10/01/2021
The latest from historian Shawcross (France, Mexico and Informal Empire in Latin America, 1820–1867) continues his research on colonial powers in Mexico. He writes that in 1862, with the United States involved in its own civil war, French emperor Napoleon III saw his chance to wrest hegemony over Mexico from the States. Through a combination of lies and half-truths, he persuaded Maximilian, restless younger brother of the Austrian emperor, and his Spanish wife Carlota to leave Europe for Mexico to become emperor and empress of a country that knew little about them and hadn't asked for their involvement. Four years later, with the American Civil War over, the United States pushed back, aiding the forces of former Mexican president Benito Juarez in fighting against Maximilian's imperial soldiers. Shawcross adeptly narrates the fallout, with Napoleon folding under international pressure and his own failures at home and withdrawing all support for the young monarchs. Maximilian died in front of a Mexican firing squad, and Carlota struggled with mental illness for the remainder of her life. Shawcross argues that the story is the same as Algeria or Vietnam but a century earlier: the same hubris and a botched withdrawal, with tragic consequences. VERDICT Crisply written and meticulously researched, Shawcross's engaging book tells a lively story that will appeal to most history buffs.—David Keymer, Cleveland
Mr. Shawcross, a British historian, creates a balanced and deeply human portrait of the emperor…[a] deeply researched narrative.”—Wall Street Journal
"A superbly entertaining and well‑researched account that sets a new standard for histories of the doomed escapade."—Financial Times
"Shawcross’s fascinating debut is keenly attuned to the ironies and tragedies that Maximilian faced in his ill-fated task."—Guardian
“Shawcross deftly reexamines the tragicomic rule of the Austrian archduke Ferdinand Maximilian… In Shawcross’s persuasive retelling, Maximilian was a well-intentioned, if flawed, Enlightenment ruler buffeted by the great forces of the mid-nineteenth century.”—Foreign Affairs
“Shawcross… is especially good at describing the cultural gulf between the imperial couple and their subjects and their adopted realm… [P]owerfully and authoritatively, he places an episode often dismissed as an ego-driven historical absurdity within the deeper context of Mexico’s history…This is history as at once both tragedy and farce.” —Paul Lay, The Times, Book of the Week (UK)
“A majestic history… Shawcross’s vivid details turn the emperor into a character as ornate as the silk tapestries he imported. Such attention to the minutiae—including Maximilian’s hunt for rare larvae—makes his demise all the more heartrending.” —Daniel Rey, The Spectator
“Here is a well-researched, ably written, consistently interesting, and mercifully short book that deserves reading.”—New Criterion
“Edward Shawcross, a historian and first-time author, has a terrific story to tell here and he tackles it with real brio and narrative punch. This is a page-turning history of imperial hubris and nemesis, deceit and delusion, love and betrayal on a grand scale, written in an easy, lucid style.” —Justin Marozzi, The Sunday Times
“Devouring Edward Shawcross’s gripping book set in the 1860s, I was screaming at the hapless Austrian Archduke Maximilian: ‘Don’t do it!’ … [Shawcross] is an eloquent writer, good at showing both sides of an argument.” —Ysenda Maxtone Graham, The Daily Mail
“One virtue of Shawcross’s book is his uncovering of the non-comic aspects of Maximilian’s story, almost all involving the true villain, Napoleon III of France…. Shawcross’s entertaining, just occasionally over-detailed account leaves the emperor with some dignity, weaving the warp of his ridiculousness with the darker threads of his betrayal by his imperial allies in Europe.” —Julian Evans, The Daily Telegraph
“Crisply written and meticulously researched, Shawcross’s engaging book tells a lively story that will appeal to most history buffs.”—Library Journal
“The story of Maximilian is one of the most compelling, absurd, cynical, and revealing chapters in the history of Mexico and the nineteenth-century Atlantic world. Edward Shawcross has marvelous material to work with, and he handles it with insight and panache.”—H.W. Brands, author of The General vs. the President
“‘They are going to Mexico, which I cannot understand,’ wrote Queen Victoria, after dining with the royal couple chosen to reign over an unwilling nation that they had yet to see. No wonder she was perplexed. The story of how Mexico, having been halved by its aggressive neighbor to the north, was then invaded by one of Europe’s old empires, defies credulity and easy comprehension. Sure enough, Edward Shawcross seems almost to make fiction of it, deftly deploying his novelist’s eye for page-turning narrative and compellingly drawn characters. Yet as improbable as it may seem, this was a very real and very tragic chapter in two extraordinary histories—that of Mexico, and that of the arrogance of empire. If only a copy of The Last Emperor of Mexico could be sent back in time to the British queen. She would not have been able to put it down, and, in the end, would surely have understood.” —Matthew Restall, author of When Montezuma Met Cortés
“The story of Mexico’s last emperor is an unhappy one, with an almost inevitable conclusion. Archduke Maximilian of Habsburg was a romantic dreamer, beguiled by the prospect of becoming emperor of Mexico, lied to by Napoleon III of France, who promised him unwavering military support, and tricked by Mexican politicians into thinking he was a popular choice for ruler. After three years of fireworks, grand balls, butterfly hunts, administrative chaos, bedbugs, dysentery, treachery, and civil war, Maximilian was captured and killed; his wife went mad. It is a story where no one comes out well, but Edward Shawcross tells it with verve, weaving together the big-power politics, fevered intrigue, and low villainy behind Maximilian of Mexico’s ill-starred venture.” —Martyn Rady, author of The Habsburgs
“France’s doomed efforts to install an emperor in Mexico have long been treated as a bizarre but minor sideshow to the Civil War in the United States. In this engrossing, fast-paced book, Edward Shawcross tells the story of the French Intervention in its own right, giving a deeply human portrait of a feckless Austrian Archduke Maximilian, who cares more for court etiquette than imperial finances, and his ambitious wife Carlotta, who descends into madness as their New World empire disintegrates. This is by far the best book we have on Maximilian and Carlotta’s ill-fated rule in Mexico.” —Alice L. Baumgartner, author of South to Freedom
“Reads like a lush screenplay with a gaudy cast: a wandering court of effete European exiles, blustering French generals, a ragtag army of Mexican rebels, a US army distracted by civil war, and high drama in Paris and London as a scheme to sit a Habsburg prince on the throne of Mexico luridly unravels.” —Geoffrey Wawro, author of A Mad Catastrophe
