Agalloch's second album,
The Mantle, is a leaps-and-bounds improvement over their first full-length, 1999's
Pale Folklore. That wasn't a bad album, but it was hampered by a low-budget production job that didn't suit the sophisticated tone of the music. The improved production is the first thing that stands out here, evident in the more detailed arrangements, the classier guitar tones, and the fuller overall sound. That said, the music itself has also evolved and matured. Along with the
Katatonia-inspired guitar work and grim, scratchy
black metal vocals also present on
Pale Folklore, a number of other sounds work their way into
The Mantle, among them prominent acoustic guitar-strumming and cleanly sung vocals, Scandinavian-tinged
folk guitar-picking (the middle breakdown during
"I Am the Wooden Doors" is straight out of
Ulver's bag), timpani percussion, and a few subtle electronic interludes. It is not just the range of sounds that's impressive, though, but rather how smoothly they are woven together, creating an album that flows from beginning to end, using its entire 68-minute running time to make its point without wearing out its welcome.
Agalloch's biggest strength, much like the early work of
Ulver and
Katatonia, is their ability to create an epic type of listening experience without resorting to bombast or heavy-handedness, and that quality is plainly evident here. Factor in the excellent artwork and packaging (which features photos of the bandmembers looking very poised and European), and you have one of 2002's most accomplished and surprising metal-related albums. ~ William York
