Reading Group Guide
Discussion Questions
1. Amélie told Jack, “In war, the concept of ‘right’ stands on its head.” Is there a different moral code during times of war? Where does one draw the line?
2. In Chapter 21, Yvette said, “[Guilt] is the price we pay for being alive during this terrible time.” What does she mean? Do you believe in survivor’s guilt?
3. Amélie learned to lie and keep secrets to help free her country. Is lying always wrong, or are there exceptions? Would it be hard to “turn off” such learned behavior?
4. Pierre thought the Nazis would win the war. Is it human nature to want to align with the winners, or to stand with your fellow countrymen? Why or why not?
5. What was behind Yvette’s decision to become the mistress of a high-ranking German? What do you think of her decision?
6. What do you think of the statement, “In war, we must use everything we have at our disposal. Nothing done to save France would be unholy.”
7. Kat said that her father had never talked about his time during the First World War. Why do think that was? Why did many Second World War veterans not talk about the war once they came home?
8. Do you think Jack would have married Kat as planned if he hadn’t met Amélie? Why or why not?
9. How did it affect the characters in the story to learn that the French government had fled Paris, then surrendered? Can you imagine how it would feel to have your own country overtaken and occupied by a foreign army?
10. Why do you think the French treated the collaborators so cruelly after the war?
11. In Chapter 16, when Amélie doubted that she was serving a useful purpose, Joshua told her that this was not for her to know; she must just believe she was and keep going. How did this advice impact her? Was it wise? Is this advice applicable to your life?
12. All of the women on the bride boats were leaving their families behind and traveling to a foreign land, not knowing when or even if they’d ever see them again. Can you imagine doing this? Why or why not?
13. In what ways does the book illustrate the era’s attitudes toward women?
14. Describe Amélie’s faith journey. Did Kat grow and change? What about Jack?