Tsardom of Sufficiency, Empire of Norms: Statistics, Land Allotments, and Agrarian Reform in Russia, 1700-1921

by David W. Darrow

Overview

What happens when you measure an economy? How does measurement impact policy? In Tsardom of Sufficiency, Empire of Norms David Darrow responds to these broad questions by looking at the application and profound consequences of statistical measurement to the peasant economy in Russia, from the eighteenth century to the Civil War. Nearly all studies of Russia make reference to the land allotment, or "nadel," as a measure of peasant wellbeing. This is the first work examining the origins of the nadel, how statistical measurement converted it into a modern entitlement, and how it framed the state?peasant relationship. Land, Darrow argues, was life ? peasants needed it and the state, most everyone believed, had an obligation to provide it. The question, however, was how much land was enough. Statistics supplied the answer but also locked policy-makers and society into a particular way of seeing peasants and their economy. Even the empire's final attempt to reform the peasant economy after 1905 remained locked within the old regime category of the nadel. Statistical measurement strengthened, rather than weakened, the nadel as a category of peasant economic wellbeing such that it persisted beyond 1917 into the early years of Soviet power. Based on archival sources and rural councils' statistical studies, Tsardom of Sufficiency, Empire of Norms shows how the state constructed both an image and a measure of peasant wellbeing from which it could not escape, and how the resultant perception that peasants were entitled to a sufficient allotment became a major obstacle to successful agrarian reform.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780773555075
Publisher:	McGill-Queens University Press
Publication date:	12/05/2018
Edition description:	3rd ed.
Pages:	376
Product dimensions:	6.00(w) x 9.00(h) x 1.30(d)

About the Author

David W. Darrow is associate professor of history at the University of Dayton.

Table of Contents

Acknowledgments ix

A Note about Translations, Transliterations, and Dates xiii

Introduction: The New Land Allotment Tradition, the New Moral Economy 3

1 Setting the Precedent: The State of Sufficiency 18

2 Serf Emancipation: Sanctifying the Normed Nadel, Measuring Its Sufficiency 54

3 Normalizing the Nadel and Peasant Economy: History and Zemstvo Statistics 94

4 "Normal" Households: Economic Development and the Middle Peasant 131

5 Stolypin's Wager on the Middle: Land Norms and "Sufficiency" 165

6 Land Norms as Social Justice in Revolution, Civil War, and Beyond 214

Conclusion: The Legacy of Serfdom and Persistence of the Sufficient Nadel 242

Notes 251

Bibliography 293

Index 347

Editorial Reviews

"Well-written, with hints of grace, wit, and wry humour, Tsardom of Sufficiency, Empire of Norms is an impressive work that delivers new insights on its subject and much food for thought besides. Darrow succeeds in getting readers to think seriously about the meaning of the presumed relationships between words and facts and how these presumptions mattered in shaping Russian political thought and economic life." Willard Sunderland, University of Cincinnati


"Tsardom of Sufficiency, Empire of Norms is an important book that will be of lasting relevance. It is a clear-headed study of a basic and understudied category in Russian and world history, human sufficiency, viewed through an institution and a measure called the nadel ? a specific allotment of land. The entire agrarian system was built on it. It is of immediate relevance to anyone in the Russian field, anyone interested in agrarian development, and anyone interested in the origins of the modern state's responsibility for the welfare of its subjects and citizens." Yanni Kotsonis, New York University

From the Publisher