Dylan Scott first released a recording called
Dylan Scott EP in 2014. Two years later came another
Dylan Scott, this one a full-length album and that's not the only difference. The 2016
Dylan Scott differs from in 2014 in terms of role models: the latter-day version swapped
Luke Bryan for
Sam Hunt, happily riding the trend for cheerful, R&B-influenced pop country. Some remnants of bro country certainly remain: "Beer Buddies" is vaguely reflective number in the vein of "Drink a Beer," "I Lost You" is a ballad not far removed from
Bryan's wheelhouse, and "My Town" strikes a small-town chord. Elsewhere, proceedings are nimble and sometimes clever, such as the processed banjos of "Freak Show" suggesting
Missy Elliott's classic "Get Yer Freak On," his heart thumps when his girl raps to
Eminem, while "Back" glides by on a soulful veneer. Between these two extremes are straight-ahead numbers, both slow and fast. The former are given a big, boastful production and the latter are designed for open roads, and
Dylan Scott handles all the curves with a smile, if not a lot of panache. If he doesn't show a lot of personality, the willingness to follow the shifting tides shows a lot of determination, and that's enough to make the 2016
Dylan Scott pleasant enough. [A Deluxe Edition of
Dylan Scott was reissued in 2017, featuring three new songs including the single "Hooked."] ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine