The Authoress of the Odyssey is one of Samuel Butler's most provocative and unconventional works of classical criticism, a daring reinterpretation of one of the central texts of Western literature. In this study, Butler advances the radical thesis that the Odyssey, long attributed to Homer, was in fact composed by a woman. His argument is not a mere curiosity of scholarship but a sustained, intricate, and persuasive examination of style, geography, psychology, and narrative technique within the epic. With characteristic boldness, Butler challenges the deeply ingrained assumptions of philology and literary history, opening a new lens through which to view one of the foundational epics of antiquity.
At the heart of Butler's thesis is the observation that the Odyssey presents a markedly different sensibility from the Iliad. Where the latter emphasizes martial valor, the clash of heroes, and the grandeur of war, the Odyssey centers on domestic life, family bonds, household management, and the subtle intelligence of figures such as Penelope, Nausicaa, and Odysseus himself in moments of wit and restraint. Butler argues that the epic's acute attention to feminine concerns—hospitality, courtship, fidelity, and emotional nuance—suggests not merely an audience of women but an author intimately familiar with women's lives and perspectives.
Equally significant is Butler's geographical analysis. He identifies the settings of the Odyssey not as vague mythical constructs but as rooted in the landscape of Sicily, particularly around Trapani. He builds his case on detailed topographical correspondences, asserting that only a writer native to the area could have so vividly described the coastlines, harbors, and cultural milieu. For Butler, this geographical precision becomes a cornerstone in identifying the possible origin of the poem and its authoress.
Butler's argument also delves into narrative style. He highlights the contrasts between the sprawling, violent grandeur of the Iliad and the more intimate, carefully plotted storytelling of the Odyssey. The structure of the Odyssey, with its complex weaving of tales, interest in hospitality scenes, and recurrent themes of fidelity and temptation, reveals, in Butler's reading, a distinctly feminine literary imagination. This perspective, though controversial, forces readers to reconsider long-accepted categories of authorship, authority, and the construction of literary tradition.
The book is not merely a dry treatise but a lively and engaging work of criticism. Butler writes with wit, conviction, and a flair for provocation, qualities that made his scholarship both admired and contested. His prose, at once incisive and accessible, engages not only the scholar of Greek literature but also the curious reader interested in the dynamics of authorship, gender, and cultural history. His thesis, while unconventional, resonates with modern discussions of voice, identity, and the shaping of the literary canon.
The Authoress of the Odyssey remains a remarkable example of how classical texts can be reinterpreted across centuries. Whether one agrees with Butler's conclusions or not, the work challenges readers to approach ancient literature with fresh questions and an openness to perspectives that disrupt inherited assumptions. It stands as both an important moment in the history of Homeric criticism and as a bold literary artifact in its own right.
In its mixture of scholarship, imagination, and intellectual audacity, Butler's book exemplifies the restless spirit of Victorian inquiry, unwilling to accept authority without scrutiny and eager to push the boundaries of established thought. For students of classical literature, feminist criticism, and the history of ideas, it offers a compelling case study of how literature can be reimagined through the lens of gender, geography, and cultural identity.
1101420127
At the heart of Butler's thesis is the observation that the Odyssey presents a markedly different sensibility from the Iliad. Where the latter emphasizes martial valor, the clash of heroes, and the grandeur of war, the Odyssey centers on domestic life, family bonds, household management, and the subtle intelligence of figures such as Penelope, Nausicaa, and Odysseus himself in moments of wit and restraint. Butler argues that the epic's acute attention to feminine concerns—hospitality, courtship, fidelity, and emotional nuance—suggests not merely an audience of women but an author intimately familiar with women's lives and perspectives.
Equally significant is Butler's geographical analysis. He identifies the settings of the Odyssey not as vague mythical constructs but as rooted in the landscape of Sicily, particularly around Trapani. He builds his case on detailed topographical correspondences, asserting that only a writer native to the area could have so vividly described the coastlines, harbors, and cultural milieu. For Butler, this geographical precision becomes a cornerstone in identifying the possible origin of the poem and its authoress.
Butler's argument also delves into narrative style. He highlights the contrasts between the sprawling, violent grandeur of the Iliad and the more intimate, carefully plotted storytelling of the Odyssey. The structure of the Odyssey, with its complex weaving of tales, interest in hospitality scenes, and recurrent themes of fidelity and temptation, reveals, in Butler's reading, a distinctly feminine literary imagination. This perspective, though controversial, forces readers to reconsider long-accepted categories of authorship, authority, and the construction of literary tradition.
The book is not merely a dry treatise but a lively and engaging work of criticism. Butler writes with wit, conviction, and a flair for provocation, qualities that made his scholarship both admired and contested. His prose, at once incisive and accessible, engages not only the scholar of Greek literature but also the curious reader interested in the dynamics of authorship, gender, and cultural history. His thesis, while unconventional, resonates with modern discussions of voice, identity, and the shaping of the literary canon.
The Authoress of the Odyssey remains a remarkable example of how classical texts can be reinterpreted across centuries. Whether one agrees with Butler's conclusions or not, the work challenges readers to approach ancient literature with fresh questions and an openness to perspectives that disrupt inherited assumptions. It stands as both an important moment in the history of Homeric criticism and as a bold literary artifact in its own right.
In its mixture of scholarship, imagination, and intellectual audacity, Butler's book exemplifies the restless spirit of Victorian inquiry, unwilling to accept authority without scrutiny and eager to push the boundaries of established thought. For students of classical literature, feminist criticism, and the history of ideas, it offers a compelling case study of how literature can be reimagined through the lens of gender, geography, and cultural identity.
The Authoress of the Odyssey
The Authoress of the Odyssey is one of Samuel Butler's most provocative and unconventional works of classical criticism, a daring reinterpretation of one of the central texts of Western literature. In this study, Butler advances the radical thesis that the Odyssey, long attributed to Homer, was in fact composed by a woman. His argument is not a mere curiosity of scholarship but a sustained, intricate, and persuasive examination of style, geography, psychology, and narrative technique within the epic. With characteristic boldness, Butler challenges the deeply ingrained assumptions of philology and literary history, opening a new lens through which to view one of the foundational epics of antiquity.
At the heart of Butler's thesis is the observation that the Odyssey presents a markedly different sensibility from the Iliad. Where the latter emphasizes martial valor, the clash of heroes, and the grandeur of war, the Odyssey centers on domestic life, family bonds, household management, and the subtle intelligence of figures such as Penelope, Nausicaa, and Odysseus himself in moments of wit and restraint. Butler argues that the epic's acute attention to feminine concerns—hospitality, courtship, fidelity, and emotional nuance—suggests not merely an audience of women but an author intimately familiar with women's lives and perspectives.
Equally significant is Butler's geographical analysis. He identifies the settings of the Odyssey not as vague mythical constructs but as rooted in the landscape of Sicily, particularly around Trapani. He builds his case on detailed topographical correspondences, asserting that only a writer native to the area could have so vividly described the coastlines, harbors, and cultural milieu. For Butler, this geographical precision becomes a cornerstone in identifying the possible origin of the poem and its authoress.
Butler's argument also delves into narrative style. He highlights the contrasts between the sprawling, violent grandeur of the Iliad and the more intimate, carefully plotted storytelling of the Odyssey. The structure of the Odyssey, with its complex weaving of tales, interest in hospitality scenes, and recurrent themes of fidelity and temptation, reveals, in Butler's reading, a distinctly feminine literary imagination. This perspective, though controversial, forces readers to reconsider long-accepted categories of authorship, authority, and the construction of literary tradition.
The book is not merely a dry treatise but a lively and engaging work of criticism. Butler writes with wit, conviction, and a flair for provocation, qualities that made his scholarship both admired and contested. His prose, at once incisive and accessible, engages not only the scholar of Greek literature but also the curious reader interested in the dynamics of authorship, gender, and cultural history. His thesis, while unconventional, resonates with modern discussions of voice, identity, and the shaping of the literary canon.
The Authoress of the Odyssey remains a remarkable example of how classical texts can be reinterpreted across centuries. Whether one agrees with Butler's conclusions or not, the work challenges readers to approach ancient literature with fresh questions and an openness to perspectives that disrupt inherited assumptions. It stands as both an important moment in the history of Homeric criticism and as a bold literary artifact in its own right.
In its mixture of scholarship, imagination, and intellectual audacity, Butler's book exemplifies the restless spirit of Victorian inquiry, unwilling to accept authority without scrutiny and eager to push the boundaries of established thought. For students of classical literature, feminist criticism, and the history of ideas, it offers a compelling case study of how literature can be reimagined through the lens of gender, geography, and cultural identity.
At the heart of Butler's thesis is the observation that the Odyssey presents a markedly different sensibility from the Iliad. Where the latter emphasizes martial valor, the clash of heroes, and the grandeur of war, the Odyssey centers on domestic life, family bonds, household management, and the subtle intelligence of figures such as Penelope, Nausicaa, and Odysseus himself in moments of wit and restraint. Butler argues that the epic's acute attention to feminine concerns—hospitality, courtship, fidelity, and emotional nuance—suggests not merely an audience of women but an author intimately familiar with women's lives and perspectives.
Equally significant is Butler's geographical analysis. He identifies the settings of the Odyssey not as vague mythical constructs but as rooted in the landscape of Sicily, particularly around Trapani. He builds his case on detailed topographical correspondences, asserting that only a writer native to the area could have so vividly described the coastlines, harbors, and cultural milieu. For Butler, this geographical precision becomes a cornerstone in identifying the possible origin of the poem and its authoress.
Butler's argument also delves into narrative style. He highlights the contrasts between the sprawling, violent grandeur of the Iliad and the more intimate, carefully plotted storytelling of the Odyssey. The structure of the Odyssey, with its complex weaving of tales, interest in hospitality scenes, and recurrent themes of fidelity and temptation, reveals, in Butler's reading, a distinctly feminine literary imagination. This perspective, though controversial, forces readers to reconsider long-accepted categories of authorship, authority, and the construction of literary tradition.
The book is not merely a dry treatise but a lively and engaging work of criticism. Butler writes with wit, conviction, and a flair for provocation, qualities that made his scholarship both admired and contested. His prose, at once incisive and accessible, engages not only the scholar of Greek literature but also the curious reader interested in the dynamics of authorship, gender, and cultural history. His thesis, while unconventional, resonates with modern discussions of voice, identity, and the shaping of the literary canon.
The Authoress of the Odyssey remains a remarkable example of how classical texts can be reinterpreted across centuries. Whether one agrees with Butler's conclusions or not, the work challenges readers to approach ancient literature with fresh questions and an openness to perspectives that disrupt inherited assumptions. It stands as both an important moment in the history of Homeric criticism and as a bold literary artifact in its own right.
In its mixture of scholarship, imagination, and intellectual audacity, Butler's book exemplifies the restless spirit of Victorian inquiry, unwilling to accept authority without scrutiny and eager to push the boundaries of established thought. For students of classical literature, feminist criticism, and the history of ideas, it offers a compelling case study of how literature can be reimagined through the lens of gender, geography, and cultural identity.
4.99
In Stock
5
1
The Authoress of the Odyssey
The Authoress of the Odyssey
Related collections and offers
4.99
In Stock
Product Details
| BN ID: | 2940184392110 |
|---|---|
| Publisher: | Samuel Butler |
| Publication date: | 08/27/2025 |
| Sold by: | Barnes & Noble |
| Format: | eBook |
| File size: | 1 MB |
About the Author
From the B&N Reads Blog