★ 2023-04-24
Lives and minds unravel in this dual-timeline gothic horror debut.
English painter Orla McGrath and her husband, Nick, are residing in Bristol with their 4-year-old son, Sam, and infant daughter, Bridie, when Sam stops speaking. Doctors diagnose selective mutism and counsel patience, but domineering Nick declares that a scenery change will help and buys The Reeve, a sprawling, centuries-old home on a remote Dorset cliffside. The patchy cell and internet service worry Orla, as she’ll be alone and carless during the week while programmer Nick stays in the city for work, but Nick insists the isolation will be good for her and her art. That initially proves true, though the atmosphere quickly turns disquieting. Phantom footsteps sound, objects appear and disappear, doors open by themselves, and Sam draws shadowy figures he indicates are friends. Nick refuses to move, however, despite spending more and more time away. Forty years earlier, London nanny Lydia Price relocates to The Reeve when her newly widowed boss, Sara, decides she and her four kids need a fresh start. Though inexplicable phenomena vex Lydia from the outset, including disembodied voices, invisible children’s playmates, and dying birds, Sara scornfully dismisses her concerns. Lydia would love to leave but can’t bring herself to abandon her young charges to the house or their increasingly distant mother. Collins skillfully intercuts the two storylines, making clever use of structure to maximize tension, resonance, and fright, while the familiar setup fools readers into thinking they know what path the plot will follow. A moody, evocative, close-third narrative underscores the keenly rendered characters’ mounting distress and claustrophobia.
A harrowing slow burn with feminist undertones.
"A feminist gothic that evokes Shirley Jackson’s The Haunting of Hill House." — New York Times Book Review
"The dream house in the country is a fictional standard for illuminating the realities of women’s domestic life; when the dream turns to nightmare, it’s the perfect setting for horror... Atmospheric and beautifully written, A Good House for Children builds slowly but surely into a terrifying ghost story." — Guardian
"[Will] go down a treat for all of those (numerous) readers with tastes straddling what passes for "literary fiction" and good old, deeply satisfying horror. It has a little bit of all things not very nice that make up a page-turning popular novel, without resorting to moral simplicity or predictability. It's a highly readable book that still inspires more questions than it answers - which is impressive, for being so rare...More than once, I was put in mind of The Turn of the Screw." — Irish Times
"Collins skillfully intercuts the two storylines, making clever use of structure to maximize tension, resonance, and fright, while the familiar setup fools readers into thinking they know what path the plot will follow. A moody, evocative, close-third narrative underscores the keenly rendered characters’ mounting distress and claustrophobia. A harrowing slow burn with feminist undertones." — Kirkus Reviews (starred review)
"An engrossing read. ... A neat mix of psychological thriller and old-fashioned haunted house drama." — Daily Mail (London)
"Utterly compelling, creepy and dark." — Irish Examiner
"That this is Collins's debut is astonishing. Her writing is well-crafted and takes us from the real to surreal and back again with ease. Keep the lights on and ignore any odd noises you hear." — Irish Independent
"Fans of gothic fiction will appreciate this tale reminiscent of Ruth Ware’s Turn of the Key." — Booklist
A stunning debut... A terrifying and propulsive gothic story with so much to say about parenthood, privilege and the psychological burden of motherhood. I was utterly mesmerised by it and found it so unsettling that I had to keep the lights on! ... Incredibly accomplished and original." — Katherine Faulkner, author of Greenwich Park
"Collins intertwines the tales of Orla and Lydia, who have each lived in the Reeve: a house subject to haunting, but also a place where boundaries blur . . . between different times, but also of the sense of reality and the other, and ultimately, the edge of sanity itself. A beautifully written, creepy tale reminiscent of Shirley Jackson." — Alison Littlewood, author of A Cold Season
"Equally terrifying and brilliant, Kate Collins' claustrophobic gothic tale of motherhood, sacrifice, and loss, captured my attention from eerie beginning to unforgettable end—-a read-in-one-sitting triumph of storytelling." — Ashley Tate, author of Twenty-Seven Minutes