- What is missing in the contents
- The areas mentioned in the above paragraphs.
- The importance of relationships between TA and pupil, TA and TA and TA and teaching staff.
- What to do if the teacher with whom the TA is working, or the school ethos or climate does not support such an agenda.
- The relationship of support to the formal, informal and hidden curriculum of a school.
- Possible competition
I do not know of a book that tackles the ECM agenda for TAs in this way. There are books that help LSAs support pupils in the affective domain, for example Glenys Fox’s book on Learning Support Assistance. She has a more holistic approach to the whole subject of supporting pupils and her book is short enough and basic enough to be of use to the beginning and ‘ordinary’ TA as well as LSAs. Other DFP books tackle individual SEN matters – Asberger’s or Down’s – but not just this affective area I think.
- Purchase of this book
I would purchase this book as a useful addition to my library of TA books. However I would advise any TA to look carefully before purchase, this should not be the only book they use to support their own learning and practice.
- Other comments
I found the author’s style in describing her own book a bit OTT, ‘outstanding success’ ‘unique, ground breaking resource’ ‘guaranteed bestseller’ etc., but this may be because I would never have the confidence to describe my own books in such terms, particularly before they are published! I wish her well.
Marcelo Staricoff
Please identify your areas of teaching, pupil support and responsibility.
I am currently the Deputy Headteacher at St. Bartholomew’s CE Primary School in Brighton. I also teach a Year 5 class and I am responsible for leading Numeracy, Assessment, Behaviour, Thinking Skills and G&T in our school. I am directly responsible for the performance management of the Midday Lunchtime Supervisors and I work alongside a teaching assistant in my Year 5 class (75% of curriculum time). I have a particular interest in Thinking Skills, Philosophy for Children and G&T Provision and I have written several articles on how these approaches to teaching and learning can be incorporated into the daily routine of a primary classroom. I have recently published a book, entitled Start Thinking, Imaginative Minds, 2005 [ISBN 1904806023] which is a collection of open ended ‘thinking skills starters’ that children engage with when they first enter the classroom in the morning. I am a member of NAGTY’s Think Tank and Primary Expert Advisory Group, of SAPERE’s National Committee and of Brighton’s Creativity Steering Group. I regularly speak at National Conferences and run CPD and INSET days for schools.
Please comment on the proposed title – is it clear/appropriate/appealing? Can you suggest an alternative title?
The title is very appropriate I would say, especially as it is another one in the series of ‘Every Child Matters’ by the same author. Having Every Child Matters as part of the title is an immediate draw for anyone currently working in Education. My only doubt is that in the Background section it states that the book will support the learning and well being of children with additional needs. As the title stands this is not clear and if this is the case it may need an explanatory sub-title. The rest of the proposal seems to deal with TAs supporting all children in helping the school to meet the ECM agenda, in which case the title would be alright.
Do you agree that a book of this type is needed? Who would be the main audience for it? Would it appeal to both primary and secondary sectors?
I definitely agree that there is a need for a book that addresses the Every Child Matters from a Teacher’s Assistant point of view. A fantastic and original idea which will represent an invaluable resource for all educational establishments, especially in Primary Schools where TAs play such an important role in nurturing children and contributing to their personalised learning.
What was your immediate reaction to the proposal? Did you like it or dislike it? Did you find it straightforward or confusing?
I really liked it as soon as I started reading it- the more I read it and the more times I read it I became increasingly convinced of its value- especially if it doesn’t restrict itself to TAs supporting children with additional needs. Although many schools view TAs as solely helping children with additional needs, I feel that they can if deployed creatively and respectfully contribute enormously to the success of all in the classroom. It all seems to be very clearly thought out and the Chapters are very well designed in terms of content and continuity.
What are the strengths of this proposed book?
I feel the book has a number of strengths. The author is obviously an expert in the field and a very successful writer of books on similar topics. It feels me with confidence that this book will be of equal quality. To bring the ECM agenda to the fore is invaluable at the moment and to provide schools with guidance as to how have TAs at the heart of school success is a great commodity. The deployment of TAs has always being an ‘issue’ with all schools I have been involved with and after every inspection/observation that I have been involved in. raising the profile of TAs is what this book will do so well. Including information on personalised learning and assessment for learning will also place TAs at the cutting edge of educational initiatives. Examples of practical support and strategies for all five areas of the ECM agenda would be fabulous. The Monitoring and Evaluating chapter is what'schools are now judged by and this chapter would be invaluable for all heads.
What are the weaknesses of this book?
From a weakness point of view, the only slight concern is the author’s assertion that ‘it will be a guaranteed best seller’. In combining theory and practical support strategies it may attract forward looking heads, but from personal experience TAs do not generally buy books themselves for their own CPD and very often are not used to dealing and assimilating educational literature. I feel that the book would be bought more as a single copy by heads rather than as a working document which teachers and TAs would want to acquire. If that is the case, heads would have to be very good at sharing the ‘practical chapters’ with the TA workforce. Having said that, I would definitely buy a copy to promote the role of TAs in our school.
What is missing (if anything) in the contents?
Only greater clarity as to whether it is intended to support TAs dealing with children with additional needs or for all TAs regardless of their child remit in and out of class.
Are you aware of any other books now on the market that compete with this book (that are on the same topic and have the same approach)?
I don’t know of any other books focusing on the TA role as part of the ECM agenda and as such it is unique as the author suggests.
Would you buy this book?
I would definitely buy this book. I feel that TAs are the ‘make or break’ of successful schools and not enough guidance is given to teachers and TAs as to how to best promote learning in the classroom. I think that this book would allow schools to approach the TA issue from a ‘third party’ point of view- i.e. if it is what the ECM agenda demands then both parties are much more likely to feel that they are working towards a common goal rather than feel that things are being imposed on them without any thought behind the proposals.
Any other comments you wish to make about this book proposal?
I feel that I would have liked to have seen a chapter in greater detail, especially the chapters dealing with practical support strategies. Overall it does seem apt for publication at this time. Would the author feel it necessary to mention something about the Renewed Frameworks for Literacy and Numeracy which are going to have such a big impact in all classrooms in the next year or so?