When Candie Montgomery reluctantly leaves a good job in Chicago to help save her family's failing used car business, she's shocked to find that the townspeople of Pinewood, Kentucky are shunning her—all 876 of them. Rumor has it that Candie's to blame for the broken engagement between her twin sister Sarah and her close friend Nick. But how can she be the other woman without even knowing it?

With the family business, her reputation, and her relationship with Sarah on the line, Candie needs an insta-boyfriend to put a lid on the gossip, pronto. Damage control comes in the sexy form of Tommy Tucker. It was supposed to be a quick fix, but Candie might just be in for the long haul.