The biggest criticism of
The Bootleg Series, Vol. 5: Bob Dylan Live 1975 -- the third installment in
Columbia/
Legacy's excavation of the exhaustive
Bob Dylan vaults (the first was a box set, containing three volumes) -- is that it's a compilation of highlights from his
Rolling Thunder Revue of 1975, one that doesn't set out to replicate a set list but instead offers two discs and 22 tracks from this fabled tour. Apart from that, there's very little to complain about on this superlative set, which offers the first official release of
Rolling Thunder material. Yes, this had been heavily bootlegged over the decades, plus it was documented on
Dylan's notoriously unwatchable film
Renaldo & Clara and there was
Hard Rain, a collection culled from the post-
Thunder 1976 tour that was similar but sour and nowhere near as good the 1975 material, as this superb set illustrates. Hearing this is a revelation, even for serious
Dylan watchers -- those so serious to own several bootlegs, even a full shelf of
Dylan, but not as obsessive as those who track
Bob's every move -- and those who aren't as dedicated, yet still harbor a serious interest, will find this equally absorbing, since this is simply tremendous. It has become legend that
Dylan will change arrangements and switch lyrics at the drop of a hat, which was evident on his jaunt with
the Band in 1974, preserved for posterity on
Before the Flood. Even so, he's looser, wilder, and more alive in this careening, thrilling album, a record where
"A Hard Rain's a-Gonna Fall" gallops along as if it were
"Leopard Skin Pill-Box Hat." As that suggests, the wildest thing about this is the electric cuts, where an unwieldy band turns out an overpowering sound that sounds inevitable, as if it's the only way these songs could be played, even when you've heard these songs countless times before in other arrangements. The acoustic moments don't pack the same charge, nor do they contain many of his duets with
Joan Baez, yet they're intimate, passionate versions of the songs. In fact, there's not a bad moment here, and if it doesn't replicate the
Rolling Thunder tour list to the letter, it does indeed capture the essence of this legendary stint, which is why it's necessary for every serious fan. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine
