stuff happens. It can make you crazy.

One morning not long ago my oldest daughter, then fifteen, got up (at noon) and to my delight--without being asked!--cleaned her room and lugged her laundry to the washing machine.

Then, as the rinse cycle whirred and we talked in the living room--I suggested that it wasn't such a great idea to take her new CD player to an amusement park with water rides--she morphed, she mutated. Shooting up off the couch--in full-tilt pubescent display--she stomped upstairs, flinging over her shoulder the battle cry of the teenage warrior goddess, circa 2003: "You suck!"

The world, of course, has been trying to figure out teenagers for centuries. Their behavior has baffled the best of our thinkers. Aristotle said teenagers appeared "fickle in their desires," which are as "transitory as they are vehement." Shakespeare, Romeo and Juliet aside, described adolescence as largely a time for "getting wenches with child, wronging the ancientry, stealing, fighting." And, if he spoke of their brains at all, which was rare, he dismissed them as "boiled."

The first whiff from those boiled brains can be subdued, even subtle.

Rhona, the mother of two teenagers in New Jersey, knew her daughter Susannah was a teenager simply because she "became embarrassed about the music I had on in the car." Bill, the father of two teenage girls in a small town in New York, says he knew adolescence had arrived when one of his daughters didn't speak to him for a week. Ron, the father of four teenagers in Phoenix, always knew one of his kids had hit adolescence when they started spending a lot of time in the bathroom.

Other times, the whiffs become shock waves.

One father in Minneapolis was aghast when his straitlaced son was caught painting graffiti on the side of a store; a mother in Princeton got a call one spring afternoon from the local police who said her well-behaved fourteen-year-old daughter had stolen a T-shirt from the mall; a mother and father were in tears when their beautiful fifteen-year-old daughter sneaked out her window at midnight to meet a twenty-four-year-old man she'd just met.

For Ellen in New York City, the mother of twin boys, the adolescent wave that swept into her house was abrupt, swift, and "horrible." It arrived about the time her sons were in the seventh grade. "To me it was a return to the terrible twos," she told me. "The tantrums, the stomping of feet, the slamming of doors, the fighting, the name-calling, the animalistic behavior. All of a sudden they got very good at evasive behavior, experts at keeping secrets. Their rooms were a mess, their bodies were clean but they had laundry all over the floor. They became very rude and the self-involvement was breathtaking. It was cosmos-annihilating narcissism, that's what it was."

One son tiptoed out of the family's apartment late at night and somehow got himself to New Jersey with his friends; the other--both boys are quite smart--was caught after he hacked into a university computer system. One--no need to say which--managed to make LSD in the high school science lab.

"Believe me, it was a struggle," said Ellen. "I knew all about how teenagers were supposed to be, but still, it knocked me out."

Teenagers themselves are often surprised at how rapidly their world changes, in all sorts of ways. Lisa, a fourteen-year-old girl from Minneapolis who plays lacrosse and actually likes studying Latin, told me it seemed that "all of a sudden" her moods "were all over the place."

"Sometimes, I just get overwhelmed now," she said. "There's all this friend stuff and school and how I look and my parents. I just go in my room and shut the door. My parents want to talk to me, and I don't mean to be mean, but sometimes I just have to go away and calm down by myself."

This is not to say that all teenagers are alike. Parents often describe at least one child, more if the gods smiled, who just seemed to sail through adolescence. But for most teenagers, blessed with natural curiosity and transversing unknown emotional, physical, and hormonal lands, something usually happens, nothing malicious, nothing illegal, just something.

"I get in trouble a lot more now, but it's for stuff I really didn't mean," said Martin, fifteen. "I forget to call home. I don't know why. I just hang out with friends, and I get involved with that and I forget. Then my parents get really mad, and then I get really mad, and it's a big mess."

What's Going On?

So what's really happening? Why do normal, well-behaved teenagers start pouting in their rooms, sneaking out windows, stomping their feet, or making LSD in the school science lab? For many years, the answer had been simple: hormones, the raging hormones of adolescence.

I remember, not long ago, going to an orientation for my daughter when she was entering sixth grade, and listening to the white-haired principal get a good laugh when he told the crowd of jittery parents sitting in front of him on folding chairs: "Don't worry, we know that all the growth in these middle school years goes on--from the neck down."

He was only partly right. No question, there's unmistakable activity from the neck down in the teenage years. No question, testosterone is there skateboarding down the railings; estrogen is throwing her hips around.

But that's not the whole story.

For the first time now, scientists are starting to look beyond hormones to explain teenage behavior. And they're finding clues in an unexpected place: the teenage brain, the boiled, besmirched--and decidedly above the neck--teenage brain.

For years it was thought that the teenage brain was finished, cooked. Most of the truly important human brain development, scientists believed, was over by the first three years of life. Explaining teenagers has been the job of social scientists, psychologists, psychiatrists, educators, and maybe a priest or two, not neuroscientists. What possible interest could still lurk behind those pierced eyebrows, under that orange-spiked hair?

As it turns out, a whole lot.

In unprecedented work, scientists are discovering exactly how the teenage brain works. Using powerful new brain-scanning machines, peering for the first time into living, working teenage brains, coordinating work across countries and across continents, drawing on pioneering work with adolescent primates and even rats, the neuroscientists are finding that the teenage brain, far from being an innocent bystander to hormonal hijinks, is undergoing a dramatic transformation.

The teenage brain, it's now becoming clear, is still very much a work in progress, a giant construction project. Millions of connections are being hooked up; millions more are swept away. Neurochemicals wash over the teenage brain, giving it a new paint job, a new look, a new chance at life. The teenage brain is raw, vulnerable. It's a brain that's still becoming what it will be.

"We used to think that, if there were brain changes at all in adolescence, they were subtle," Elizabeth Sowell, a neuroscientist at UCLA and one of the country's top researchers of the adolescent brain, told me. "Now we know that those changes are not as subtle as we thought. Every time we look at another set of teenage brains, we find something new."

And this growing group of neuroscientists--in some cases with teenagers of their own they need to figure out--are uncovering clues that can help us all understand why teenagers do what they do, zeroing in on what the normal, average teenage brain might be up to during what one normal, average seventeen-year-old-girl described as her "brief insanity."

The portrait is far from one-dimensional.

The teenage brain may, in fact, be briefly insane. But, scientists say, it is crazy by design. The teenage brain is in flux, maddening and muddled. And that's how it's supposed to be.

And the teenage brain is also wondrous. It's the brains of teenagers, after all, that begin to grapple with our knottiest, most abstract concepts, with honesty and justice. In the neuronal nooks and crannies of their evolving brains, teenagers, for the first time, develop true empathy. They may find themselves, often to their own surprise, happy to stay up until three a.m. to listen to a friend in trouble, worrying about the children in war-torn Afghanistan, or passionately falling in love with the nuances of a poem.

"I love teenagers," said a mother whose two children had successfully navigated their teenage years. "I like their intelligence and their growing ability to think for themselves, to argue intelligently, and get excited by ideas. I like sharing books with them and I like the way they can show me things, like how to use a Palm Pilot. And I like their sense of style."

In their own way, the brain scientists, too, have detected this polysided adolescence, a normal brain evolution that includes moments of mayhem as well as growing precision and passion. Inside the teenagers' brains--smart ones, shy ones, silly ones--they've found, and this word comes from the neuroscientists' own ungainly language, exuberance.

Chapter 2

The Passion Within

Peering into the Living Brain in Search of Normal

Nora loped through the clinic door, her long brown hair with a wide purple streak flowing behind her. In recent years, Nora Berenstain had survived a move from Sacramento to Washington, D.C., her parents' divorce, and a horrific seventh grade when her best friend moved away.

Now sixteen, Nora was confident and instantly likable. She volunteered at NOW headquarters and helped edit the school paper. Wearing faded jeans and a flowered shirt, she flopped her tall, thin body down on a chair and burst out: "How ya doin', Dr. Giedd?"

David and Matthew Goldstein, thirteen-year-old twins, came next, bounding in like matching soccer balls. It was their first time at the clinic and they blurted nervous questions. "This machine, what exactly is it going to do, Dr. Giedd?" asked Matthew.

Dr. Jay Giedd, the forty-year-old neuroscientist at the National Institutes of Health (NIH) who they'd come to see, is one of a small group of scientists who have recently discovered that the brains of regular, average teenagers like Nora and David and Matthew are far different from what anyone had imagined.

A child psychiatrist, a neuroscientist, and the father of four young kids himself, Giedd is originally from North Dakota. He has an open, round face, a short red beard, and he grinned broadly as each teenager arrived at his clinic trying, with one of his corny North Dakota jokes, to get them to laugh." Oh, I love your hair," he told Nora when he saw her purple streak. He patted his own balding head. "I wish I had enough to do that."

Tuesdays are brain-scanning nights at the National Institutes of Health. Giedd, one of the country's top brain scanners, had come to the basement room of Building 10 on the NIH campus, as he had every Tuesday from five to midnight, to engage in his latest passion: Trying to understand the normal teenager.

Teenagers usually come to the big brick buildings of the National Institutes of Health because they're sick. On the third floor of Building 10, there are beds filled with glassy-eyed children diagnosed with schizophrenia. But the teenagers who come down the long, white corridors to the basement room of Building 10 on Tuesday nights are not sick. Purpled-haired and baggy-panted, they're as normal and ordinary and healthy as possible. Volunteered by parents, lured by the $60 per visit they're paid, they arrive and, in the name of science, stick their heads into a big, noisy MRI brain-scanning machine.

Giedd has been putting kids' heads in this machine for ten years, scanning and rescanning the brains of hundreds of children and teenagers. It's the world's first such long-term study of brain development in normal kids and it has produced extraordinary results, the ripples of which extend far beyond any individual teenager and any individual brain and--for parents and neuroscientists alike--are likely to change the way we think about teenagers forever.

One big stumbling block in studying the brains of teenagers has been that relatively few of them die. As far as studying human brains go, it's far easier for scientists to get their hands on the brain of a baby or a grandmother than that of a fourteen-year-old. Studying the development of the adolescent animal brain, too, has not been easy. Unlike in humans, adolescence in animals is often, as one biologist put it, "over in an eye blink," making serious long-term study difficult.

Beyond that, there's been the overreaching issue of boredom. Teenage brains were thought to be largely finished, as far as serious, interesting neural development went. The only big thing happening in adolescence, as far as anyone knew, involved those pesky hormones, hair and pimples, all that.

Reading Group Guide

1. For many years, most people thought the adolescent brain was finished, cooked, just sitting there waiting for all that Chaucer, all that calculus, all that parental caution to pour in. Now, as Strauch writes, we are finding that’s not the case. In fact, the teenage brain is still a work in progress, first bursting with new growth and then pruning back brain cells and brain branches, a process that continues well into a person’s twenties. Does this surprise you?

2. The main explanation for a lot of teenage behavior has been the rampaging hormones of adolescence that bring on moods and misbehavior. Is it also possible that teens misbehave and ignore parental authority and advice because their brains are not fully grown? What influence do you think hormones have on behavior?

3. One of the places that is still under construction in the teenage brain, according to the research outlined in The Primal Teen, is the prefrontal cortex, the area that helps us see consequences of our actions and enables us to plan ahead. Could this be one reason that teenagers often do not seem to see the full consequences of their actions? Is this just another excuse for teenage behavior or does it help us to understand why they act the way they do?

4. As Strauch reports, a number of scientists have suggested that teenagers may not see the world as we see it and may respond with different areas of their brain. In particular, in stressful situations, they may respond more quickly with their more primal, emotional part of their brain because the frontal cortex, the more rational part, is not yet fully wired. If this is so, are there ways, as parents or teachers, that we can adjust our responses to teenagers?

5. Does the lack of a fully functioning prefrontal cortex contribute to a teenager’s attraction to and assessment of risk?

6. Because the brain is still changing so dramatically in young people, new research shows that heavy drinking and drug taking may damage memory functions in the brain. And, in addition, negative experiences such as bullying or abuse can permanently reshape the pathways of the brain. What can be done in schools and at home to combat this?

7. Why don’t teenagers seem to listen? Is it true that teenagers have a difficult time holding onto several instructions at once? One neuroscientist has found that it helps, when dealing with her teenagers, to ask them to do one thing at a time, rather than tell them to brush their hair, clean up their rooms, and empty the dishwasher–and being met with the stare of inaction.

8. If we are dealing with a developing brain–one that is not the same as an adult’s–at what point can we assume that the brain is mature enough to be held responsible in the same way adults are held responsible? Do you think that this new brain science will just be used as another excuse to go easy on teenagers?

9. Are there some aspects of adolescence–the teen sense of humor, the increasing ability of teenagers to understand abstract concepts–that we should focus more on and, instead of despairing, actually celebrate?

10. Is the news that a teenager’s brain is still developing a basically hopeful message? Why?

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

See All Customer Reviews