Publishers Weekly
08/21/2023
Journalist Pengelly debuts with an intimate portrait of the members of the West Point Military Academy’s rugby team of 2001–2002—the first academic year following the September 11 attacks, whose graduating class entered a military at war. In the U.S., rugby is found mostly on college campuses and “very few arrive at rugby in a straight line,” according to Pengelly: “At West Point, the rugby team were proud outsiders, cut from football, drifted over from lacrosse, wrestling, or track.” In one of the oldest academic institutions in the country, where cadets are taught to live by the motto “duty, honor, country,” rugby was a “sport of the outsider, the eccentric, the nonconformist.” The teammates, along with their classmates, were fired up to serve following a terrorist attack on U.S. soil, and three members of the team later died during active-duty service—two were killed in stateside accidents within months after graduation and one died in Iraq after an IED attack. A fourth teammate died of cancer after leaving the army. Drawing on his own love of rugby, personal reminiscences from the cadets, and in-depth reportage, Pengelly provides a vivid snapshot of his subjects and their experiences of war, combined with an elegiac meditation on the sport. It’s a poignant account. (Oct.)Correction: An earlier version of this review incorrectly stated that two of the teammates were killed in Afghanistan.
From the Publisher
Praise for Brotherhood
“Weaves together multiple in-depth biographies to form a highly readable account of who these men were, where they came from, how they played the game and how they fought the longest war in U.S. military history….We’re better off for having these men among us.”
—Wall Street Journal
“A mammoth of a journalistic, sporting, historical and emotional work … the product of a writer with a tangible respect for the privilege of the story he is telling”
—The Rugby Journal
“Brotherhood is a mad, perfect book. Pengelly’s audacious act combining biography, war reportage and sports writing is like nothing I’ve read before. The ’02 West Point ruggers are painted in beautiful relief and their combat episodes are brilliantly rendered. Sports book? War book? I’m not sure, but I’m certain you must read it.”
—Anthony Swofford, author of Jarhead: A Marine's Chronicle of the Gulf War and Other Battles
“An intimate portrait . . . Drawing on his own love of rugby, personal reminiscences from the [West Point] cadets, and in-depth reportage, Pengelly provides a vivid snapshot of his subjects and their experiences of war, combined with an elegiac meditation on the sport. It’s a poignant account.”
—Publishers Weekly
“A memorable and moving book, a significant contribution to the literature of the American military after 9/11.”
—Thomas E. Ricks, author of Waging a Good War: A Military History of the Civil Rights Movement, 1954–1968
“Brotherhood breaks the heart with its dramatic story of a fraternity of teammates broken by war.”
—David Abrams, author of Fobbit
“In rugby, we often talk of ‘going into battle’ with your team. It's just a game, of course, but in Brotherhood, sport, war, and friendship leap from the pages as players really do become warriors—and heroes.”
—Dan Lyle, U.S. Rugby Hall of Famer and NBC Sports analyst
“In a time when men struggle to find their place in society—a time of disheartening news on education, relationships, and lifespan itself—Martin Pengelly brings a rare story of encouragement. The young men of Brotherhood remind us of the best in men: courage, sacrifice, even nobility.”
—Matthew Teague, co-author of The Steal: The Attempt to Overturn the 2020 Election and the People Who Stopped It
“Brotherhood captures men working through shared hardships, the lessons learned, and bonds forged through that journey. Ultimately, the book shares the stories of young men and their families who were willing to give everything for our country—and some who did.”
—Matthew Sherman, West Point Men’s Rugby Coach
