More of the Same--Unfortunately
The setting of this story is undeniably interesting. The artifact of the ringworld (take a piece of old orange Hot Wheels track and make it into a loop, then expand its size to match the path taken by the Earth orbiting the sun the dimensions are roughly equivalent) is a fantastic fictional creation critics of such artifacts in SF refer to them as BDO's--Big Dumb Objects--but, as he proudly declares in the introduction, Niven's was the first. Critics of the plausibility (read: stability) of such an object drove Niven to write a sequal ten years later this was basically a rewrite of the first book, in which he vouchsafes the characters (and through them the readers) some explanations to justify the ringworld's existence. About fifteen years after that he comes out with another book (really two short novels grafted together) that was all right if, you want to read stories about vampires in an alien setting or traders in a bartering culture sealing the deal with sex. Now ten years after that we get yet another adventure set on the ringworld. The characters somehow manage to be interesting, if one-dimensional for the most part. The story has some okay moments, some good moments, a couple of really good moments, and quite a few very bad moments. There's a sense that when Mr. Niven reaches a crisis point in handling a character he takes the easy way out (kill him or her.) The Kzin, Acolyte, gets moved offstage and is forgotten about [anyone who's read 'Gods of Riverworld' by Philip Jose Farmer, knows that he did the same thing to the character of Nur--just forgot to mention his status (alive, dead, present, missing)--at the end of that book]. The book has some virtues: the focus of the plot on the history, condition, and future of the ringworld the action involving the galactic forces poised to invade and exploit the ring for its resources, the story of Louis Wu (the one constant character of the series) finding his destiny by becoming the protector of the ringworld. But the road is rocky, to say the least when one of the major plot turns relies on a total coincidence occurring (one character, who has no knowledge of another character's presence, being at a precise location on the millions of square miles of surface area that comprise the ring) I don't care how you try to justify it (Niven does by saying that the character inherited his mother's propensity for good luck--now try writing that thought literally: Luckily he was at the one spot, out of the millions of square miles of land on the ringworld, where the invaders punched a hole through the surface after they saved him from being sucked out the hole, they transported him to the spot where he met other characters and advanced the plot. This, of course, is Niven's way of trying to justify the existence of that earlier character (Teela Brown) the fact that key elements of the plot in the first two books were dictated by her natural luckiness didn't sit well with critics...and why should it? Chance encounters are the kind of garbage they peddle on soap operas, not in the pages of quality fiction. If you are a fan of this series then I say this is the best book since book 1 but it still isn't that good.
1 out of 2 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback.
Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.