Too Many Choices 1 is a young adult novel and first in a series, filled with the comedy and drama of a high school turned upside down by the Choice quadruplets. Separately, Chad, Robbie, Marcie, and Margie are all-state in their sports, but together, the Choice quads are serious competitors in several sports, especially to returning varsity football players, like the quarterback Brad and his all-county receiver, Bruce. As the senior football players scramble to keep their spots on the team, they learn that their new varsity coach, Coach Choice, plays no favorites.
To intensify strained relationships, love interests develop around Brad and Marcie and Bruce and Margie, earning the disapproval of Chad and Robbie Choice and alienating ex-girlfriends. Tensions run high at Timber Lake High School.