Diagnosis, Therapy, and Evidence: Conundrums in Modern American Medicine

by Gerald N. Grob, Allan V. Horwitz

Overview

Employing historical and contemporary data and case studies, the authors also examine tonsillectomy, cancer, heart disease, anxiety, and depression, and identify differences between rhetoric and reality and the weaknesses in diagnosis and treatment.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780813548128
Publisher:	Rutgers University Press
Publication date:	11/13/2009
Series:	Critical Issues in Health and Medicine
Sold by:	Barnes & Noble
Format:	eBook
Pages:	270
File size:	398 KB

About the Author

Gerald N. Grob is the Henry E. Sigerist Professor of the History of Medicine Emeritus in the Institute for Health, Health Care Policy, and Aging Research at Rutgers University. He has written extensively, including The Dilemma of Federal Mental Health Policy: Radical Reform or Incremental Change? (Rutgers University Press).

Table of Contents

Preface
List of Abbreviations
Chapter 1 Rhetoric and Reality in Modern American Medicine
Chapter 2 Medical Rivalry and Etiological Speculation
Chapter 3 How Theory Makes Bad Practice
Chapter 4 How Science Tries to Explain Deadly Diseases
Chapter 5 Transforming Amorphous Stress into Discrete Disorders
Chapter 6 Creating Consensus From Diagnostic Confusion
Chapter 7 PostTraumatic Stress Disorder
Where Do We Go From Here?

Editorial Reviews

"Through a series of fascinating cases, Grob and Horwitz show how the diagnostic and treatment rhetoric of medicine and psychiatry often far exceeds the scientific evidence. A significant contribution to our understanding of medicalization."

Brandeis University - Peter Conrad

"This book deserves to be in the libraries of medical schools and schools of public health. Recommended."

Choice

"This book is an outstanding collection of highly informative and well-written chapters that aim to provide the reader with an understanding of the complexities of diagnosis and treatment in some important chronic diseases, from peptic ulcers to post-traumatic stress disorder. The authors bring together into one book a variety of medical conditions that have been discussed in different places, allowing a rich comparison of their similarities and differences."

professor of sociology, University of Maryland, Baltimore County - William Rothstein

"Medical historian Gerald Grob and medical sociologist Alan Horwitz provide an important and carefully crafted interdisciplinary analysis of how numerous therapies are introduced into clinical practice in the absence of clear and compelling data and kept alive by a combination of faith, analogy, tradition, ideology, inertia, and politics."

Journal of the History of Medicine

"The case study structure of the book nicely reflects the authors' disciplinary interests and is justified by the burden of their argument—which turns on the complex and contingent nature of the historical and sociological processes through which diseases are defined and managed."

author of Our Present Complaint: American Medicine, Then and Now - Charles Rosenberg

"The case study structure of the book nicely reflects the authors' disciplinary interests and is justified by the burden of their argument—which turns on the complex and contingent nature of the historical and sociological processes through which diseases are defined and managed."

From the Publisher

"Through a series of fascinating cases, Grob and Horwitz show how the diagnostic and treatment rhetoric of medicine and psychiatry often far exceeds the scientific evidence. A significant contribution to our understanding of medicalization."

— Peter Conrad

Brandeis University