Not One of Her Best
This new installment of the Black Jewels saga was something I was looking forward to, so i didn't pay too much attention to the critics reviews about it, wanting to judge for myself. Unfortunately, I'd have to agree with them this once. The strongest story in the whole quartet was Kaeleer's Heart, since the characters seemed to interact with each other the most belivably. The thing that disturbed me the most about this book was the way most of the people in it, who are supposedly thousand of year old adults seemed at times to behave with the restraint and decorum of teenagers and two-year-olds. The Warlord Princes--Lucivar, Daemon, Saetan, who are supposed to be good guys, seem to look at killing or violence as a solution to everything. Someone pisses them off, they kill them. This is not only a disturbing concept, it's a sickness. Normal people do not, should not behave that way. And whatever happened to the creed with great power comes great responisiblity? that simply because you CAN do something doesn't mean you SHOULD. Apparently Bishop's characters have never been taught this, since all of her males seem to think it's okay to react violently whenever something goes wrong. And the cliched line--of the 'savage' beast nature of a Warlord Prince doesn't ring true here. Animals aren't savage--WE are. If you've ever observed predators int he wild, such as wolves, dominance fights 9 times out of 10 DO NOT end in death--both challenged and challenger walk away. The idea that a warlord Prince's response to a rival was to kill him is insane and irrational. Come on, if a person were that unbalanced emotionally, he should be locked away somewhere. I also found the response of Saetan to the Zuuliman killing his son to be the reaction of a madman--I'm sorry but the death of one person is NOT and never should be an excuse for the genocide of an entire people. And he didn't even show remorse for killing all of those innocent people! And THIS is a good guy? I don't think so! Whatever happened to being better than those you fight? And if Sae6tan is so powerful, surely he could have used his powers to discover who was really behind his son's death, instead of lashing out like an enraged toddler and killing everyone. That to me is the act of a monster, not a hero. I don't think Bishop gives her characters any room to grow and act like normal adults and human beings here. You can't have a man be both a gentle, sweet person and a killing machine--unless they're bipolar. You sure as hell don't want that same person in charge of a country. That i think, has always been the flaw in this series, the characters are way too violent and some of them are fixated on sex, even though they claim not to be. I felt that these stories could have been done much much better. The only parts I felt were well done were the spider story and some of the scenes between Daemon and Janelle. The Lucivar story had the potential to be really good, but was spoiled by the shallowness of the main characters and the fact that they wouldn't talk to each other about how they felt, which is essential in any good relationship.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback.
Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.