Penny Brummer was a lesbian. Sarah Gonstead was straight. Glenda Johnson, Brummer's ex-lover and Gonstead's best friend, wasn't sure what she was. When Gonstead was found dead near Madison, Wisconsin, shortly after she disappeared on March 15, 1994, investigators immediately focused on Brummer as the killer. Brummer was convicted of Gonstead's murder months later, but questions about the case continued. Sheila and Doug Berry now provide provocative answers to those questions in this riveting journey through a wilderness of errors. Along the way they take you to a twilight zone where evidence is ignored or manipulated, innocence is disbelieved and justice is denied to both Penny Brummer and Sarah Gonstead.