Practical Equality: Forging Justice in a Divided Nation

by Robert L. Tsai

Overview

“A work of striking political and legal imagination.” —Aziz Rana, author of The Two Faces of American Freedom

Robert L. Tsai offers a stirring account of how legal ideas that aren’t necessarily about equality have often been used to overcome resistance to justice and remain vital today. From the oppression of emancipated slaves after the Civil War, to the internment of Japanese Americans during World War II, to President Trump’s ban on Muslim travelers, Tsai applies lessons from past struggles to pressing contemporary issues.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780393358551
Publisher:	Norton, W. W. & Company, Inc.
Publication date:	10/20/2020
Pages:	288
Product dimensions:	5.50(w) x 8.30(h) x 0.80(d)

About the Author

Robert L. Tsai is Professor of Law and Law Alumni Scholar at Boston University. He is the author, most recently, of Practical Equality, and his essays have appeared in the New York Review of Books, Politico, Washington Post, Boston Globe, and Slate. He lives in Boston, Massachusetts, and Washington, DC.

Table of Contents

Introduction 1

Chapter 1 Practical Equality 13

Chapter 2 Fair Play 51

Chapter 3 The Rule of Reason 93

Chapter 4 No Cruelty 137

Chapter 5 Free Speech 181

Conclusion 229

Acknowledgments 233

Notes 235

Index 263

Editorial Reviews

"Appalled by inequality, our minds turn immediately to its opposite. Sidestepping that impulse, as Tsai advocates, requires giving up a satisfying rhetorical clarity, but it may bring us closer to our moral common sense."

New Yorker - Joshua Rothman

"Robert L. Tsai develops his argument via a great array of well-told historical and contemporary cases, and he is deeply alive to the perils as well as the promise of his proposal."

William E. Forbath

"Provocative and sensible.… Robert L. Tsai shows us that in the never-ending struggle for equality, progress is sometimes more effectively achieved indirectly."

David Cole

"Robert L. Tsai brilliantly describes great court decisions of the past that engaged in such bridge-building exercises, setting precedents for future justices to follow if they hope to sustain broad public support."

Bruce Ackerman

12/24/2018

Tsai (America’s Forgotten Constitutions), a law professor at American University, presents an unusually practical guide for advocates pursuing legal challenges to systemic inequalities in American society. Tsai argues that, while it would be gratifying to have courts apply 14th Amendment equal protection jurisprudence to eliminate all inequalities affecting minorities, women, and citizens and noncitizens alike in every case, courts are reluctant to make such sweeping rulings for a host of reasons—for example, fear of risking cultural disruption or popular blowback that might erode the courts’ authority. In the face of such reluctance, Tsai proposes that challenges based on more limited and focused legal theories have a greater likelihood of success. He demonstrates how traditional legal concepts such as due process and First Amendment rights have underpinned successful challenges. He illustrates his points with examples that touch on many current high-profile controversies, including racial profiling, the passage of the Defense of Marriage Act, and the current administration’s attempts to implement a ban on immigration from Muslim countries. Although his tactical suggestions are pragmatic, Tsai writes with passion about the moral necessity of eliminating the damage inequality does. This framework will resonate with readers interested in equality and advocacy. (Feb.)

Publishers Weekly

"Recognizing that the efforts to achieve full equality in an imperfect and often deeply flawed society are invariably met with severe resistance, Robert Tsai urges that those striving for equality must be strategic, determined, resilient, and often patient in order to achieve their goals. The struggle is worth it, but as history teaches, the battle cannot be won in a day. Tsai offers important lessons from history about how to move forward."

Geoffrey Stone

"Tsai's clear writing and questioning approach make this ultimately both accessible and engaging…Deeply thought-provoking as the topic of egalitarianism remains highly contested in today’s political discourse."

Booklist

"How do you fight for social change during periods of reaction or when structures of injustice are deeply entrenched? Robert Tsai’s Practical Equality beautifully wrestles with this dilemma and with the everyday political challenge of defending the principle of equality under less than ideal circumstances. The result is a work of striking political and legal imagination, an essential book with critical insights for activists, scholars, and lawyers."

Aziz Rana

2018-10-28

A timely review of America's pursuit of equality and pragmatic solutions to better achieve it.

Tsai (Law/American Univ.; America's Forgotten Constitutions: Defiant Visions of Power and Community, 2014, etc.) argues that to overcome injustice and inequality, we must be open to "second-best solutions" and "workable alternatives" as a matter of constitutional duty to seek common ground. This approach, writes the author, "practical egalitarianism…entails creating a long-term backup plan to deal with recurring situations where we struggle to enforce equality's demands. Practical egalitarians take seriously the basic idea of civic equality for all." Yet "equality," a loaded word with substantial variations in meaning and emphasis, can be tough to pin down. The author clearly understands this conundrum and addresses the issue with appropriate nuance and respect for diverse ideologies, and he argues that gradual and incremental developments can be just as important as massive legal battles, particularly in the advancement of fairness and free speech. Tsai examines how Americans have wrestled with equality throughout history, from slavery to the most recent ban on Muslim travelers, and the lessons we can draw from these struggles. Much of the book offers practical advice for spreading equality in the legal system, but he mostly avoids legalese, delivering his ideas in vivid prose: "Instead of flying higher and higher into theory in a quest for gorgeously rendered concepts that can solve all of our problems at once, our goal should be to immerse ourselves in the squalor of human existence." Like a battle "waged on multiple fronts," equality's advocates must be prepared to "initiate fresh lines of attack." The author's intended audience, however, is not entirely clear. The premise inherent in the subtitle will likely find currency among general readers, but the book seems best tailored for policymakers, scholars, jurists, and activists.

A well-reasoned treatise on the history of equality in America and how best to secure it in the future.

Kirkus Reviews