Major Disappointment
While I usually enjoy (not love, but enjoy) Tom Clancy's novels, TB&D is by far the worst I have read. I can go on for hours why I don't like it, but I'll try to keep it to the basics.
First of all, the books drips with racism. There is a fine line between being politically incorrect and being offensive, and this book leaps over it. Chinese people are constantly referred to with harsh racial terms ("slant eyed" among others), their culture and behavior is attacked and smeared, not only by all the Americans and Russians, but in the general writing. Chinese leadership is portrayed as near comically incompetant and arrogant.
The plot is terrible. The whole premise is unrealistic. Why would China, arguably Russia's most valuable military and economic parter, invade their ally out of the clear blue? The plot drags on and on, with unneccessary subplots and ramblings, the "war" doesnt even start untill the last 200 or so pages in the 1000+ page book, and there is absolutely no suspense or danger to the Americans. They blow the Chinese away with less than half a dozen casualties with artillery and jets. The whole cause of the war is rediculous. Chinese officers shoot dead an innocent Vatican ambassador trying to stop an innocent family from having a forced abortion (In front of a CNN news team!!). Being ever-so-good christians, the entire world is outraged and China's economy suffers. The Politburo hatches a brilliant plan to invade Russia and seize it's oil. Clancy also intrigues us with detailed troop movements and logistics, but starts and finishes the final battle in a single sentence! There is also a commando raid by Rainbow and Spetsnaz forces on a nuke facility (which is rendered unguarded by a single airstrike) which results in the launch of an ICBM at Washington DC. The invincible Americans suffer 0 losses in this raid while the Spetsnaze are virtually wiped out by themselves as they use hand grenades to take out missile silos. A conveniently present US navy ship shoots the nuke down with it's last anti-missile weapon. The ending in China is laughably implausable.
Ruined Characters. People that have been present in almost every Clancy novel before have been reduced to children in this book. Ryan is an unlikable racist crybaby who constantly moans and whines about how much he hates being president (after being in office for a full term!) and is impulsive. Stilted dialogue, and constantly repeated lame one-liners are abundant. Everyone on the American side is a noble angel, while all the Chinese are devious and eeevil. Women are faitrhful wives, the Russians love Americans, the American public are all Regan Conservatives, and the Chinese youth take their anger out on their own government when the Americans bomb their country.
Bad writing. There are tons of typos and repeated themes/conversations)
Innacurate. From what I've heard, much of his descriptions of China and it's culture are WRONG. The Chinese military (The PLA) is hopelessly underestimated. They are portrayed as third world level dummys that are basically cannon fodder for the good guys. I know this was written 10 years ago, but in recent years, the PLA had been upgrading like mad with modern tanks, jets, ships, and weapons, they could surely put up a far stronger fight than portrayed.
Politics. Clancy constantly crams his political views down your throat, and characters are puppets for his POV.
Overall, this is just a low point in
0 out of 4 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback.
Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.