West Hall, Vermont, has always been a town of strange disappearances and old legends. The most mysterious is that of Sara Harrison Shea, who, in 1908, was found dead in the field behind her house just months after the tragic death of her daughter, Gertie. Now, in present day, nineteen-year-old Ruthie lives in Sara's farmhouse with her mother, Alice, and her younger sister, Fawn. Alice has always insisted that they live off the grid, a decision that suddenly proves perilous when Ruthie wakes up one morning to find that Alice has vanished without a trace. Searching for clues, she is startled to find a copy of Sara Harrison Shea's diary hidden beneath the floorboards of her mother's bedroom. As Ruthie gets sucked deeper into the mystery of Sara's fate, she discovers that she's not the only person who's desperately looking for someone that they've lost. But she may be the only one who can stop history from repeating itself.
|Publisher:||Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group|
|Sold by:||Random House|
|File size:||3 MB|
About the Author
Read an Excerpt
Excerpted from the Hardcover Edition
Visitors from the Other Side
The Secret Diary of Sara Harrison Shea
January 29, 1908
The first time I saw a sleeper, I was nine years old.
It was the spring before Papa sent Auntie away--before we lost my brother, Jacob. My sister, Constance, had married the fall before and moved to Graniteville.
I was up exploring in the woods, near the Devil’s Hand, where Papa had forbidden us to play. The trees were leafing out, making a lush green canopy overhead. The sun had warmed the soil, giving the damp woods a rich, loamy smell. Here and there beneath the beech, sugar maple, and birch trees were spring flowers: trilliums, trout lilies, and my favorite, jack-in-the-pulpit, a funny little flower with a secret: if you lift the striped hood, you’ll find the preacher underneath. Auntie had shown me this, and taught me that you could dig up the tubers and cook them like turnips. I had just found one and was pulling back the hood, looking for the tiny figure underneath, when I heard footsteps, slow and steady, moving my way. Heavy feet dragging through the dry leaves, stumbling on roots. I wanted to run, but froze with panic, having squatted down low behind a rock just as a figure moved into the clearing.
I recognized her at once--Hester Jameson.
She’d died two weeks before from typhoid fever. I had attended her funeral with Papa and Jacob, seen her laid to rest in the cemetery behind the church up by Cranberry Meadow. Everyone from school was there, all in Sunday best.
Hester’s father, Erwin, ran Jameson’s Tack and Feed Shop. He wore a black coat with frayed sleeves, and his nose was red and running. Beside him stood his wife, Cora Jameson, a heavyset woman who had a seamstress shop in town. Mrs. Jameson sobbed into a lace handkerchief, her whole body heaving and trembling.
I had been to funerals before, but never for someone my own age. Usually it was the very old or the very young. I couldn’t take my eyes off the casket, just the right size for a girl like me. I stared at the plain wooden box until I grew dizzy, wondering what it might feel like to be laid out inside. Papa must have noticed, because he took my hand and gave it a squeeze, pulled me a little closer to him.
Reverend Ayers, a young man then, said Hester was with the angels. Our old preacher, Reverend Phelps, was stooped over, half deaf, and none of what he said made any sense--it was all frightening metaphors about sin and salvation. But when Reverend Ayers with his sparkling blue eyes spoke, it felt as if he said each word right to me.
“I am he who will sustain you. I have made you and I will carry you; I will sustain you and I will rescue you.”
For the first time, I understood the word of God, because Reverend Ayers spoke it. His voice, all the girls said, could soothe the Devil himself.
A red-winged blackbird cried out conk-a-reee from a nearby hazel bush. He puffed up his red shoulders and sang over and over, as loud as he could, his call almost hypnotic; even Reverend Ayers paused to look.
Mrs. Jameson dropped to her knees, keening. Mr. Jameson tried to pull her up, but did not have the strength.
I stood right beside Papa, clutching his hand, as dirt was shoveled down on the coffin of poor Hester Jameson. Hester had a crooked front tooth, but a beautifully delicate face. She had been the best in our class at arithmetic. Once, for my birthday, she gave me a note with a flower pressed inside. A violet it was, dried out and perfectly preserved. May your day be as special as you are, she’d written in perfect cursive. I tucked it into my Bible, where it stayed for years, until it either disintegrated or fell out, I cannot recall.
Now, two weeks after her very own funeral, Hester’s sleeper caught sight of me there in the woods, crouching behind the rock. I shall never forget the look in her eyes--the frightened half-recognition of someone waking from a horrible dream.
I had heard about sleepers; there was even a game we played in the schoolyard in which one child would be laid out dead in a circle of violets and forget-me-nots. Then someone would lean down and whisper magic words in the dead girl’s ear, and she would rise and chase all the other children. The first one she caught would be the next to die.
I think I may have even played this game once with Hester Jameson.
I had heard whispers, rumors of sleepers called back from the land of the dead by grieving husbands and wives, but was certain they only existed in the stories old women liked to tell each other while they folded laundry or stitched stockings--something to pass the time, and to make any eavesdropping children hurry home before dark.
I had been sure, up until then, that God in his infinite wisdom would not have allowed such an abomination.
Hester and I were not ten feet apart. Her blue dress was filthy and torn, her corn-silk hair in tangles. She gave off the musty smell of damp earth, but there was something else behind it, an acrid, greasy, burnt odor, similar to what you smell when you blow out a tallow candle.
Our eyes met, and I yearned to speak, to say her name, but could only manage a strangled-sounding Hss.
Hester ran off into the woods like a startled rabbit. I stayed frozen, clinging pathetically to my rock like a bit of lichen.
From down the path leading to the Devil’s Hand came another figure, running, calling Hester’s name.
It was her mother, Cora Jameson.
She stopped when she saw me, face flushed and frantic. She was breathing hard and had scratches on her face and arms, pieces of dry leaves and twigs tangled in her hair.
“Tell no one,” she said.
“But why?” I asked, stepping out from behind the rock.
She looked right at me--through me, almost, as if I were a pane of dirty window glass. “Someday, Sara,” she said, “maybe you’ll love someone enough to understand.”
Then she ran off into the woods, following her daughter.
I told Auntie about it later.
“Is it really possible?” I asked. “To bring someone back like that?”
We were down by the river, picking fiddleheads, filling Auntie’s basket with the curled fern tops, as we did each spring. Then we’d bring them home and make a creamy soup stuffed full of wild greens and herbs that Auntie had gathered along the way. We were also there to check the traps--Auntie had caught a beaver just two days before and was hoping for another. Beaver pelts were a rarity and brought a high price. They were once nearly as common as squirrels’, Auntie said, but trappers had taken all except a handful.
Buckshot was with us, nosing the ground, ears attentive to every little sound. I never knew if he was all wolf, or only part. Auntie had found him as a pup, when he’d fallen into one of her pit traps after being all shot up by someone. She’d carried him home, pulled the buckshot pellets out of him, stitched him up, and nursed him back to health. He’d been by her side ever since.
“He was lucky you found him,” I said after hearing the story.
“Luck had nothing to do with it,” Auntie told me. “He and I were meant for one another.”
I never saw such devotion in a dog--or any animal, for that matter. His wounds had healed, but the buckshot left him blind in his right eye, which was milky white. His ghost eye, Auntie called it.
“He came so close to death, he’s got one eye back there still,” she explained. I loved Buckshot, but I hated that milky-white moon that seemed to see everything and nothing all at once.
Auntie was not related to me by blood, but she cared for me, raised me after my own mother died giving birth to me. I had no memory of my mother--the only proofs of her existence were my parents’ wedding photograph, the quilt she’d sewn that I slept under every night, and the stories my older brother and sister told.
My brother claimed I had my mother’s laugh. My sister said that my mother had been the best dancer in the county, that she was the envy of all the other girls.
Auntie’s people came from up north, in Quebec. Her father had been a trapper; her mother, an Indian woman. Auntie carried a hunting knife, and wore a long deerskin coat decorated with bright beads and porcupine quills. She spoke French, and sang songs in a language I never did recognize. She wore a ring carved from yellowed bone on her right pointer finger.
“What does it say?” I asked once, touching the strange letters and symbols on its surface.
“That life is a circle,” she answered.
People in town were frightened of Auntie, but their fear did not keep them away from her door. They followed the well-worn path to her cabin in the woods out behind the Devil’s Hand, carrying coins, honey, whiskey--whatever they had to trade for her remedies. Auntie had drops for colic, tea for fever, even a little blue bottle that she swore contained a potion so powerful that with one drop the object of your heart’s desire would be yours. I knew better than to doubt her.
There were other things I knew about Auntie, too. I’d seen her sneak out of Papa’s bedroom in the early morning, heard the sounds that came from behind his locked door when she visited him there.
I also knew better than to cross her. She had a fiery temper and little patience with people who did not see things her way. If people refused to pay her for her services, she’d call on them, sprinkle their homes with black powder pulled from one of her leather pouches, and speak a strange incantation. Terrible things would befall those families from then on: sicknesses, fires, crop losses, even death.
I tossed a handful of dark-green fiddleheads into the basket.
“Tell me, Auntie, please,” I begged, “can the dead come back?”
Auntie looked at me a long time, head cocked to the side, her small, dark eyes fixed on mine.
“Yes,” she told me at last. “There is a way. Few know of it, but those who do, pass it down to their children. Because you are the closest I will ever come to a child of my own, the secret will go to you. I will write it all down, everything I know about sleepers. I will fold up the papers, put them in an envelope, and seal it with wax. You will hide it away, and one day, when you are ready, you will open it up.”
“How will I know I am ready?” I asked.
She smiled, showing her small teeth, pointed like a fox’s and stained brown from tobacco. “You will know.”
I am writing these words in secret, hidden under covers. Martin and Lucius believe I am sleeping. I hear them downstairs, drinking coffee and discussing my prognosis. (Not good, I’m afraid.)
I have been going back in my mind, thinking over how all of this began, piecing things together the way one might sew a quilt. But, oh, what a hideous and twisted quilt mine would be!
“Gertie,” I hear Martin say above the clink of a spoon stirring coffee in his favorite tin mug. I imagine the furrow of his brow, the deep worry lines there; how sad his face must be after he spoke her name.
I hold my breath and listen hard.
“Sometimes a tragedy breaks a person,” Lucius says. “Sometimes they will never be whole again.”
If I close my eyes even now, I can still see my Gertie’s face, feel her sugary breath on my cheek. I can so vividly recall our last morning together, hear her saying, “If snow melts down to water, does it still remember being snow?”
January 12, 1908
“Wake up, Martin.” A soft whisper, a flutter against his cheek. “It’s time.”
Martin opened his eyes, leaving the dream of a woman with long dark hair. She’d been telling him something. Something important, something he was not supposed to forget.
He turned over in bed. He was alone, Sara’s side of the bed cold. He sat up, listening carefully. Voices, soft giggles across the hall, from behind Gertie’s bedroom door.
Had Sara spent the whole night in with Gertie again? Surely it couldn’t be good for the girl, to smother her like that. Sometimes he worried that Sara’s attachment to Gertie simply wasn’t . . . healthy. Just last week, Sara had kept Gertie home from school for three straight days, and for those three days Sara doted on her--plaiting her hair, making her a new dress, baking her cookies, playing hide-and-seek. Sara’s niece, Amelia, offered to take Gertie for the weekend, and Sara had made excuses--she gets homesick so easily, she’s so frail--but Martin understood that it was Sara who could not bear to be without Gertie. Sara never seemed whole unless Gertie was by her side.
He pushed the worried thoughts away. Better to focus on the problems he understood and could do something about.
The house was cold, the fire out.
He peeled back the covers, threw his legs over the side of the bed, and pulled on his pants. His bad foot hung there like a hoof till he shoved it into the special boot fashioned for him by the cobbler in Montpelier. The soles were worn through, and he’d stuffed the bottoms of both boots with dry grass and cattail fluff, all layered over scraps of leather, in a futile attempt to keep the dampness out. There was no money for new custom-made boots now.
Blight had ruined most of last fall’s potato crop, and they relied on the money they got from selling the potatoes to the starch factory to get through the winter. It was only January, and the root cellar was nearly bare: a few spongy potatoes and carrots, some Hubbard squash, half a dozen jars of string beans and tomatoes Sara had put up last summer, a little salt pork from the hog they’d butchered in November (they’d traded most of the meat for dry goods at the general store). Martin would have to get a deer soon if they were going to have enough to eat. Sara had a talent for stretching what little food they had, for making milk gravy and biscuits with a bit of salt pork into a meal, but she couldn’t create something from nothing.
Reading Group Guide
The questions and discussion topics that follow are intended to enhance your reading of Jennifer McMahon’s The Winter People. We hope they will enrich your experience of this mesmerizing novel.
1. At the heart of the novel is the longing to be reunited with a loved one who has died. How would you respond to this possibility, even if you could only see your beloved for one week? What risks would you take to take to experience such a reunion?
2. What was it like to read Sara’s diary, alternating with scenes from other time periods? Did Sara’s words change your vision of the spirit world? Did her bond with Gertie remind you of your own experience with a mother’s love?
3. When Alice and her family inhabit Sara’s house and her land, how does that environment transform them? Do you believe that the history of a locale can influence your present-day experiences there?
4. Ruthie and Fawn have been raised to question authority and to live a non-materialistic life. What benefits and challenges does their upbringing give them when their mother goes missing? Ultimately, what did Alice try to teach her daughters about becoming fulfilled women?
5. Reread the excerpt from Amelia’s introduction on the book’s first page. How do Amelia and the other townspeople react to their legacies? Why did Reverend Ayers feel so threatened by Auntie?
6. Martin cherishes Sara and continually strives to please her. Does she love him in equal measure, or does her ancestry make it too difficult for an outsider to fully share a life with her?
7. How was Sara affected by her history with her siblings, Constance and Jacob? Why did their father easily become dependent on Auntie, while Sara’s mother didn’t trust her?
8. Did Tom and Bridget O’Rourke have ethical motivations? Did Candace? How do the revelations about them affect Ruthie’s sense of self?
9. How did you react to Gertie’s hunger? What is its significance to the maternal women who must care for her?
10. Discuss Katherine and Gary’s love for each other. How does their marriage compare to the others presented in the book? How do Katherine’s art and Gary’s photography give them a unique perspective on life and memory? What does their story indicate about whether a sleeper should be awakened?
11. Consider the rules for waking a sleeper. What do the words and the ingredients represent in terms of the cycles of life and the nature of death?
12. What were your theories about the many unsolved deaths in West Hall? Did your instincts prove to be correct when the truth about the Devil’s Hand was revealed?
13. In The Winter People and previous novels by Jennifer McMahon that you have enjoyed, how is the author able to make surreal situations seem highly realistic? What role do fear and courage play in each of her books?
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
You wont be sorry if you buy this book, i couldnt put it down!
I love the plot. I think it would make a fantastic movie. I highly recommend it!
I bought this on a whim and practically stayed up all night to read it. I would think it would turn out one way and then it would go another. A great puzzle to figure out. Definitely worth reading if you like to check under the bed for monsters. Highly recommended!
The newest Jennifer McMahon book has the requisite teens and tweens that she does so weli, as well as a healthy dose of things that go bump (and growl, claw and shape shift) well into the night. The Tower is a character unto itself snd the letters to Alfred Hitchcock a whimsical touch. The mare was a bit predictible, telegraphed but enjoyable nonetheless.
Keeps you wanting to turn the page.
Blends folklore with the perfect setting to create an unsettling tale of what it means to make sacrifices...
You've got secrets, lies, mysteries and ghosts too? This was a GREAT book!!! I am definitely glad I was reading it during the day. I wish I could say the best parts of this book without spoiling it for you. This is like nothing I've ever read before. And while, I'm getting a little tired of that genre, this book has just the right amount. There is absolutely no way you could figure this one out. It's a one of a kind. Especially since you don't see the different genre being mixed up in this at all. It was definitely a nice surprise from your ordinary thrillers. I, without a doubt, highly recommend this book. I'm definitely sure it will be on my top 12 for 2015!!! Thanks Doubleday and Net Galley for providing me with this free e-galley in exchange for an honest review.
A little hard to keep up with at first, but very very good!
Fast paced with the change of perspectives. Loved past to present jumps and all the little mysteries connected!
I have read The Winter People by this author and I wanted to read more of her work, so I picked up this novel. I liked the mysterious elements of this novel and I liked the voices of the characters. One mystery dealt with where Sylvie was and the other mystery materialized the night that Amy and her family died. This novel centered on a hotel that had a tower constructed beside it, a replica of The Tower of London. I kept picturing The Bates Hotel with a tower, as I read this novel as there was this creepy and shadowy element to the happening surrounding the hotel and the family that ran the hotel, they felt unusual and dark. I liked the characters as they were a diverse bunch. It seemed that some individuals wanted to hide the past, they never wanted to look back while others were trying to uncover the details as the puzzles transpired. I wanted to feel empathy as events arose, but I hesitated for I felt that I didn’t know who was truly involved, how involved they were and the true story that would accompany that event. The story pops between a few different time periods but the stories all comes together in the end, the characters aging in the process and new individuals being introduced. It wasn’t so much a sitting-at-the- end-of-my-seat read for me but there was that anticipation of what would transpire as I read, who was involved in the events and what the outcome was. I enjoy reading Jennifer McMahon’s novels and I am looking forward to the next one.
After reading this book, I'll definitely be looking at others by this author. Loved the plot. A great blend of mystery and supernatural.
this was the most ridiculous book I've read in a long time
The pages of my book are nice and worn from sharing this one with my friends. I couldn't put it down and finished it in just three days. A suspenseful story of a family with dark secrets threatening to come to the surface. Friends feeding their childlike curiosity in an abandoned hotel, what could go wrong? When the hidden treasures lead them to more stories of mysterious missing family members and frightening secrets what more do you need?
I found this writer recently in an airport when I bought Winter People. Very intriguing! I decided to follow with this one and also was not disappointed. I love the back and forth with characters and timelines, leaving a good amount of mystery to be had until the end. It kept me reading late into the night. I look forward to reading more of her stories!
Another fantastic book by Jennifer McMahon! I read The Winter People by her (read review here) and really enjoyed it, so I was excited to read this one for book club. There was a perfect amount of mystery, thriller and supernatural elements in this book. McMahon is a master at writing books that jump around different time periods. In this one there are four; 1955, 1961, 1989, and 2013. For each time period she is spot on with the various details including clothing and expressions. It is very apparent when the times shift, unlike some books where you have to really puzzle it out. There are so many questions that revolve around the mystery of the book, but McMahon keeps the tension high while answering them, and still give you a break from time to time so you can catch your breath. For me the supernatural elements were not so scary that you want to keep all the lights on, but added just enough creepiness to keep the thrills coming. I also really enjoyed how she added in the letters to Alfred Hitchcock, and included the real life event of him coming to the town for an opening of a film. I wasn’t surprised at the ending because I thought it was going to go that way about halfway into the book, but I wanted to keep reading to see how all the pieces fit together. And I was still surprised with a couple of the details. If you enjoy supernatural thrillers or mysteries, I highly recommend this one, as well as The Winter People.
Horrible. Could not finish the book. Not what I would call entertaining.
The Night Sister was a wonderful mystery/thriller. It was written with the same Characters through out the book. We also get to read about 4 different time era's that jump back and fourth from 1955, 1961, 1989 and the year 2013. Everyone of us carries around family secretes but none like we find in The Night Sister. Pick up this book read it and you will find that you will enjoy the wonderful writing by Jennifer McMahon.
This is a suspenseful paranormal mystery. I really liked how Silvie wrote a letter to Hitchock regarding the story he did about the old roadside motel where strange things happened. I think we all remember that one. As for me, I still don’t like taking showers at night. Anyway, Silvie wanted to know if Hitchcock got that idea from her... Strange things do sometimes happen, and sometimes there are no logical explanations as to what or how it happens. I believe we have a lot of paranormal activity going on...sometimes we know about it and sometimes we don’t have the slightest idea it is happening. But, the ones who have experienced paranormal activities know there is more to this world than what meets the eye. Why not give this novel a whirl? Jeannie Walker (Award-Winning Author) "Fighting the Devil" - A True Story of Consuming Passion, Deadly Poison,and Murder
I just finished reading The Night Sister by Jennifer McMahon. Amy grew up in the Tower Motel. It was closed in 1971 after a highway was built that diverted traffic from London, Vermont. One of the attractions was a tower (made of stone) their grandfather built for their grandmother who came from London, England. It is now in bad shape and should be torn down. Jason Hawke grew up with Amy (had a big crush on her). He is now married to Margot and they are expecting their first child. Jason is an officer with the London Police Department. He is going off duty when he hears a call out to the Tower Motel. When he arrives, he finds a very bloody and disturbing scene. Amy, her husband, Mark, and their son, Levi are all dead. The only survivor is their daughter, Lou (who climbed out onto the roof with her bloody feet). Margot is confined to bed and asks Piper to investigate what happened to Amy’s family. The book is told from the perspective of Rose, Piper, and Jason. It jumps from 2013 (present day) to 1955, 1961, and 1989 (which makes it jumbled and confusing). Sylvia and Rose are sisters (1955 and 1961). Sylvia is the golden girl. She dreams of being an actress and she writes odd letters to Alfred Hitchcock (which Rose steals out of mailbox). She disappears in October the year of her eighteenth year and is never heard from again. Amy, Margot, and Piper (Margot and Piper are sisters) find her suitcase buried in the floor of the tower their grandfather built. They start looking for more information and find her typewriter. Inside is another letter to Alfred Hitchcock which mentions a secret 29th room at the motel. The girls are curious and start investigating Sylvia and the mysterious room. Where could the 29th room be? Amy is a strange girl. Raised by her grandmother after her mother, Rose takes off (has issues). When Rose was little her Oma came over for a visit from England. Oma would tell Rose stories about mares. Rose believes her Oma’s stories about mares. Humans that can transform into animals. Rose thinks that Sylvia is a mare and keeps watching her over the years. She wants to catch Sylvia in the act of transforming. Is there such a thing as mares? What happened to Sylvia Slater? Did Amy kill her family and herself? The Night Sister tells the story about the two investigations and what happened to the family. I found the novel extremely strange (sad, but true). A paranormal element was added at the end which actually made the story worse. I think the novel would have been better off it had just been a mystery. It is confusing to read as the book jumps all around. It does come together in the end, but I did not especially like the ending. I give The Night Sister 2 out of 5 stars. The idea is intriguing, but I found the execution of the idea lacking. The writing is just lack luster. I never got drawn into the story because it was going to different years and different characters. Unfortunately, The Night Sister was just not for me. If I use one word to describe this book it would be weird! I received a complimentary copy of The Night Sister from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. The review and opinions expressed are my own.