Ascending Order: Rising Powers and the Politics of Status in International Institutions

by Rohan Mukherjee

Overview

Why do rising powers sometimes challenge an international order that enables their growth, and at other times support an order that constrains them? Ascending Order offers the first comprehensive study of conflict and cooperation as new powers join the global arena. International institutions shape the choices of rising states as they pursue equal status with established powers. Open membership rules and fair decision-making procedures facilitate equality and cooperation, while exclusion and unfairness frequently produce conflict. Using original and robust archival evidence, the book examines these dynamics in three cases: the United States and the maritime laws of war in the mid-nineteenth century; Japan and naval arms control in the interwar period; and India and nuclear non-proliferation in the Cold War. This study shows that the future of contemporary international order depends on the ability of international institutions to address the status ambitions of rising powers such as China and India.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9781009186810
Publisher:	Cambridge University Press
Publication date:	08/04/2022
Series:	Cambridge Studies in International Relations
Pages:	352
Product dimensions:	6.18(w) x 9.25(h) x 0.94(d)

About the Author

Rohan Mukherjee is Assistant Professor of International Relations at the London School of Economics and Political Science. He was previously Assistant Professor at Yale-NUS College, Singapore. He is a former Stanton Nuclear Security Fellow at the MIT Security Studies Program and non-resident Fellow at the United Nations University in Tokyo.

Table of Contents

1. Introduction; 2. Conceptual foundations; 3. Institutional status theory; 4. The United States and the Atlantic system in the 19th century; 5. Japan and the Washington system of the interwar period; 6. India and the international order of the cold war; 7. China and the liberal international order; 8. Conclusion.

Editorial Reviews

‘In a world in transition, Rohan Mukherjee helps us understand when rising powers are likely to challenge the world order or cooperate. In this path-breaking book, Mukherjee shows that the answer lies in overlooked areas - their place and status in international institutions - and the psychology of identity.’ Deborah Welch Larson, co-author of Quest for Status: Chinese and Russian Foreign Policy

‘Ascending Order makes a real contribution to the literature on great power politics and the ways in which we can use institutions to shape the behavior of rising nations. Mukherjee’s analysis is clear and compelling, readily accessible for both scholars and practitioners. A timely and valuable read.’ Anne-Marie Slaughter, CEO, New America

‘Ascending Order is a timely and important contribution to international relations scholarship. Rohan Mukherjee moulds research on status concerns, rising powers, and international institutions into a novel theory that opens a new window on crucial but still poorly understood dimensions of great power politics. If you want to understand the substance underlying much of the talk about the ‘rules based order’ and ‘great power competition,’ read this book.’ William C. Wohlforth, Daniel Webster Professor, Department of Government, Dartmouth College

'The most dangerous moments in international affairs occur when rising states emerge to challenge the dominance of a reigning great power. In this excellent study, Mukherjee shows that these power transitions do not inevitably culminate in great-power conflict or hegemonic war.' G. John Ikenberry, Foreign Affairs

‘It is a theoretically ambitious and empirically jam-packed contribution that explains why rising powers in global politics sometimes challenge an international order that enables their growth, and at other times support an order that constrains them. The biggest strength of this book is indeed the breadth, depth, and novelty of the archival material, undoubtedly completed through extensive and meticulous labour.’ Caroline Dunton, Small States & Territories

‘Mukherjee provides helpful insights for nation-states and international organizations on how different institutional decisions can shape the behaviour of rising powers. In addition, the book will be of great value to researchers and practitioners as a starting-point for future research on the changing global order.’ Tobias Scholz, International Affairs

‘This book is an important work of both theory and historical analysis that hopefully will have a significant impact on current debates about the rise of China and the fate of the LIO. … Ascending Order has the potential to spark a deeper debate about the rise of China and the future of international order; a debate that is informed more by notions of justice, fairness, and legitimacy than by security concerns and the balance of military power.’ John G. Oates, Ethics & International Affairs

'Mukherjee provides an important analysis of how status and symbolic equality impact international relations. … Highly recommended.’ M. F. Cairo, Choice

‘… an outstanding book … Together with Mukherjee’s cogent writing style, the book’s timeliness and its contributions to the literatures on status, hierarchy, revisionism, and global governance make Ascending Order a must-read for otherwise disparate audiences.’ Review of International Organisations

‘… an outstanding book. Rohan Mukherjee’s first, it explains rising powers’ behavior with respect to the rules and institutions of the international order. To do so, Mukherjee articulates a novel theory that centers on rising powers’ pursuit of elevated status in the international society of states. Using a clever research design, Mukherjee presents three carefully researched historical cases that illustrate and arguably test the theory. The result is an excellent study that illuminates the changing institutional frameworks of distinctive international orders, explains how rising powers become dissatisfied with those orders, and traces over time the strategies they employ to move up the ranks of those orders, change them, or challenge them.’ Jonathan M. DiCicco, The Review of International Organizations

‘… offer[s] new inspiration to address the enduring challenges facing the international order.’ Ziyuan Wang, China International Strategy Review

‘… a theoretically innovative and empirically rich study of the politics of status in global governance.’ Zheng Chen, China International Strategy Review

From the Publisher