"[An] earth-shaking exposé of clerical corruption ... What Martel does, quite masterfully, is to connect the dots that reveal an ecclesial system in profound decay ... In the Closet of the Vatican examines in impressive detail the double lives led by many of the church's prelates ... Without question, [the book] is a truly remarkable publishing event." - National Catholic Reporter
"It’s a bewildering and vast piece of reporting ... The picture Martel draws is jaw-dropping ... I urge every Catholic to read it, however difficult that may be." - Andrew Sullivan, New York Magazine
"[T]he book is astonishing." - Associated Press
"This masterful and spine-chilling study of the sexual life in the Vatican is the most detailed exposé of sexual corruption in the heart of Catholic establishment. This is the first time somebody has succeeded in having access to priests’ sexual lives in the Vatican … Martel surely does not criticize homosexuality but what he is critical of is the hypocrisy around the sexual lives of the priests. This beautifully written and well-researched book would bring many adjectives to mind — revealing, explosive, shocking, stunning, chilling, sensational, and many more. It may not be easy to read it for a believer but everybody must read this astonishing piece of investigative journalism." - Washington Book Review
"Stunned may be a much-overused word, but it's the best one I know to describe my wonderment at the dimensions of what has come into view […] All this builds up to the realisation that you are seeing something which, once seen cannot be unseen. By anyone who has seen it. Once it is seen, it is known as a fact about the Church's institutional working that cannot be got around. To pretend otherwise is a sign of delusion." - James Alison, ABC.net.au
"A truly shocking theory about the Vatican; the largest gay community in the world" - Il Giornale [Italy]
"Probably one of the best books by a journalist ever written" - Gazeta Wyborcza [Poland]
"Martel’s conversational style is that of the raconteur […] he tells a captivating story" - Catholic Herald
"A glimpse of the poisonous world that Frédéric Martel, himself gay, has spent five years researching for this book" - Andrew Brown, Guardian
"An important revelation" - Daily Telegraph
"Sensational … this is much, much more than an expose of some taffeta-clad hypocrites…fascinating" - Sunday Times
"Explosive … Pope Francis seems to be … determined to reform the Vatican … If Martel’s book proves anything, it is that this is now seriously overdue … It would be a mistake to rubbish this book … [Martel is] a highly intelligent and honest journalist and the Church will need courage to respond to his revelations fruitfully" - The Tablet
