The Child Cases: How America's Religious Exemption Laws Harm Children

The Child Cases: How America's Religious Exemption Laws Harm Children

by Alan Rogers


Choose Expedited Shipping at checkout for guaranteed delivery by Wednesday, October 23


When a four-year-old California girl died on March 9, 1984, the state charged her mother with involuntary manslaughter because she failed to provide her daughter with medical care, choosing instead to rely on spiritual healing. During the next few years, a half dozen other children of Christian Science parents died under similar circumstances. The children's deaths and the parents' trials drew national attention, highlighting a deeply rooted, legal/political struggle to define religious freedom.

Through close analysis of these seven cases, legal historian Alan Rogers explores the conflict between religious principles and secular laws that seek to protect children from abuse and neglect. Christian Scientists argued—often with the support of mainline religious groups—that the First Amendment's "free exercise" clause protected religious belief and behavior. Insisting that their spiritual care was at least as effective as medical treatment, they thus maintained that parents of seriously ill children had a constitutional right to reject medical care.

Congress and state legislatures confirmed this interpretation by inserting religious exemption provisos into child abuse laws. Yet when parental prayer failed and a child died, prosecutors were able to win manslaughter convictions by arguing—as the U.S. Supreme Court had held for more than a century—that religious belief could not trump a neutral, generally applicable law. Children's advocates then carried this message to state legislatures, eventually winning repeal of religious exemption provisions in a handful of states.

Product Details

ISBN-13: 9781625340726
Publisher: University of Massachusetts Press
Publication date: 05/31/2014
Pages: 256
Product dimensions: 6.00(w) x 8.90(h) x 0.80(d)
Age Range: 18 Years

About the Author

Alan Rogers is professor of history at Boston College and author of Murder and the Death Penalty in Massachusetts (University of Massachusetts Press, 2008).

What People are Saying About This

Chris Beneke

Original scholarship on an original topic that challenges religious exemptions to generally applicable laws. The research is thorough and the writing reflects Rogers's impressive mining of newspaper reports and judicial records.

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

See All Customer Reviews