Syl Johnson's first album,
Dresses Too Short, was fairly innocuous good-time soul, but he'd obviously been doing some thinking about the world around him in the interim between that and his second release.
Is It Because I'm Black is characterized by socially conscious songwriting, especially in the seven-and-a-half-minute title track, an elongated, serious statement of black pride with a sad funk-blues groove. It wouldn't be fair to call
Johnson a bandwagon jumper; this was before
Sly Stone's
There's a Riot Goin' On and
Marvin Gaye's
What's Going On had made realistic ghetto songs chic, and it was a fairly gutsy move for a minor soul singer such as
Syl to put such material at the forefront. While nothing else here matches that lost mini-classic, there are some good cuts along similar lines in which
Johnson pleads for tolerance and justice, including covers of jazzman
Oscar Brown's "Black Balloons,"
Joe South's "Walk a Mile in My Shoes," and, less successfully,
the Beatles' "Come Together." ~ Richie Unterberger
