On their first album of original material since 2010's
O, Florida post-hardcore outfit
Underoath cleared the slate with a different sound and outlook. Produced by
Matt Squire (
Panic! At the Disco,
the Used),
Erase Me features plenty of changes that may prove especially divisive for longtime fans. For starters,
Underoath shed their "Christian" label, freeing them from that associated baggage (even at the risk of alienating the fellow faithful). They're also using profanity. While God isn't entirely absent on
Erase Me -- there's plenty of related disillusionment and frustration -- that faith-focus is set to the side. In addition to the less-overt religious bent, the band have also smoothed out their sound. There's more singing and less blood-curdling bellowing. Past ferocity and darkness have given way to (relatively) polished sheen and focus. This is not so much a completely unrecognizable band as it is a changed one. Like similar evolutions from genre-mates like
Bring Me the Horizon,
Asking Alexandria,
the Devil Wears Prada, and
Of Mice & Men,
Underoath still have teeth; the bites are just less bloody and jagged. "It Has to Start Somewhere" kicks the album off with an explosive burst of violent but controlled fury before veering headlong into synth programming and an arena-sized chorus on "Rapture." Unapologetic, this is the first taste of the rebooted version of
Underoath. As if sensing the fan grumbles, they whip back into shape on "On My Teeth," a towering highlight that features the best synthesis of old and new
Underoath. It's a brutal, unrelenting powerhouse. They maintain a similar balance over the course of the album. There are more restrained numbers -- some of the softest
Underoath tracks to date -- like the epic "Wake Me," the yearning "ihateit," and the urgent call-for-help "No Frame." For the old-school fans,
Underoath oblige with "In Motion," the closest they come to their early-aughts days. Otherwise, perfectly serviceable standouts like the propulsive "Sink with You" and the near-industrial "Hold Your Breath" are pit-ready tornadoes that should ease the fears that
Underoath have lost their edge. Much like their
Dallas Spencer-era sound changed with the arrival of
Spencer Chamberlain -- which then morphed once again over their mid-era progression --
Erase Me can be considered yet another radical shift in the band's lifetime of variation, a risk that pays off with an open mind and open ears. ~ Neil Z. Yeung
