Mea Culpa: Lessons on Law and Regret from U.S. History

by Steven W. Bender

Overview

In Mea Culpa, Steven W. Bender examines how the United States’ collective shame about its past has shaped the evolution of law and behavior. We regret slavery and segregationist Jim Crow laws. We eventually apologize, while ignoring other oppressions, and our legal response to regret often fails to be transformative for the affected groups. By examining policies and practices that have affected the lives of groups that have been historically marginalized and oppressed, Bender is able to draw persuasive connections between shame and its eventual legal manifestations. Analyzing the United States’ historical response to its own atrocities, Bender identifies and develops a definitive moral compass that guides us away from the policies and practices that lead to societal regret.

Mea Culpa challenges its readers. In a different era, might we have been slave owners or proprietors of a racially segregated establishment? It’s easy to judge immorality in the hindsight of history, but what current practices and policies will later generations regret?

More than a historical survey, this volume offers a framework for resolving some of the most contentious social problems of our time. Drawing on his background as a legal scholar, Bender tackles immigration, the death penalty, the war on terror, reproductive rights,
welfare, wage inequity, homelessness, mass incarceration, and same-sex marriage. Ultimately, he argues, it is the dehumanization of human beings that allows for practices to occur that will later be marked as regrettable. And all of us have a stake in standing on the side of history that resists dehumanization.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9781479899623
Publisher:	New York University Press
Publication date:	01/09/2015
Edition description:	New Edition
Pages:	256
Product dimensions:	6.30(w) x 9.00(h) x 1.20(d)

About the Author

Steven W. Bender is Professor of Law and Associate Dean for Planning and Strategic Initiatives at Seattle UniversitySchool of Law. He is the author of Mea Culpa: Lessons on Law and Regret from US History (NYU Press, 2015), Run for the Border: Vice and Virtue in U.S.-Mexico Border Crossings (NYU Press, 2012), Tierra y Libertad: Land, Liberty, and Latino Housing (NYU Press, 2010), and Greasers and Gringos: Latinos, Law, and the American Imagination (NYU Press, 2003).

Table of Contents

Contents
Acknowledgments ix
Introduction 1
Part I . Running for the Border to Escape Justice
1 El Fugitivo 11
Part I I . Economic Motivations for Southbound Border Runs
2 Gringos in Paradise 31
3 A Giant Sucking Sound 40
Part I I I . Illicit Motivations for Southbound Border Runs
4 Margaritaville: The Lure of Alcohol 57
5 Losin’ It: Prostitution and the Child Sex Trade 70
6 Going Southbound: Mexican Divorces and Medical 79
Border Runs
Part IV. Economic Motivations for Northbound Border Runs
7 Rum-Running for the Border 91
8 Acapulco Gold 95
9 Coming to America 114
Part V. A Framework for Comprehensive Border Reform
10 Lessons from 150 Years of Border Crossings 141
11 Good Neighbor Immigration Policy 158
viii | Contents
12 Reefer Madness 163
13 A Framework for Southbound Crossings 172
14 Laws the Border Leaves Behind 177
Conclusion 183
Notes 185
Index 221
About the Author 224

Editorial Reviews

"Bender, through the prism of regret for policies enacted as a result of dehumanization of particular groups, presents an admirable intersectional synthesis of current and past legal marginalization."

Choice

"A fascinating book that explores how American government has come to adopt policies that it regards in hindsight with great regret. Bender does a superb job of exploring both historical and current regrettable decisions and shows that they are all based on dehumanizing others. He offers a path forward based on a law founded on compassion. Through powerful examples and clear writing, Bender has written a book that is profound in its observations and conclusions and that deserves a wide readership."

Erwin Chemerinsky

"Bender articulates a bold challenge to those who value inclusive democracy: confront dehumanizing policies and media images with individual moral courage and collective compassion. Mea Culpa is an energizing elixir to revive our commitment to a broad definition of community and thus to avoid the sorrow of personal regret and the tragedy of national regret."

Hazel Weiser

"The book challenges readers to ask if we are as enlightened as we think we are."

The Seattle Times

"Steven W. Benders Mea Culpaprovoked deep sorrow and profound anger in me, as it will in most thoughtful readers. Professor Bender, one of the more nuanced listeners writing in the fields of immigration narratives and the codification of hate, has produced one of the more interesting books I have read in some time, paradoxically both troubling and hopeful. Of course, the many depredations he chroniclesexamples of sin verguenza, or shamelessnessare dismaying, and have caused great harm to the stigmatized groups and the body politic, but he also notes that the deep shaming of past mistakes has often led to personal and official expressions of genuine regret, reparations, and reconciliation. He is no Pangloss, but his transformative work is ultimately uplifting, despite its documenting such hateful and spirit-murdering narratives."

Michael A. Olivas

"Bender is a prolific author-activist whose work always commands a reading. One is rewarded for doing so because of the scope and complexity of Benders thought as well as his gift for prose. That he speaks and writes credibly in so many different conversations enhances the contribution of his work. . . . One need not be a natural law doctrinaire to recognize that law, jurisprudence, and morals have more than an accidental relationship. [Bender] zeroes in on this and shows precisely why this matters."

John Shuford

"Steven W. Bender’s Mea Culpa provoked deep sorrow and profound anger in me, as it will in most thoughtful readers. Professor Bender, one of the more nuanced listeners writing in the fields of immigration narratives and the codification of hate, has produced one of the more interesting books I have read in some time, paradoxically both troubling and hopeful. Of course, the many depredations he chronicles—examples of sin verguenza, or shamelessness—are dismaying, and have caused great harm to the stigmatized groups and the body politic, but he also notes that the deep shaming of past mistakes has often led to personal and official expressions of genuine regret, reparations, and reconciliation. He is no Pangloss, but his transformative work is ultimately uplifting, despite its documenting such hateful and spirit-murdering narratives."-Michael A. Olivas,William B. Bates Distinguished Chair in Law, University of Houston Law Center

"A fascinating book that explores how American government has come to adopt policies that it regards in hindsight with great regret. Bender does a superb job of exploring both historical and current regrettable decisions and shows that they are all based on dehumanizing others. He offers a path forward based on a law founded on compassion. Through powerful examples and clear writing, Bender has written a book that is profound in its observations and conclusions and that deserves a wide readership."-Erwin Chemerinsky,Raymond Pryke Professor of First Amendment Law, University of California, Irvine

"Bender is a prolific author-activist whose work always commands a reading. One is rewarded for doing so because of the scope and complexity of Bender’s thought as well as his gift for prose. That he speaks and writes credibly in so many different conversations enhances the contribution of his work. . . . One need not be a natural law doctrinaire to recognize that law, jurisprudence, and morals have more than an accidental relationship. [Bender] zeroes in on this and shows precisely why this matters."-John Shuford,Director of the Institute for Hate Studies, Gonzaga University

"Bender articulates a bold challenge to those who value inclusive democracy: confront dehumanizing policies and media images with individual moral courage and collective compassion. Mea Culpa is an energizing elixir to revive our commitment to a broad definition of community and thus to avoid the sorrow of personal regret and the tragedy of national regret."-Hazel Weiser,former executive director, Society of American Law Teachers

From the Publisher