Disc 1
- Lament to Love
- A Sinner Kissed an Angel
- The Devil Sat Down and Cried
- Idaho
- Take Me
- Serenade in Blue
- It Can't Be Wrong
- You'll Never Know
- In My Arms
- Wait for Me Mary
- I Never Mention Your Name (oh, No!)
- Put Your Arms Around Me, Honey (I Never Knew Any Girl Like You)
- I Heard You Cried Last Night (And So Did I)
- For the First Time (I'VE Fallen in Love)
- How Many Times Do I Have to Tell You
- How Blue the Night
- I'll get By
- Long Ago and Far Away
- It Had to Be You
- Together
- Janie
- Laura
Disc 2
- The More I See You
- I Wish I Knew
- Till the End of Time
- Love Letters
- I'll Buy That Dream
- Some Sunday Morning
- That's for Me
- It Might as Well Be Spring
- Slowly
- I'm Always Chasing Rainbow
- It's a Grand Night
- Oh! What It Seemed to Be
- Come Rain or Come Shine
- In Love in Vain
- You Make Me Feel So Young
- Why Does it Get So Late So Early
- On the Boardwalk
- For You, For me, For Evermore
- How Are Things in Glocca Morra
- Mam' Selle
- Stella by Starlight
- There's No Business Like Show Business
Disc 3
- Ivy Dick Haymes
- Naughty Angeline
- I Wish I Didn't Love You So
- And Mimi
- The Treasure of Sierra Madre
- Teresa
- Little White Lies
- Nature Boy
- You Can't Be True, Dear
- It's Magic
- Every Day I Love You
- Comme Ci Comme Ca
- Bouquet of Roses
- Room Full of Roses
- Maybe It's Because
- The Old Master Painter
- Roses
- I Still Get a Thrill
- Count Every Star
- Can Anyone Explain? (No, No, No)
- You're Just in Love
- And So to Sleep Again
- Two Different Worlds