Words and Thoughts: Subsentences, Ellipsis, and the Philosophy of Language

by Robert Stainton

Overview

It is a near truism of philosophy of language that sentences are prior to words. Sentences, it is said, are what we believe, assert, and argue for; uses of them constitute our evidence in semantics; only they stand in inferential relations, and are true or false. Sentences are, indeed, the only things that fundamentally have meaning.

Does this near truism really hold of human languages? Robert Stainton, drawing on a wide body of evidence, argues forcefully that speakers can and do use mere words, not sentences, to communicate complete thoughts. He then considers the implications of this empirical result for language-thought relations, various doctrines of sentence primacy, and the semantics-pragmatics boundary.

The book is important both for its philosophical and empirical claims, and for the methodology employed. Stainton illustrates how the methods and detailed results of the various cognitive sciences can bear on central issues in philosophy of language. At the same time, he applies philosophical distinctions with subtlety and care, to show that arguments which seemingly support the primacy of sentences do not really do so. The result is a paradigm example of The New Philosophy of Language: a rich melding of empirical work with traditional philosophy of language.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780199250394
Publisher:	Oxford University Press
Publication date:	06/22/2009
Pages:	262
Product dimensions:	6.10(w) x 9.10(h) x 0.60(d)

Table of Contents

Part One: The Appearances and Some Background

1. Introduction: The appearances, and what they might mean
2. Further Background Issues

Part Two: The Genuineness Issue

3. Not A Full-fledged Speech Act?
4. Extra-Grammatical Maneuvers
5. Semantic Ellipsis
6. Syntactic Ellipsis
7. A Divide and Conquer Strategy
8. A Positive Representational-Pragmatic View

Part Three: Implications

9. Language-Thought Relations
10. Sentence Primacy
11. The Sentences, Assertion and the Semantics-Pragmatics Boundary

Editorial Reviews

"Stainton is a meticulous philosopher. In Words and Thoughts, he explains his positions and those of his opponents in great detail and with great care. Words and Thoughts is to be enthusiastically recommended to philosophers of language, particularly to the growing group of philosophers conversant with the cutting-edge work in linguistics."—Edouard Machery, Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews

From the Publisher