The monumental embarrassment of their covers album,
Thank You, derailed
Duran Duran's impressive early-'90s comeback and its successor, the clumsily named
Medazzaland, finds the group trying regain lost territory.
John Taylor left the group early in the recording of
Medazzaland, leaving
Simon LeBon and
Nick Rhodes as the only surviving original members. With former
Missing Persons member
Warren Cuccurullo assisting on guitar, bass, and production,
LeBon and
Rhodes decide to update their basic
new romantic dance-pop to include
industrial,
Brit-pop, and
ambient flourishes. Ironically, all this window dressing merely emphasizes that
Duran Duran are at their best when they concentrate on straight-ahead
dance-pop and balladry, not when they try to be hip. Unfortunately, for most of
Medazzaland, the group tries to stay hip and contemporary, and ultimately that's what prevents the album from offering enough pleasure. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine