Most Helpful Customer Reviews
A Day to Die For: 1996: Everest's Worst Disaster based on 0 ratings. 2 reviews.
Questions, questions… The May 1996 Everest disaster claimed the lives of eight climbers from three different expeditions. Two of the victims were the leaders of their particular expedition. Many of the survivors have since written about their experience. There was controversy over the deaths, some claiming that it was totally avoidable. Some also questioned an Everest climbing decision that has been like an unwritten law: Those above the Death Zone on Everest who cannot move are left to die. People have died in helping others, and Rob Hall of Adventure Consultants was told to abandon one of the climbers, but refused and died along with his client Doug Hansen near the South Summit. Many of the survivors have authored books on their experience, with themes ranging from survivor’s guilt to allegations of misconduct with decisions made by the leaders of the expeditions. I have read all of them. This book was written by someone who was there, but not on any of the expeditions that lost climbers on the mountain. One of the people who died, Yasuko Namba, died within 200 meters of the camp where the author was resting for his own summit bid, having avoided being involved in the disaster by delaying the summit bid to another day. I am sorry, but what I am reading is a lot of “poor me, I feel so guilty.” There is also a large part of this book that has nothing at all to do with the “Day to die for.” I felt an outsider’s view would be great, but this book does nothing for me. It is a hot mess… I give this book only two stars… Quoth the Raven…
A truly wonderful book! An amazing detective story enriched by artfully written descriptions of events and locations encountered along the way, from an old school in the British countryside to Tibet. Thanks to the stunning dedication of the author and the sincere work of a few meteorologists, a 5-year investigation through lost tracks and poorly responsive actors finally leads to success, shedding light on a crucial yet essentially unreported issue in the 1996 Everest story, the prevailing weather conditions. Reading this book, as well as The Climb, Into Thin Air, Climbing High, and Above the Clouds, and watching related documentaries, carefully and twice each in alternating order, can help one draw conclusions about the event and identify the ones that are truly important. This book’s contribution to those conclusions is much greater than some.