This book examines the underlying assumptions and implications of how we conceptualise and investigate poverty. The empirical entry point for such inquiry is a series of research initiatives that have used mixed method, combined qualitative and quantitative, or Q-Squared ( Q2) approaches, to poverty analysis. The Q2 literature highlights the vast range of analytical tools within the social sciences that may be used to understand and explain social phenomena, along with interesting research results. This literature serves as a lens to probe issues about knowledge claims made in poverty debates concerning who are the poor (identification analysis) and why they are poor (causal analysis). Implicitly or explicitly, questions are raised about the reasons for emphasising different dimensions of poverty and favouring different units of knowledge, the basis for distinguishing valid and invalid claims, the meaning of causation, and the nature of causal inference, and so forth. Q2 provides an entry point to address foundational issues about assumptions underlying approaches to poverty, and applied issues about the strengths and limitations of different research methods and the ways they may be fruitfully combined. Together, the strands of this inquiry make a case for methodological pluralism on the grounds that knowledge is partial, empirical adjudication imperfect, social phenomena complex, and mixed methods add value for understanding and explanation. Ultimately, the goals of understanding and explanation are best served if research questions dictate the choice of methodological approach rather than the other way around.
|Publisher:||Oxford University Press, USA|
|Product dimensions:||6.10(w) x 9.10(h) x 0.50(d)|
About the Author
Paul Shaffer, Associate Professor, Department of International Development Studies, Trent University, Canada
Paul Shaffer is a professor of international development studies at Trent University, Canada. He has conducted research, and worked on applied poverty issues, in around twenty five countries in sub-Saharan Africa and Asia. His publications have appeared in top international development journals such as World Development and the Journal of Development Studies. Shaffer was the recipient of the 2010 Symons Award for Excellence in Teaching, Trent University's highest teaching honour. He holds a DPhil from the Institute of Development Studies, University of Sussex.
Table of Contents
Part 1: Introduction
1. Q-Squared: Combining qualitative and quantitative approaches to poverty analysis
Part 2: Identification: Who are the poor and what are their characteristics?
2. Foundations: Epistemology
3. First Generation Q2: Exploring differences
4. Second Generation Q2: Addressing comparability and validity
Part 3: Causal Analysis: Why are people poor?
5. Foundations: Causation and causal inference
6. Q2 Causal Analysis: Exploring the drivers of poverty status and dynamics
7. Q2 Impact Assessment: Evaluating the poverty impact of programs and projects
Part 4: Conclusion
Appendix: Q2 research designs and methods
A.1. Identification: Who are the poor and what are their characteristics?
A.2. Causal analysis of poverty status and dynamics
A.3. Causal analysis in impact assessment