New Adventures in Hi-Fi functioned as the starting point for
Up,
R.E.M.'s first album without drummer
Bill Berry and their first that truly repudiates the legacy of jangle pop.
Up is dominated by keyboards, muted percussion, buried guitars, and moody melodies -- only "Daysleeper" finds the group in familiar sonic territory. What's striking about the album is that it doesn't sound like a dramatic departure; even without the ringing guitars, it sounds like
R.E.M., albeit
R.E.M. trying to be adventurous and hip. To a certain extent, that's a good thing, since it proves that the band has developed a signature sound more elastic than many would have predicted, and that they are skilled enough to successfully take risks with their sound. Above all else,
Up is an accomplished and varied record, the work of smart record-makers and veteran musicians. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine