After Shaun O'Rielly decides to end nine months of mourning the death of his wife Andrea to reconnect with his friends and teammates on an amateur baseball team, he discovers that a new guy that throws like a girl is playing his position at second base. The interloper is his late wife whose tinkering with reincarnation has resulted in her coming around again as a man. As Shaun's attraction and his confusion grow, new guy Andy Stock seeks to seduce Shaun into becoming lovers, much to chagrin of their best friend coach and the Powers That Be.
