During some of the better moments of
All This Time, the second album from Ohio's
the Heartless Bastards, one gets the feeling that this trio could be the Midwestern cousin of
PJ Harvey -- not
Polly Harvey the singer and songwriter -- but the bone-shattering power trio named for the bandleader on
Dry and
Rid of Me. While frontwoman
Erika Wennerstrom doesn't particularly sound like
Polly, she conjures up a similar degree of gale-force vocal impact and plays a not-dissimilar variety of dirty, elemental electric guitar, while her rhythm section (
Kevin Vaughn on drums and
Mike Lamping on bass) calls up a massive Wall of Sound and energy behind her. But a few spins of
All This Time makes it clear the similarity between
the Heartless Bastards and
PJ Harvey is a matter of similar musical philosophy rather than conscious emulation, and that
Wennerstrom has a flinty, down-to-earth lyrical perspective that reflects the experiences of someone who was born and raised in Ohio (and still works a day job when not on the road).
All This Time makes a powerful virtue of its muscular, no-frills production, and
Brian Niesz's engineering, which allows the individual elements to stand out while still coalescing into a unified and gloriously dangerous whole.
All This Time swings with the force of a heavyweight champ, but there's an unpretentious intelligence, compassion, and cautious hope in these ten songs, and
the Heartless Bastards bring them across with an elegance that belies their muscle; they know how to say a great deal with a little, and that's a large part of what makes this album worth hearing. ~ Mark Deming
