By the Fire We Carry: The Generations-Long Fight for Justice on Native Land

by Rebecca Nagle Narrated by Rebecca Nagle

Overview

Notes From Your Bookseller

A murder leads to a landmark Supreme Court decision that reaffirms Native rights in America. This page-turner blends first-person reportage and historical sleuthing from journalist and podcaster Nagle, an enrolled member of the Cherokee Nation.

“Rebecca Nagle gives a clear and compelling narration of her look into how a small-town murder in the Muscogee Nation led to a significant 2020 Supreme Court case-and the largest restoration of Native tribal land in American history. . . . An illuminating listen.” - AudioFile

""Impeccably researched. . . . A fascinating book and an important one.” - Washington Post

“[A] brilliant, kaleidoscopic debut. . . . Nagle's narrative is lucid and moving. . . . A showstopper.” - Publishers Weekly, starred review

Most Anticipated Book of the Fall: Washington Post, People, Los Angeles Times, Parade, Bustle, Book Riot

A powerful work of reportage and American history that braids the story of the forced removal of Native Americans onto treaty lands in the nation's earliest days, and a small-town murder in the 1990s that led to a Supreme Court ruling reaffirming Native rights to that land more than a century later

Before 2020, American Indian reservations made up roughly 55 million acres of land in the United States. Nearly 200 million acres are reserved for National Forests-in the emergence of this great nation, our government set aside more land for trees than for Indigenous peoples.

In the 1830s Muscogee people were rounded up by the US military at gunpoint and forced into exile halfway across the continent. At the time, they were promised this new land would be theirs for as long as the grass grew and the waters ran. But that promise was not kept. When Oklahoma was created on top of Muscogee land, the new state claimed their reservation no longer existed. Over a century later, a Muscogee citizen was sentenced to death for murdering another Muscogee citizen on tribal land. His defense attorneys argued the murder occurred on the reservation of his tribe, and therefore Oklahoma didn't have the jurisdiction to execute him. Oklahoma asserted that the reservation no longer existed. In the summer of 2020, the Supreme Court settled the dispute. Its ruling that would ultimately underpin multiple reservations covering almost half the land in Oklahoma, including Nagle's own Cherokee Nation.

Here Rebecca Nagle recounts the generations-long fight for tribal land and sovereignty in eastern Oklahoma. By chronicling both the contemporary legal battle and historic acts of Indigenous resistance, By the Fire We Carry stands as a landmark work of American history. The story it tells exposes both the wrongs that our nation has committed and the Native-led battle for justice that has shaped our country.

Supplemental enhancement PDF accompanies the audiobook.

Editorial Reviews

From the Publisher

"Richly reported." — The New Yorker, Briefly Noted

“I cannot think of a book that more powerfully illustrates that the past is never dead. By the Fire We Carry is a triumph.”
— Claudio Saunt, author of Unworthy Republic

“[A] fascinating history of Native American land, the U.S. government’s broken promises and outright theft of said land, and the legal battles fought by Indigenous peoples to reclaim what is theirs.”  — Ilana Masad, NPR’s Books We Love

"Nagle is skilled at explaining the intricacies of the legal arguments in terms that a layperson can understand. . . . She compellingly describes not only the historical wrongs committed against Indigenous peoples, but also how we can’t excuse those wrongs by assuming that they were acceptable to their contemporaries because of some kind of lesser moral standard. . . . Impeccably researched. . . . A fascinating book and an important one.” — Washington Post

"A narrative as propulsive and affecting as it is infuriating.” — Vanity Fair 

“Nagle's gripping historical and legal chronicle sheds light on a centuries-long struggle for Indigenous sovereignty and tribal land in Oklahoma." — New York Times Book Review

"This powerful, important story is a must-read addition to any American's historical education.” — People, Best Books of September 2024

“A powerful history. . . . Blending reportage and historical research into a propulsive narrative that reads like a legal thriller. . . . Detailed and impassioned, it’s a gripping corrective to the historical record, and not to be missed.” — Esquire

“Terrific. . . . Nagle writes with sensitivity and empathy for the Native American communities she grew up in and around.” — The Atlantic

“Rebecca Nagle delivers a true life legal thriller with rare ambition and scope. . . . One of the best books of the year.”  — Parade, 30 Best New Book Releases This Month 

“Nagle gracefully carries readers back and forth through time, explaining the history of the Five Tribes before and after the Trail of Tears, the evolution of U.S. policy toward Native Americans, and the unique peculiarities of Indian law…. She is just as careful to elucidate the technicalities of court procedure, helping readers understand how a death-row appeal on jurisdictional grounds led to ‘the largest restoration of Indigenous land in US history.’ The legal arcana are dense, but Nagle’s writing is not. With restrained passion she exposes one injustice after another…. Gripping, infuriating, and illuminating—a valuable corrective to our national ignorance.” — Kirkus, starred review

“In a fiery account as chilling as a legal thriller, Rebecca Nagle lays bare centuries of injustice in Oklahoma and the southeastern lands from which the American government exiled her ancestors and thousands of other Indigenous peoples. By the Fire We Carry is a clear and courageous call for justice.”
— Tiya Miles, author of All That She Carried and Ties That Bind

“This is great storytelling, dogged reporting, and a compelling personal tale all wrapped in a book that should live for years to come.”
— Timothy Egan, author of A Fever in the Heartland

“Nagle brings us face-to-face with personal and collective histories and their consequences in a multigenerational story of corruption, betrayal, and the enduring strength of Native resistance. This book is enlightening, enraging, inspiring, and impossible to put down.”
— Ijeoma Oluo, author of So You Want to Talk About Race and Mediocre

“This is brilliant journalism and exceptional history. In the best tradition of social justice writing, it challenges the head, breaks the heart, and offers hope for the future.”
— Philip J. Deloria, Dakota descent, author of Becoming Mary Sully

“Part legal page-turner, part her own compelling family saga, and part eloquent lament for the horrific way our nation has treated Native Americans over the centuries, Rebecca Nagle’s By the Fire We Carry has also given us something exceedingly rare—a story about Native Americans in the Supreme Court in which the good guys actually win.” — Adam Cohen, author of Supreme Inequality

“Spanning several centuries and covering topics ranging from the rights of impoverished Native criminal defendants to the Indian law jurisprudence of the United States Supreme Court, By the Fire We Carry is essential reading for the American public.”
— Sarah Deer, JD; enrolled citizen, Muscogee (Creek) Nation; author of The Beginning and End of Rape

“With a veteran storyteller’s talent and the easy first-person narration of a family memoirist, Nagle shows how the tragic political legacy tribes have been given continues to disrupt Native communities today.”
— Kevin K. Washburn, dean, University of Iowa College of Law; citizen of the Chickasaw Nation; former assistant secretary for Indian Affairs

“By The Fire We Carry is history come alive, an intelligent and personal story about justice. Rebecca Nagle is at her best as a deft journalist and storyteller.”
— Nick Estes, author of Our History Is the Future  

“[A] brilliant, kaleidoscopic debut. . . . Nagle’s narrative is lucid and moving . . . . a showstopper.” — Publishers Weekly, starred review

“In this thrilling legal exposé, investigative journalist Nagle uses her exemplary skills to scrutinize the Supreme Court case, McGirt vs Oklahoma. . . . Combining impeccable research with rich detail and scintillating prose, Nagle tells a story that is two hundred years in the making and enormously relevant today. Excellent for book groups; fans of Patrick Radden Keefe and David Grann will be transfixed. . . . [This is an] important topic made electric by Nagle's dogged reporting and suspense as riveting as a Michael Connelly courtroom drama.” — Booklist, starred review

“A vital account. . . . With precision and ease, Nagle defines and contextualizes legal terms and historical figures, allowing the reader to gain footholds for exploration and discussion as well as pass judgment on the supposed impartial nature of the American government and Supreme Court….essential reading for considering how the country can end this cycle of irreparable damage and move toward a more just future.” — BookPage, starred review

“Breathtaking: essential reading for anyone yet to understand who US law exists to serve, and who it exists to exploit. Nagle’s book achieves impeccable balance; it’s a call for hope which still never loses sight of the labor and blood underpinning every victory in this rigged system. A triumph.” — Noreen Masud, author of A Flat Place

“Compellingly told and deeply researched, Nagle’s timely work brilliantly reveals the sweeping and yet profoundly personal consequences of ongoing Indigenous struggles for sovereignty.” — Caroline Dodds Pennock, author of On Savage Shores

“[Nagle’s] historical analysis, combined with her commentary on the endurance of contemporary Native American activism, provided a unique and fresh perspective on the issue of trivial sovereignty, leaving a powerful message of hope and determination.” — The Harvard Crimson

“A powerful work of reportage and American history…” — Next Big Idea Club, September 2024 Must-Read Books

"[A] gripping legal thriller . . . . This is essential reading on American history." — 425 Magazine, 3 Books to Fall for This September

“…deeply felt, crisply written, and superbly knowledgeable.  Any lawyer involved with Indian law should read this book.  So should anyone who wants to appreciate the history of the American frontier – both what white settlers won, and what America’s native peoples held on to. And so should those of us who live in Lafayette County, in the solid corner of northeastern Mississippi that the Chickasaw ceded, and or the broad arc of territory that the Choctaw surrendered, before they were removed.” — The Oxford Eagle

“A clear and compelling narration. . . Nagle, a journalist whose reporting includes her podcast, This Land, is a practiced speaker, and she makes complex history accessible to listeners. She weaves the personal and political together into an illuminating listen.” — Literary Hub, "AudioFile’s Best Audiobooks of November"

"No part of the judiciary exposes the chasm between American ideals and institutional practice like federal Indian law. In By the Fire We Carry, Nagle, a Cherokee journalist, turns a case most Americans haven’t heard of into a legal thriller." — New York Times Book Review

Kirkus Reviews

★ 2024-07-10
A Cherokee journalist unpacks the landmark 2020 Supreme Court case that recognized the eastern half of the state of Oklahoma as Indian country.

In 1832, almost 200 years beforeMcGirt v. Oklahoma, the Supreme Court held inWorcester v. Georgia that the Cherokee nation was a sovereign power. Andrew Jackson ignored it, forcing the Cherokee, Choctaw, Chickasaw, Muscogee (Creek), and Seminole nations—collectively called the Five Tribes—to leave their ancestral lands in what is now the southeastern United States and go west of the Mississippi to Indian Territory. Nagle gracefully carries readers back and forth through time, explaining the history of the Five Tribes before and after the Trail of Tears, the evolution of U.S. policy toward Native Americans, and the unique peculiarities of Indian law, thornily complex in part because “US courts kept bending the rules, and not to the benefit of tribes.” She is just as careful to elucidate the technicalities of court procedure, helping readers understand how a death-row appeal on jurisdictional grounds led to “the largest restoration of Indigenous land in US history.” The legal arcana are dense, but Nagle’s writing is not. With restrained passion she exposes one injustice after another. Following a recitation of the greed and lawlessness prompted by the discovery of oil on Muscogee land, she observes that the “origin story of the great state of Oklahoma contains a vast criminal conspiracy to rob Native people of their land and money.” Of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, considered the swing vote in the case, Nagle writes: “After everything our ancestors sacrificed, our land was in the hands of this one person—who knew a fraction of our history, if that. The feeling was powerlessness.”

Gripping, infuriating, and illuminating—a valuable corrective to our national ignorance.

Product Details

BN ID:	2940160591193
Publisher:	HarperCollins
Publication date:	09/10/2024
Edition description:	Unabridged

Videos